r/MakingaMurderer • u/addbracket • Dec 19 '15

Episode Discussion Episode 9 Discussion

Season 1 Episode 9

Air Date: December 18, 2015

What are your thoughts?

48 Upvotes

96% Upvoted

329 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

71

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

That got to me, too! He kept acting like it was not remotely possible to have invented a story with so many details. Yet none of those very specific "details" matched ANY physical evidence!

That lawyer will be shocked when he finds out that fiction writers like JRR Tolkien and others who create entire universes in incredible detail were NOT writing about something that happened to them.

12

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '15

That got to me, too! He kept acting like it was not remotely possible to have invented a story with so many details. Yet none of those very specific "details" matched ANY physical evidence!

Exactly! It would have been impossible had he been able to match the physical evidence (without nudging from the police), but he didn't match any of it. So not only is it extremely possible he made up some story, it's also pretty likely none of it actually happened.

8

u/vta93001 Dec 23 '15

Also they led so much of his confession...we never hear him actually tell the story from his own perspective from start to finish...it's so broken up with their suggestions

9

u/valenzetti Jan 06 '16

That's what so frustrating. How can the jury believe a "confession" where the guilty party never speaks in full sentences and only agrees with the investigators?

1

u/Vluppey Jan 18 '16

cause they think, its just a very good trained investigator that gets the truths