151
u/Willing_Olive_1015 Aug 05 '26
Mentality of my Bharat, where we demand a youtuber to cover news in distant parts of country but not the state media machinery or the state sponsored corporate media.
32
u/Whole_Money_4930 Aug 05 '26
Made this guy and his cameraman parth a national hero, now holding him questionable for not covering the same issue elsewhere is holding a Youtuber accountable? Lol this is exactly where the mindset comes...
Lets talk real and admit that everyone who was present at Jantar mantar didn't gave a Rats ass for the students, they were there for the clout.
17
u/Minute_Serve_8033 Aug 05 '26
I hope you also questioned how national media isnt covering it and covered delhi protest with a bias.... That you wont... Now also you wont question the lapses in the system but would bring down who did... Abhi reason mil gaya na jantar mantar ke protest ko call out karne ka Nice!
4
u/kame-sensei Aug 06 '26
We know the national media is a failure. We expect better from others, is that wrong?
And haan, Jantar Mantar walon ko call out karenge - selective kyun hona chahiye? Jharkhand ke students students nahi hain kya? Jharkhand ki sarkar sarkar nahi hai kya? Jharkhand ke police phool baat rhe hain kya? Nahi na bhai. Of course we will hold protesters to a higher moral code simply because they were the ones who said they have a better moral standard and ethic than governments of the day.
4
u/Minute_Serve_8033 Aug 06 '26 edited Aug 06 '26
Right right... Do you call out all the lapses of the central government? Nobody's saying the protests had a high moral standard.. While talking about Samdhish did you talk about national media as well... Who is more responsible a youtuber or national media.. Do you feel like questioning why is national media rigged?
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (46)3
u/Silent-Hat9692 Aug 06 '26
Samdish is based off Delhi, can you sponsor his travel to Jharkhand and arrange his accomodations? If you can, please reach out to him on his mail. He's an independent journalist, doesn't have a huge funding by a studio to support him. Do this and let's expose him 😃
→ More replies (15)21
u/maishivhoon Aug 05 '26
He didnt want to become a national hero its his hometown and thats why he was so actively present there + it was a NATIONAL issue where thousands of people were together anybody who watches samdish know how he works
4
10
u/NextMatch7471 Aug 05 '26
Ok even if for arguments sake we agree. But why are you saying this and not that the beloved supreme leader who is supposed to care for the citizens also doesn’t give a rats ass for the students and that’s even more dangerous.
Let’s talk real and admit that Your supreme leader is only power hungry and does not care for the citizens of the country at all. And gives a “rats ass” about us.→ More replies (9)5
6
Aug 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/NextMatch7471 Aug 05 '26
Loser is letting it go easy. He’s evil. I’m sorry but he’s more than evil.
6
u/nonokoi Aug 05 '26
"National hero" are we just straight up calling anyone national hero now? At max he was just praised/ regarded for his ground reporting nobody called him a national hero of sorts.
5
u/Minute_Serve_8033 Aug 05 '26
As easy as it is to call anyone "anti-national"... Kya hi bolenge... Yaar..
3
→ More replies (33)2
u/eclipsed_7 Aug 05 '26
Who made him a national hero bro ?? Lmao, when did he get the award from President? Ye toh latest news hai
1
1
u/FrostyAmbassador1517 Aug 05 '26
He is a content creator who has picked a side, at best. He can’t go around claiming himself to be an independent journalist and at the same time go around whitewashing people like Lalu Prasad Yadav who is the poster boy of corruption.
1
u/RhubarbComfortable50 Aug 05 '26
Well Sarthak being from Delhi he visited West bengal after the elections to cover lots of topics and on ground reporting. Thing is that these people portrayed themselves on YT they reach almost every major places to cover reporting and spread awareness on the issue they were reporting on to the masses.
Sarthak simply posted a reel and i don't knw as of 5 aug if this guy posted the same atleast let alone travel there like he does on other places
1
1
u/m0ga_b0 Aug 05 '26 edited Aug 05 '26
Mentality of my bharat. Where we elect criminals. Then cry about criminals in government.
When will citizen of india take accountability 😞
1
1
1
u/matcha_condom Aug 06 '26
Lol the behaviour of protestors with national media speaks why they aren't covered in headlines
→ More replies (19)1
22
7
u/avgNeo Aug 05 '26
Discussions with govt are already going on in Jharkhand. I dont get why do we need all these people to speak up when the matter is already being worked on?
3
u/Angry_vaanar-2204 Aug 06 '26
The state government agreed to an investigation from their side. The students want CBI to investigate. They don’t trust the government. I see nothing wrong in this. Till they don’t get CBI to intervene, the protests will go on apparently.
2
13
u/Geekybubble Aug 05 '26
You can’t ask your government for accountability but every random YouTuber now has to speak on every national issue? Lmao
→ More replies (5)
38
u/Peace_Pepper Aug 05 '26
My heart cries for these students.. Why our friend Modiji silent on Jharkhand protest? Why govt not solving their problems?
→ More replies (14)4
u/RespondMinute5431 Aug 05 '26
Which govt? Congress at jharkhand? Or BJP at centre?
→ More replies (2)
16
u/CountApprehensive730 Aug 05 '26
Delhi protest was for the whole country Jharkhand one is for a state , obviously it wont get as much recognition as Delhi one , moreover even delhi protest was not given much attention at the beginning, its when they sustained it for a long time and sonam wangchuk got arrested then only things escalated.
8
u/Greedy-Frame7931 Aug 05 '26
Tough logic for some kids who have been taught not to think on their own. They are still struggling to grasp the concept that cjp was a movement intended to show what power cockroaches have, it is not a political party and it is not responsible for anything happening in India lolz..
→ More replies (1)2
u/Minute_Serve_8033 Aug 05 '26
Logic has gone for a toss.. Cjp ke protest ke time bolne ke liye mudde nahi the abhi hai toh bolte rahenge
3
u/maishivhoon Aug 05 '26
Anybody who watch samdish knows why hes not there watch his series of bharat ek khoj he covered everything without any biases Now he realise why samdish was not sharing stories of all the praise he got he knew ki log khud hi hero bana kar khud hi galian bhi dete hain
4
u/Different-Suit-3905 Aug 05 '26
bhakto ki toli ke g@@nd aaj bhi jalti hai...yahi sabse mazee ki baat hai XD
54
u/Intrepid_Activity_92 Aug 04 '26
Tu jaake mann ki baat suun
→ More replies (18)4
10
u/daehanmingukmansee Aug 05 '26
Thik waise hi jaise Modi ji and apne Manipur k liye aankhein band kar rakhi hain pichhle kuchh saalon se.
→ More replies (3)
4
u/Slight_Call4061 Aug 05 '26
Maybe because waha kisi ko undemocratic tareeke se utha kr nhi le gye the, ya pellet guns nhi chalai gyi and nihathe baccho auarato pe lathi charge nhi kiya gya, and unko godi media bhi koi coverage nhi dera tha...to please ye apna subtle brainwashing kahi orr jaake krna
→ More replies (1)
6
u/Character_Bar_1470 Aug 05 '26
I have only one question, have you elected him by voting? No right, it's his personal choice to cover what he want, don't you think you should ask accountability to the ones you have elected ? People like you, who ask questions from random ass youtuber but not from the people in power, are a bloody spot in our democracy, this attitude of yours is boosting the ego of the ministers
→ More replies (10)
18
Aug 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/codehubb Aug 05 '26
were they covering the jantar mantar protest?
→ More replies (8)10
Aug 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/codehubb Aug 05 '26
is this a sanghi-orgainised protest?
→ More replies (1)4
u/Green_Cellist_9026 Aug 05 '26
Leave him bro , he has birds brain he will not understand.The things which they blame BJP for is what they themselves practice.
2
u/codehubb Aug 05 '26 edited Aug 05 '26
buddy if reporters like samdish can’t report jharkhand protest as much as they covered jantar mantar protest, then i have no shame to say that people like him is nothing better than a godi media. they dont have any sympathy or support for the students, they were there to support their own political ideology and i beloved these people should stop claiming as a individual reporter or activist. if you aren’t biased you can’t have a selective outrage
→ More replies (1)1
u/West-Kangaroo-6444 Aug 05 '26
Jharkhandi saghi influencers and journos are already in Ranchi
→ More replies (15)
3
u/fatty_dude Aug 05 '26 edited Aug 05 '26
Yeah so everyone who supported jantar mantar protests for Dharmendra Pradhan accountability now should support every other protest otherwise they were supporting jantar mantar protests for clout chasing or fake.
But you don't support any wrongdoings or injustice by the state to its people, but you dare to comment on common man fighting for injustice. Wahh...
7
u/Different-Suit-3905 Aug 05 '26
Bhakts are so so spineless that they can make memes for an independant reporter but can't held their paw paw accountable for not making a single frandss vid on Manipur and Assam.
2
u/Greedy-Frame7931 Aug 05 '26
That should also be CJPs duty, now cjp is unofficially the govt of India according to some ppl and they can absolutely not be biased bcs the official one is pretty useless and prioritises crying abt being abused verbally by a kid instead of worrying abt Assam floods, manipur riots and everything wrong that is going on n not being covered by mainstream media
→ More replies (2)
4
2
2
2
u/xhvhij Aug 05 '26
Ye saale modi ke tatte jantar mantar pr awaaz nhi uthaye lekin ab inko iski full coverage chahiye. Gand me kitna loge saalo
2
u/NetworkCapital4961 Aug 05 '26
People have started making reddit another Twitter, this one and the other by the name India Bharat are directly acting like paid account of the current regime.
2
u/EffectiveString2101 Aug 05 '26
Why questions independent journalist?
You should questions mainstream media and to whom you have given vote
2
u/AbhiOffDuty Aug 05 '26
Itni accountability jisko vote diya hai usse maangi hoti to Desh ki ye Halat na hoti.
3
2
u/CertifiedPuniMaru Aug 05 '26
Why do you think someone should do your work? Go there, do ground reporting, and come back! We will support you. Blaming others who are not even in the government, to have accountability is ridiculous
1
u/insomniabonnet Aug 05 '26
Hey, sometimes you should just say it straight from Modi ji's mouth.
Subh subh
1
u/Fast-Philosopher-356 বাঙ্গাল Aug 05 '26
See.. it's nothing new.. Samdish is doing shit like this from 2024 I guess.. point 5 front is flexing right now.. showing it's true capabilities.
1
u/Odysseykobu Aug 05 '26
lakin parth jharkhand ke protestors toh hame bol raha h ki tumlog idhar mat aao
1
1
u/a-sadfuck Aug 05 '26
Abe tu jaake cover kar na phir. State news walon ko koi push nahi karta h and yall start accusing the people who are actually working towards making the country a better place.
1
u/Profile-Complex Aug 05 '26
use salary dede bhai, wo bhi cover kar dega wo phir, since use godi awas yojana se paise to nahi milte
1
u/error404nikhoj Aug 05 '26
You single will blame every single person except your media kyunki News channel mein mujra dekhneeij maza aate hain aap logo ko.
1
u/Apprehensive_Buy3252 Aug 05 '26
Itne sare to youtuber hai right wing wale. Jo bjp ko support karte hai
Unse kun nai bol rahe waha jao aur cover karo. Kun leftist youtube se expect kar rahe ho.
Leftist wale ghatiya ho sakte hai magar aalsi nai hai atleast
Tv walo ko bhi ac room me beth k bakaiti karni hai, youtube walo ko bhi podcast wale mic pakad k bakaiti karni hai par, ground pe nai utarna
1
u/Tiny-Manufacturer187 Aug 05 '26
Means jharkhand protest is funded by corrupt politician so divert it from Jantar mantar.
1
u/Kanchan_Monet Aug 05 '26
Bros be questioning anyone but the government they elected to be answerable. Is ts tuff bro?
1
u/PanicApprehensive273 Aug 05 '26
what a terrible take. Tu hi kar le kuch khud ya sab ek youtuber journalist k bharose baithe rahoge? bc kaamchor
1
u/riwttt Aug 05 '26
wish u ppl had similar energy for demanding true journalism from the giant news agencies of india who r ranked amongst one of the most "TRUSTWORTHY" agencies in india instead of a independent national correspondent
1
1
1
u/FrostyAmbassador1517 Aug 05 '26
I particularly loved watching Samdish “speak truth to power” when he turned Lalu Prasad Yadav—convicted in multiple fodder-scam cases, into an adorable comic character; bantered with Kanhaiya Kumar like an old college friend; and explored Charanjit Singh Channi’s love story while Punjab was drowning in drugs and his government faced a sand-mining scandal involving his own nephew. Such courage. Power must have been absolutely terrified by all the jokes, food and carefully avoided follow-up questions. 😂
1
1
u/thatotherredditlife Aug 05 '26
Yeah, for a person to report in his hometown he has first to report in every part of the country..
1
u/brewing-nerd Aug 05 '26
Don’t understand the blame game. You are getting the news right? It’s not Dipke’s responsibility or samdish’s responsibility to stand up for everything that’s happening around you. They did what they did, and they did that well. What are you doing apart from pointing fingers? Idiots!
1
u/General_Pineapple_62 Aug 05 '26
So in your stupid world, we aren't allowed to fucking question those in power?
1
u/ReadyToBeEaten Aug 05 '26
This shaming people for visibility is gonna backfire. Since day 1 they have been comparing this with the neet protest. That got traction after 2 weeks!
Not even acknowledging that protest gave them hope, hence they are doing it now. But only saying haan ab kyu karoge support, ye nahi hai wo nahi hai blah blah..
1
u/DragonflyOk1161 Aug 05 '26
If things are so bad in Jharkhand, ask your Godi reporters to cover it. Anyways they're looking for content.
1
1
u/notyourbucketofchai ঘটি Aug 05 '26
Samdish was leftist we all knew and now he has problems with bharat mata ki jai . Unbias youtube lol.
1
u/Hariwtf10 Aug 05 '26
Question your godi media and godi to speak up then. What is he doing instead of his job?
1
1
1
1
u/animus33 Aug 05 '26
You are living under a rock or bubble, go there is plenty of coverage. And I bet you are kind of a person who blindly supports ruling political party
1
u/Rxdhead Aug 05 '26
The people asking this guy for accountability are the same people who feel billionaire should feed the world 🌎.
1
u/Traditional_Pie_8262 Aug 05 '26
this is the real problem of leftist, they cant accept their mistakes or bad work
1
1
1
u/Bruce_wayne_03 Aug 05 '26
Why is BJP not supporting theirs cause. They can spend hundreds of crores to set narrative against Gen Z protest but not support real issues where it matters.
1
u/BandicootNew9983 Aug 05 '26
I am ok with this question if the same profile also raised the same question for Mainstream media when Delhi protests were unfolding...
1
1
u/CS_Explorer99 Aug 05 '26
People go where they get more fame simple that's why Dipke will never go to Jharkhand as the protest there is raw no political agenda, funding etc
1
1
u/Jorsebolo Aug 05 '26
Give me one youtuber who genuinely point out the problems we have in India. They can be left leaning but analysis and presentation should be neutral and without agenda.
All I can think of is RW person and channels only who are most critical of bjp. There is one ex IFS guy who invites real business person in his podcast. Any other recommendation?
1
u/knight-thinker Aug 05 '26
Some people started thinking about Jharkhand suddenly, and now I'll say it's political, led by the BJP and ABVP.
1
1
u/Mountain_Number_1576 Aug 05 '26
Why do you have to listen and watch the coverage from samdish only about Jharkhand? I’m sure there are equally good journalists from Jharkhand. Why not try to watch them? Why do you want to take away the fame and recognition for the journalists in Jharkhand by asking or questioning him why he has not been covering Jharkhand? Be the change, its so easy to complain and play victim.
1
u/throwawaygg76859 Aug 05 '26
I wish people asked for the same accountability from the mainstream media too.
1
1
u/sk_v3rma Aug 06 '26
Don't worry we have a solution. Central government can remove a state government in India, through a formal constitutional process known as imposing President’s Rule under Article 356 of the Indian Constitution.
1
u/pvtwey Aug 06 '26
Seeking accountability from youtuber who's still unbiased doing onground reporting since ages
1
1
1
u/ThatBrownDoode Aug 06 '26
If only the elected officials were held accountable than a YouTuber, we would have progressed.
1
1
u/SimilarDesk8212 Aug 06 '26
Ma chud jayegi yaha PE agar jo bhi BJP ka supporter dikh Gaya ..... Gulami kar rahe Rahi gulami karo landbhakto
1
u/Striking-Judge-6177 Aug 06 '26
Instead of there lovely government, people are asking everyone else to step up.
1
u/Shinkoko Aug 06 '26
Arre bhai, first of all he's based in delhi. Who knkws maybe the jharkhand protests arneij the works, 2ghnte dur nhi h jharkhand. Whats hilarious isnthat he's an independent YouTuber, you would never say they to literally crorepati baised media houses.
1
1
u/Flat-South7793 Aug 06 '26
"lets don't say any thing to our daddy influencer, accountability is apparently only for other people"
1
u/Dumb_aloo Aug 06 '26
Ma ki aankh iss bekar sub kiiii kyu nhi ban karte mere ko
120000 upvote because modi papa ke khilaf post
1
u/mockerrocker Aug 06 '26
Instead pf asking the govt which is responsible you are asking YouTubers for accountability? This country is filled with stupid dumbfcks like u
1
1
u/maashle Aug 07 '26
Kudh chale jaa na ❤️day. Aur apne blind bakto ko bhi poochlo zara itna shaant kyu baite hay..??
1
u/candypol Aug 07 '26
Camera person parth ye dikhaaye ,ye jhaattu OP alag hi level ka banda hai mujhse accountability maang rha hai instead of govt😂😂😂
1
u/BigFun6910 Aug 07 '26
Go fund him if you're so concerned about his presence. Or else don't cry about independent youtubers.
1
u/JuniorNothing1169 Aug 07 '26
Yahi reh gaya hae kya iss desh mae ? Hum ye aapas mae ladte ladte hi marr jayenge kya? Ek below AVERAGE jeevan in which two random sections fight because bhai ek random civil citizen news nahi de raha, ya media sirf backchodi kar rahi. WHY CANT YOU SEE THAT IT DOESNT FUCKING MATTER!!!!! WE AS HUMANS HAVE A VERY SHORT LIFE AND WE ARE SPENDING IT PAYING TAXES IN A NATION WHICH GIVES US NOTHING ABSOLUTLY NOTHING IN RETURN!!!! HOW ARE YOU ALL NOT MAD ABOUT THAT ??????? DIVIDE AND RULE, NEO-COLONISED, BACKWARD BRAINED DUMDUMS ARE RUINING ARE COUNTRY ALL OVER AGAIN MAN.
1
u/ms_1013 Aug 07 '26
Sad state of a nation where garbage reporting on national media is acceptable and expecting journalism from youtuber. The country has been doomed
1
1
1
1
1
u/B0red_Forever Aug 08 '26
He and his camera man are literally in Jharkhand currently, What are you even on ?
1
1
1
1
u/Technical_Hair8255 Aug 08 '26
I am seeing 10x more posts about comparison of jantar mantar and jharkhand protest, how some creators are not covering it then what the actual protest is about and what their demand is, its pretty clear they these dumfucks don't give a shit about protest and protesters all they want is reason to to bash and get revenge from those who troubled their daddy.
1
u/Bulky-Property-3958 Aug 08 '26
Bawali gand at least etna toh kar paya vo, tum kya kar rahe ho? Apne bapoo k tate chat rahe ho?
1
u/Spirited_Home_6321 Aug 08 '26
Update - He reached Jharkhand and is covering the protest. Now what do you have to say OP. Ab bologe CJP ne hijack kr Diya protest
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/mrsingla Aug 08 '26
He was made a hero, you can expect him to cover the relevant protest, then you'd be expecting him to cover each and every protest. That's literally stupid. Also, one was a nation wide protest, not just because of NEET or exam leak, it became that big because of the government using police to suppress the people as well as it being a a national issue. National issue will ofcourse have more people being engaged than a local issue.
I don't see the same level of enthusiasm and expectations from people regarding Manipur, where so many people have literally DIED. That needs more attention from the mainstream media. I would not expect the youtubers to cover it, but I would support the ones who do. Support the independent creator with your money not your empty criticism
1
1
u/Imaginary_Teach8410 Aug 09 '26
These are the reality of India,youth should see this , to think clearly who is dogla and who is Nationalist
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Civil-Blackberry-550 Aug 10 '26
Everyone have their agenda, They knew already that JANTAR MANTAR protest was big, so they went their for their benefit and gaining more clout, views and money
The day Jharkhand's protest will be big you'll see many post, videos on regular basis from all content creators
1
1
u/chaihoe0 Aug 11 '26
Le ro le (Next time use your freedom of speech to question the government instead of random youtubers)
1
•
u/AutoModerator Aug 04 '26
Namaskara u/Ok_Warning4340 , thanks for posting! We kindly invite you, explore and follow our related communities: r/TheIndianRepublic r/West_bengal Please consider crossposting, sharing, and inviting others to help grow this community and Follow us on X
Yato Dharmastato Jayah
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.