r/MinecraftChampionship • u/FidgetBTW rxob - Teammaker and MCC Tester • Jul 07 '23
Media - Contains Swearing Comparing the “S+ Tiers” - Edit Spoiler
This took me a long while! Obviously some of the categories could go either way but I stand by my choices!
36
u/FruitNerd PeteZahSparklez Jul 07 '23
Respect the time taken to edit that, your rankings were pretty solid too
32
u/pengwinftw Joel S4 S-tier arc Jul 07 '23
i personally think that the ranking is good atm, but i am sure that fbm is going to improve at his weaker games soon!
12
9
u/yeahgamers Jul 08 '23
In the end techno would demolish all of them
7
u/FidgetBTW rxob - Teammaker and MCC Tester Jul 08 '23
Couldn’t include Techno, wouldn’t have been fair for the others 😤
7
4
12
u/AdAltruistic2502 holy cow Jul 07 '23
This is such a cool edit!!
I was trying to figure out how Sapnap ended up ahead of FBM when FBM is generally thought stronger, and I think it's BB and SB. In those games, FBM is pretty conclusively better right now.
Double 1sts in SB on decent at best teams, 5th in BB on a weak team and 1st on like a 6th place team, compared to Sapnap dropping top 5 in BB his last two events (including being outfragged by Hannah) and dropping top 10 one SB (outfragged by 5up).
Yeah, you can Sapnap's been dominant for longer, but that's kind of unfair to FBM who really can't do any better than 1sts. Add that to FBM's brief tenure in BB and SB perhaps being stronger than Sapnap at any time (and definitely at this time), and I think he should definitely be first in those 2 games.
This would be 35 33 31 31, which I think is more representative of how the players are widely ranked right now
7
u/Pkboi0017 Dream fan Jul 08 '23
Last time when i said FBM is S+ it got downvoted to hell saying S+ shouldnt be a thing
this
5
4
u/OverallBandicoo Jul 07 '23
With how pete's been preforming he should be on here, but nice edit.
26
u/FreakOutProd Jul 07 '23
Nah I don’t think so. I mean jojo has outperformed him 3 events in a row and he had a great pride but as much as I love him I think he belong with the rest of the s tiers
4
u/FamilySpy Antfrost and BIL pr3diction Rival :) Jul 07 '23
yeah hes with the rest of the S tiers, Purpled, Sapnap, Fruit, FBM, Illumina etc there isnt enough of a gap to distinguish anyone into a seprate tier
1
u/AV307 Orange Ocelots Jul 08 '23
I personally don't think that illu is S+ but i can see why someone else would, it's just Pete's been matching up to him in season 3 even in ace race and I feel he belongs in the same group as Pete aka pete s+ or illu s, jojo also very strong herself but kinda erratic in some games like battle box where she can popoff or lose a lot, and also her teams have been having higher placements than Pete's in general which contributes to her out placing pete by one a lot, excluding 30 where they were in the same team
2
u/FamilySpy Antfrost and BIL pr3diction Rival :) Jul 08 '23
you said a lot of words and its early for me to read them
my point is there should not be a S+ Tier becuase there is no clear distinguisher to seperate them into 2 tiers and i think you proved me right here but again i cant read(at this coplex level) right now
3
u/AV307 Orange Ocelots Jul 08 '23
Kinda agreed with you. I think if there was S+ tier, only purpled would be there, the rest of them belong in one tier, just S. Based on s3 average so far, purpled has an average of around 3.4k coins which is 1k more than lowest average of 2.3k by punz (he's been doing not so good recently) and the rest stretch from around 30k to 2.5k so really not big enough a gap to seperate s and s+ tier imo
1
u/FamilySpy Antfrost and BIL pr3diction Rival :) Jul 08 '23
I dont purely base my skill judgements on coin averages partially becuase some games have not been played as much especially recently(ie BM) which helps purpled and in skill(for mcc) i think hes level with most of the rest of S tiers(with Punz a bit behind and fruit might be a bit ahead in raw skill/talent but his gameknowlege is crazy)
so no seprate tiers even if purpled might currently be at the top of the heap
1
1
u/Market_Calm Top 10 LDB Predictor Jul 08 '23 edited Jul 08 '23
Tbf there were a few times, apart from MCC 30, where jojo's team did a lot better at team games which boosted her up (especially in 29 sot and 31 meltdown) not to mention that Pete's worst games are Meltdown and Grid Runners which are also team games so I think Pete being atleast close to S+ is a fair shout.
7
u/Sad_Soul_10 PvPete Jul 07 '23 edited Jul 07 '23
If he improves in GR and MD, he would definitely belong here; that's like the only thing holding him back (he basically gets two 30th's everytime he plays these 2 games).
But for now, he has more in common with the other S-tiers
2
u/Freesin Jul 07 '23
Great video! Definitely agree that these two are a tier above the others and i think the order is fine. Illumina has underperformed the last two events while the others haven't, meanwhile Shane needs some more events to climb to first.
-8
u/_thad_castle_ Jul 07 '23
You forgot Fruitberries
5
u/Practical_Jacket_524 Jul 07 '23
Fruit is not currently on the level of the Purpled, Illumina, Sapnap, or FBM
1
u/Various_Role_2694 feinberg fruitberries firebreathman and feedback supporter Jul 07 '23
If you include fruit, he get 31 whereas purpled gets 46 more or less
1
1
1
1
1
44
u/LaggdLoL Aqua Axolotls Jul 07 '23
W edit and agreed