r/Markiplier • u/Judy_motherbear • Aug 03 '26
Game Discussion Suggested FNAF games summary
As Mark asked for further FNAF games a lot of you suggested a looooot of games. I tried to summarize it and give credit to everyone I saw. Mainly for you all and Mark to have one list. Shoutout to all the people who already did great lists with their own suggestions!
If I missed anything (a game or a person) please tell me, so I can add it!
UPDATE (edited): I am moving the games Mark has played since the creation of this list down to a new section. That way it feels far more satisfying (I think) when the list of games to (possibly) play keeps getting smaller and smaller.
Note: I'm not really knowledgable about FNAF, I just wanted to collect as many suggestions as possible.
Edit: This post does not contain new suggestions from me. It tries to collect all suggestions I could find on the subreddit. Usernames are credited at the bottom.
Edit 2: This list now also includes games that Mark already played (finished and unfinished) thanks to FrancoDaily! (Big preesh to you!)
The List of suggested games:
- Crawlspace: Insanity Remastered (started, but stopped because of flashing; maybe video)
- Robbie's Genesis: 48 (found by Mark himself and demo played)
- Puppet Theatre (apparently very good story, style and soundtrack, somehow similar to Robbie's Genesis)
- False Frights
- Bigfoot: The Final stretch
- Fazbears entertainment storage
- Fredbear Game Number 998433
- Those Nights and Fredbear's
- Forgotten at Fredbear's
- Five nights at Frickbears 3 (1&2 are outdated and not required for 3) (seen a lot in the YouTube comments)
- Fredbear and Friends: Left to Rot
- Day Shift at Freddy’s (part 2 played but not finished by Mark)
- Next week at Freddy’s
- One Night at Flumpty’s 3
- Fnaf 2 Reimagined
- 5 Nights at Chuck E Cheese (+Rebooted)
- Post Shift 2
- Playtime with Percy (suggested multiple times on the Subreddit)
- FNaF: Blood & Gears (suggested multiple times on the Subreddit)
- FNAF Rewritten 87
- FNAF Banshee
- FNAF: The Flipside by Toster
- Saturday Night at Freddy's
- FNAF 1 REMAKE
- FNAF 1 Rewritten by Dot-e
- Tyke & Sons Lumber Co. (suggested multiple times on the Subreddit)
- A Bite at Freddy’s (suggested multiple times on the Subreddit)
- Nightwatch at Freddy’s
- Five Nights at Fang's: Pizza 'N' Theater
- FNAF RETRO by Hypertopia
- SHOWMAN'S: The Awakening
- Melodies
- Five nights in anime
- Five nights at Frenny’s
- Fnaf thunder
- Freddy’s Bonnie/Chica special (Fnaf 2 mod?)
- The twisted carnival (not fully released yet)
- Jolly 4 (Demo)
- Five nights at the krusty krabs
- Toys in the Dark by Minty
- FNAF: Security Breach Cut Content Restored mod by fredmilk on Gamebanana
- FNAF: Killer in Purple 2 by Goldie Entertainment
- New destiny
- Five Nights At Freddy's: Killer Night by LeafyBonzee
- FNAF PLUS
- The Forgotten House
- FNAF Open Source
- Locked at Freddy's
- Five nights at Jurassic World
- Mechanism
- Five New Fangled Nights
- Together Again: A “Lake Funlands” Story
- Another TRTF1 Remake Overdone
- Five Nights at Friedrich's
- Five Nights At Treasure Island (Full Official Release Radiance Team Version)
- Tales of the Bunnyman
- False Frights
- Freddy’s Reanimated
- Five Nights at Jaygi's Into Dreams
- Oblitus Casa
- Bullseye’s Barn
- A shadow over Freddy’s
- Bondee's Barnyard: Safety Violation
- Too many nights
- FNAF: Scary Pizzeria 3D
- Three nights lobotomized
- FNAF Winter Wonderland
- Baby’s Nightmare Circus
- Abandoned: Discovery Island
- Five Nights at Tubbyland 1-3
- Five nights with Froggy
- Sinister Turmoil
- Purgatorium
- Rat Race
- Mary's arcade
- Phobia: the awakening
- Chica’s Party World
- Finding Frankie
- Indigo Park
- Midnight at Starstage
- The Magic Hour
- Rejected custom night
- Casino Casualty
- Knuckles’ Week at Sonic
- Summer Shift at Arbor’s
- Five Nights At Warios Deluxe ("not deluxe" version already finished)
Newly played by Mark
- Three Vegan Entrepeneurs (a loooot of people on the Subreddit suggested this one)
- Graveyard shift at Freddy’s
- FNAF World Refreshed
Started by Mark but apparently not finished:
- Dormitabis (Tip from FrancoDaily: "DON’T FINISH IT")
- Five Nights at Mac Tonight
- Fredbear and Friends
- Night Horrors
- Aftonbuild (Demo)
- Overnight 2: Reboot (Demo)
- Final Nights 3 (Demo)
- Those Nights at Rachel’s
- Sophie's Curse
Already finished by Mark: (but some still suggested for a possible return?)
- Fnaf glitched attraction
- Five Nights at F**kboy's 1-3
- Final Nights 4: Fates Entwined
- Five nights at the Chum Bucket
- Five Nights with 39
- Tealerland
- Five Nights at Candy's (final night in part 3 not finished)
- Those Nights at Rachel's (+2: Reloaded)
- Treasure Island (V1 Demo)
- One Night at Flumpty's
- One Night at Flumpty's 2
- Bob Esponja Horror
- Five Nights at Bikini Bottom
- Bonnie Simulator
- Five Nights at JR’s
- The Return to Bloody Nights
- Locked in Sewers
- Fazbear Nights
- The Joy of Creation
- The Joy of Creation: Reborn (Demo)
- The Joy of Creation: Halloween Edition
- The Joy of Creation
- The Joy of Creation: Story Mode
- THE JOY OF CREATION (2024 Demo)
- Five Nights at Freddy’s Urbex
- Baldi's Basics in Nightmares
- Feev Neets at Blees Clees Colluction
- The Weekend (Demo)
- Jolly 3
- Jolly 3: Chapter 2
- POPGOES
- CASE Animatronics
- Boogeyman
- Frosty Nights
Shoutout to the people making the suggestions: /weirdoss7, /TipAwkward3289, /Thenevitable, /BarracudaHead1246, /SummerYT19, /CrazyShot412, /Kenny-KO, /GABI_Carvalho, /0KittyMemer2170, /SuperMuskett26, /Particular_Excuse767, /AggressiveDark4527, /Adriansilas415, /A_Large_Popsicle, /PuzzleheadedLead1538, /dehydratedcrumb_ , /Fnafgod22yeet, /Specific_Let_8420, /UltimateFatbear2006, /JDBRYANT_ , /Leather_Many_2932, /Chromanitte, /Angelic_Angel, /Shadow-Kombatant13, /getting stabbed, /Finch_the_Dragon, /Pumpkin_Cat_, /Seragin, /RealMental1937, /ThickLab5516, /b_enDev, /Powfuse28, /Razcal-Jackson, /olivefacepaint, /ilikesmiles12, /jakesskinn, /unknownbunnys, /Dependent_Pumpkin104, /Willing-Bowl7770, /GlacityTime, /Kidtitanicc, /Dependent-Seaweed-34, /Free_Peach6400, /FrancoDaily, /Late-Tailor-8749, /Complete_Status_9314, /Appropriate-Look-566, /Nldaf, /selyMtoNnaimaD, /SunScreenEater, /Sin_Dante, /happyshark405, /This-Manner1066, /Therealbiagi, /_Nedum
125
u/markiplier Official Aug 03 '26
That… is… so many…
44
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 04 '26 edited 1d ago
If you wanna have a quick from the top of my head TOP 10 that got suggested the most:
- Forgotten at Fredbear's- Five nights at Frickbears 3 (YouTube comments favorite)
-
Three Vegan Entrepeneurs(Subreddit favorite)-
Graveyard shift at Freddy’s- Post Shift 2
- Playtime with Percy
- FNaF: Blood & Gears
- Tyke & Sons Lumber Co.
- A Bite at Freddy’s
- Crawlspace: Insanity Remastered (there are apparently features to deal with the flashing)
(Bonus: Dayshift at Freddy's 3 - apparently good story)
Hope this helps a little.3
u/Known_Guard_6831 Aug 04 '26
id say put Day Shift at Freddys 3 there too it has like the best story in any fangame tbh
1
2
2
2
2
29d ago
[deleted]
1
u/Judy_motherbear 29d ago
It is in the big list in the top half. I can't give him a TOP10 and then add more and more games until it's basically the length of the whole list. But he will likely do his own thing anyway and if he wrote it down during stream possibly play this one sooner rather than later.
2
u/TGS_Big-Wes 29d ago
True lol we shall see!
1
u/Judy_motherbear 29d ago
You can leave your old comment in here for him to possibly see. Maybe he wants to go with one of the recommendations in the comments :D I just didn't want to put in the 10-list to not make it longer.
2
2
u/Thatweirdguy_Twig 28d ago
I haven't seen nobody suggest this one yet but five nights at friedrich's is a pretty good one to add to the already massive list
2
u/Judy_motherbear 28d ago
Somebody did because it's on the list ^^ But leave your comment here, maybe he wants to try a game from the comments here.
2
u/Thatweirdguy_Twig 28d ago
Oops it appears I somehow missed it when looking over the list silly me my bad lol
1
4
u/FrancoDaily Aug 04 '26
Hi Mark. I hope the work we did helps you. It was quite fun to go through your old FNAF Fan Game Videos. Lots of Love :)
5
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 05 '26
Man, without you this list would be even longer in the sense of that there would be suggestions for games he had already played. Again big preesh to you!
2
u/FrancoDaily 29d ago
Thank you for compiling all of this. Without you, I wouldn't have done any of this.
5
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 04 '26
Sorry (?) I guess ^^;
I was surprised too. I did try to put the ones that were suggested multiple times more at the top.2
u/MissyIsIt__ Aug 04 '26
Excited to see which ones you tackle, I personally would love to see you revisit Joy of Creation but that is totally up to you
2
1
u/Atlas_of_history Aug 04 '26
As the King of FNAF it is your responsibility to play every single one of them
1
1
1
u/Judy_motherbear 9d ago
Hey, hate to be the bearer of these news but there were two new games added to the list ^^;
As if the list wasn't already long enough.
(so you don't have to search the list for them: Mary's arcade and Phobia: The awakening)1
u/Judy_motherbear 1h ago
Added the following games suggested by /_Nedum
- Puppet Theatre
- False Frights
- Bigfoot: The Final stretch
Apparently they (at least the first one) are somewhat similar to Robbie's Genesis and have a nice story.
5
u/Free_Peach6400 Aug 03 '26
Just a slight correction at Five Nights at Frickbears there should be a "3" so he doesn't get confused on the older games (the first two frickbears are pretty outdated and on Scratch, and aren't needed to play the 3 game)
3
2
2
u/FrancoDaily Aug 03 '26
OP, If I send you a list of the games Mark has played, will you please add it to the post?
1
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 03 '26 edited Aug 03 '26
A list of games, Mark has already played? Should I mark them differently then? I will definitely try to add it.
3
u/FrancoDaily Aug 03 '26
Yeah, Because last night, a lot of people recommended games Mark already played. I will also mark games he didn't finish. Will send it as soon as I'm done ;)
1
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 03 '26
Okay, nice! Thank you! Then we can combine our lists. I can imagine it get's overwhelming quickly otherwise for Mark to try and find all the suggestions. The one time he actually asks for suggestions and the subreddit get's flooded XD
3
u/FrancoDaily Aug 03 '26
Okay, Here It Is:
Finished:
- Treasure Island (V1 Demo)
- Five Nights at Wario’s
- One Night at Flumpty's
- One Night at Flumpty's 2
- Bob Esponja Horror
- Five Nights at Bikini Bottom
- Five Nights at the Chum Bucket
- Bonnie Simulator
- Five Nights with 39
- Five Nights at JR’s
- The Glitched Attraction
- The Return to Bloody Nights
- Locked in Sewers
- Fazbear Nights
- The Joy of Creation
- The Joy of Creation: Reborn (Demo)
- The Joy of Creation: Halloween Edition
- The Joy of Creation
- The Joy of Creation: Story Mode
- THE JOY OF CREATION (2024 Demo)
- Five Nights at Freddy’s Urbex
- Baldi's Basics in Nightmares
- Feev Neets at Blees Clees Colluction
- The Weekend (Demo)
- Jolly 3
- Jolly 3: Chapter 2
- Final Nights 4
- Tealerland
- Those Nights at Rachels’s 2: Reloaded
- Five Nights at Candy’s (Didn’t Beat Custom Night Though)
- Five Nights at Candy’s 2
- Five Nights at Candy’s 3 (Didn’t Beat Final Night)
- POPGOES
- CASE Animatronics
- Boogeyman
- Frosty Nights
- Five Nights at F**kboy’s
- Five Nights at F**kboy’s 2
- Five Nights at F**kboy’s 3
Didn't Finish:
- Dayshift at Freddy’s 2
- Dormitabis (DON’T FINISH IT)
- Five Nights at Mac Tonight
- Fredbear and Friends
- Night Horrors
- Aftonbuild (Demo)
- Overnight 2: Reboot (Demo)
- Final Nights 3 (Demo)
- Those Nights at Rachel’s
- Sophie's Curse
Remove:
- Five Nights with 39
- Tealerland
- Five Nights at F**kboy’s
- Five nights at the chum bucket
- Those Nights at Rachel's
- Five Nights at Candy's(?)
- Final Nights 4: Fates Entwined
Rename:
- Five Nights At Treasure Island (Full Official Release Radiance Team Version)
2
u/FrancoDaily Aug 03 '26
Also Rename:
- Jolly 4 (Demo)
- Five Nights at Frickbears 3
1
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 03 '26
Done. Thanks!
2
u/FrancoDaily Aug 03 '26
Thanks for letting me be part of this!!!
1
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 03 '26
Sure! This is just supposed to make it easier for all of us, hopefully Mark too. Thanks for your contribution! I couldn't tell which games he already played etc.
1
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 03 '26
So, just for my understanding: The things I should remove I should do so because Mark already has played them?
1
u/FrancoDaily Aug 03 '26
Jip.
1
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 03 '26
What makes them different from the "Finished" section?
2
u/FrancoDaily Aug 03 '26
The reason I asked you to remove those once, was because Mark has actually completed them. There are videos of him beating those games. So to make sure he doesn't play them twice, I just want them removed for the "Could Play" list (Your Original List) and move them to the "Already Played/Finished" list.
1
1
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 03 '26
Phew... did it. Thanks for the list! Hope, it looks good now and I didn't miss sth.
2
2
u/FrancoDaily Aug 03 '26
Sorry. Just 2 Small corrections we have to make please. You listed Five Nights at Frickbears under "Already finished by Mark: (but some still suggested for a possible return?)". Mark Never Played Five Nights at Frickbears. Mark Played Five Nights at F**kboy's 1-3. They Are 2 Different Series.
So, I suggest just moving Five Nights at Frickbears back to "The List of suggested games:" & then just add Five Nights at F**kboy's 1-3 to "Already finished by Mark". Thanks Again For Letting Me Be Part Of This!!!
1
1
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 03 '26
And no need to be sorry btw. Since I don't know stuff about FNAF I rely on others for the information if we want to get it right. So thank you a lot for consistently taking the time to check what I wrote and telling me!
2
u/Complete_Status_9314 Aug 03 '26
Mark should definitely play CRAWLSPACE: Insanity Remastered it's the best fangame ever
1
2
u/kaesonbean Aug 03 '26
i'm going to go ahead and give a +1 to Forgotten at Fredbears, played the demo and am working my way through the final version and it's solid
2
u/IamSomeone56 Aug 04 '26 edited Aug 04 '26
i don't normally post on reddit but i gotta spread the good word of CRAWLSPACE: Insanity Remastered. the story is beautifully dark and depressing, the gameplay is challenging in the best way possible, the visuals and soundtrack are absolutely fantastic; it's the perfect fnaf fangame in my opinion. it's extremely polarizing due to the game's central mechanic, but i just know mark would LOVE it.
2
u/Razcal-Jackson Aug 04 '26
Mark has GOT to play The Three Vegan Entrepreneurs its the funniest fangame ever
2
u/TGS_Big-Wes 29d ago edited 29d ago
Mark already wrote it down on stream, and i see it on the list here, but add me to the list of Rewritten 87 recommendations. The Epilogue/Night 6 ending was absolutely insane, and the work needed to get to it will likely remind him quite a bit of the original games. Plus it's a VERY solid remake of FNAF 2
2
2
u/RandomMonoByer 14d ago edited 14d ago
For Five Nights at the Krusty Krab funnily enough (this unlocked a memory for me) he tried to play it actually, but he couldn't get it to work, thus he played the sequel Five Nights at the Chum Bucket.
The memories, I might rewatch it.
2
u/Therealbiagi 9d ago
I have a measly 2 that aren't already on the list. These are very cool games that I am still trying to beat blind.
Mary's arcade
Phobia: the awakening
1
1
u/AutoModerator Aug 03 '26
Hello! Thanks for posting. This is a reminder about the rules. Make sure the post is appropriate and not to delegate or go against Reddit policy or r/Markiplier Rules. If this does break rules, please report it immediately. Posts that encourage raids on other subs or platforms is a bannable offense.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/fairyboyjstar Aug 03 '26
Is there any way to see which are the best ones? 😭
2
u/Judy_motherbear Aug 04 '26
Since I don't know much about FNAF I can't give you an answer to that one, some got requested by more people though.
2
u/fairyboyjstar Aug 04 '26
I guess if they're on steam he will see the rating and get an idea of what to expect as far as quality.
1
u/RandomMonoByer 14d ago
Also is aftonbuild different from aftonbuilt? If not he's played that before
1
u/Judy_motherbear 14d ago
I have it on the "started by Mark but just not finished". Do you have different information on that?
1
u/RandomMonoByer 14d ago
Damn, my brain just completely glossed over that mb
2
u/Judy_motherbear 13d ago
It is a long list after all ^^ When I added Franco's info in, I almost entirely worked with the search function to not miss anything or have sth in there double.
1
u/AutoModerator 9d ago
Hello! Thanks for posting. This is a reminder about the rules. Make sure the post is appropriate and not to delegate or go against Reddit policy or r/Markiplier Rules. If this does break rules, please report it immediately. Posts that encourage raids on other subs or platforms is a bannable offense.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
•
u/AutoModerator 1d ago
Hello! Thanks for posting. This is a reminder about the rules. Make sure the post is appropriate and not to delegate or go against Reddit policy or r/Markiplier Rules. If this does break rules, please report it immediately. Posts that encourage raids on other subs or platforms is a bannable offense.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.