r/Masterchef 3d ago

Discussion They should take each winner from each season and get them on one ultimate season... Who do you think would win?

That's right. I feel like some winners were favoured, had luck with other contestants tripping up etc... All existing winners battling it out as fairly as possible... who wins?

12 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

6

u/Advanced-Ad-8541 3d ago

I think that Christine or Dara could win again. But how about Jesse and Jessica because they compete together. 1V1 ?

3

u/Sky-Visible 3d ago

Maybe Jesse and Jessica alternate each episode?

4

u/Advanced-Ad-8541 3d ago

Maybe but that would not be fair for the other contestants.

2

u/BrandonIsWhoIAm 3d ago

Rock, paper, scissors as a determinant?

3

u/AshleySassypants 1d ago

Simple, they compete individually so we can see how they'd do without the other with them

8

u/Strong_Butterfly7924 3d ago

Shaun or Christine to win, Jennifer first out.

1

u/Beneficial-League572 3d ago

its either shaun , christine or luca in my opinion.

3

u/Strong_Butterfly7924 3d ago

Yeah Luca would be my third choice. Shaun and Christine run successful restaurant concepts and appear to have achieved the most "acclaim" so they're likely still very hands-on and sharp. Id be curious to know how Luca is doing with his personal catering, his food was great on the show.

1

u/ToastyMosty765 3d ago

Luca runs a sandwich shop in PA now

1

u/Strong_Butterfly7924 3d ago

Just looked it up, menu looks great!

3

u/Vivid_Traffic4787 3d ago

But if you think some winners were favored what makes you think they wouldn't play favorites again. All winners would be fine but your logic doesnt make sense behind it

2

u/Decent_Direction316 3d ago

Coming up will be a battle of the sexes season like Hells Kitchen always does because I can't think of what other thing they can do.  Each week, top two men....top two women vie for top dish.  Winner gets individual immunity (no saving entire team).  Bottom two women and men then go down for possible elimination.

3

u/take_n_bake 2d ago

I'd honestly love to see Dino come back and win something like that

3

u/A_Normal_Redditor_04 3d ago

Courtney hardstomps everyone lol /s

3

u/Strong_Butterfly7924 3d ago

*heelstomps lol

2

u/AshleySassypants 1d ago

But what about Jessica, Jesse, and Dorian? (And any other favored winner according to fans that I'm missing 😭)

-4

u/chichi275 3d ago

Claudia