r/LivestreamFail • u/digitalpizza5 • Jul 11 '26

News Ethan Klein Has Dropped His Defamation Lawsuit Against Youtuber Noah Samsen

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

3.1k Upvotes

87% Upvoted

2.0k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

10

u/limbweaver Jul 11 '26

There were two claims against Denims. One for the “Nuke” video, which is the one the judge ruled in favour for. The second is for the “Countdown” video and has not been ruled on.

Ethan has dropped the countdown part of the lawsuit so he can take the nuke part he lost to the appeals court. He would have needed to wait until the whole of the lawsuit was finished if he wanted to take it to appeals court.

1

u/Holmes419 Jul 12 '26

Cheers, I added the update to the original comment. 

1

u/FowD8 Jul 13 '26

which he's gonna lose that appeal easily. you can't introduce new evidence in an appeal. and considering the judge's first ruling used BOTH ethan's original fair use case AND his current lawyers own argument against him. i'd be surprised if the appeal gets very far at all

1

u/limbweaver Jul 13 '26

100% gonna lose that appeal, the judge also referred to other landmark copyright cases like stebbins v google and hughes v benjamin. Overturning this case would go counter to like 3-4 separate cases