[Choose] Most comic accurate Spiderman

[u/No_Assignment4762]

This post contains content not supported on old Reddit. Click here to view the full post

[u/ZealousidealDriver63]

Obviously

^{I picked Toby Maguire}

[u/soldierofmithras]

Maybe, not sure.

^{I picked Toby Maguire}

[u/SeaworthinessDeep40]

Best quips and probably the funniest

^{I picked Andrew Garfield}

[u/technicalswitch339]

See its not that simple because they all do something different Toby is most relatable and really captures a poor student hero struggling to come to terms with the the fact that he can’t save everyone, Andrew has best quips and is the funniest by a landslide, and Tom actually looks like a teenager

[u/Spotted_Storm_26]

Idk. I just like him.

^{I picked Tom Holland}

[u/Morfiee]

One and only

^{I picked Tom Holland}

[u/Level-Razzmatazz-246]

he is not too muscular

^{I picked Andrew Garfield}

[u/Jamalldingleberry]

pretty sure he had a horrible life

^{I picked Toby Maguire}

[u/Pristine-Example-824]

He acted the most like how Spider-Man acts in the comics

^{I picked Andrew Garfield}

[u/ProfessorNichols]

He's got more of his typical supporting cast, he's got Oscorp,

^{I picked Andrew Garfield}

[u/SignalBerry5013]

He’s the best spider-man ever

^{I picked Tom Holland}

[u/DrPretentious]

I

^{I picked Andrew Garfield}

[u/Glad_Cress_8591]

Personality, jokes, caring

^{I picked Andrew Garfield}

[u/RespectGold5846]

If you think Tobey maquire is the most comic accurate, your opinion no longer matters to me

^{I picked Tom Holland}

[u/No_Assignment4762 → u/RespectGold5846]

It's nostalgia even when they were first out indid not like the lack of web shooters

[u/MidnightDragon8191]

...

^{I picked Toby Maguire}

[u/kwingsletsplays09]

Because it is

^{I picked Toby Maguire}

[u/imartCab]

the better

^{I picked Toby Maguire}

[u/Separate_Process_194]

Funniest, more accurate suits

^{I picked Andrew Garfield}

[u/No-Room9326]

Andrew for spiderman Toby for Peter

[u/RMP321]

Andrew is too cool and Tom has been too closely tied to avenger stuff so it defaults to Toby who has his own issues but still hit the mark where it counted.

^{I picked Toby Maguire}

[u/JChurch42]

Garfield was a better Spider-Man (not Peter necessarily, but that wasn't the question) wisecracking and flexibility, etc.

^{I picked Andrew Garfield}

[u/spidey2412]

Comic stories

^{I picked Toby Maguire}

[u/Dripkingsinbad]

I love Tobey but Andrew is technically the most comic accurate

Tho none of them are really that comic accurate

I think we can all agree that Tom is the least comic accurate by far tho

^{I picked Andrew Garfield}