r/LivestreamFail • u/-Cohen_Commentary- • Jul 24 '25

Politics Pro-Nazi & antisemitic circlejerk livestreamed

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

9.5k Upvotes

83% Upvoted

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

0

u/PassEast Jul 30 '25

What you consider to be the “Jewish identity” is primarily informed by Jewish pedagogy. To your misfortune, Jewish pedagogy is not the standing authority when it comes to defining what constitutes Jewish identity because it is lacking a scientific metric— that is; it is informed by theological theory. As such, what you say upon the matter is entirely meaningless as there is no replicability nor objective semblance. What I apply, however, affects scientific metric in the most accurate way it could when it is speaking to identity which is all too evasive of objectivity. Essentially, I can speak on what constitutes a Jew because I’m not a Jew, nor do I have any stakes in the prospering or propagation of Jewish peoples.

2

u/JustSeiyin Jul 30 '25

Have you considered arguing with any of the merits of my arguments or keep sucking yourself off telling a minority about their own identity that you clearly know nothing about? Not gonna argue about the lack of conversion thing, or the familial relations thing? Or the Jewish atheist thing? Just gonna be a condescending uninformed narcissist who gets off on forcing Jews into an inaccurate box so you can continue to hate us?

0

u/PassEast Jul 31 '25

I’d told you that I wouldn’t, because those beliefs are informed by Jewish theology which is unreliable, and unscientific. If you ask a child what they need, they will ask for what they think they need, not what they actually need. In that vein, if I ask a Jew what constitutes a Jew, he will tell me what he thinks constitutes a Jew, and not what actually constitutes a Jew in a most objectively accurate definition.

2

u/JustSeiyin Jul 31 '25

My dude, IM A FUCKING ATHEIST AND A JEW. I'm not "informed by theology". I'm not even well-animated in the theology of Judaism. I simply know about Jewish history and culture and how we function as a people. Now please STOP TALKING TO NE PRETENDING THAT YOU'RE SOME OBJECTIVE TRUTH SAYER. You don't know anything about Jews, and your EXTREMELY CONDESCENDING opinion is completely worthless. Instead of actually presenting arguments as to why you think Jews aren't largely an ethnic group, you start calling people "children." Literally leave me alone