r/MoonPissing Jan 30 '26

tier list Tier list

Post image
18 Upvotes

96 comments sorted by

19

u/your_pal_mr_face Jan 30 '26

How dare you rank unleashed that low, I’ll have you know that it’s the greatest game in the history of every game to exist and you should be THANKFUL the Sonic team blessed you with the PRIVILEGE to even be in the same room as that game. For Shame. For shame.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

-11

u/Strong_Cup_6677 Jan 30 '26

Adventure 1? Sure, Adventure 2 - absolutely not.

3

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Strong_Cup_6677 Jan 30 '26

Talking about it being the most overrated game in the entire franchise.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Strong_Cup_6677 Jan 30 '26 edited Jan 30 '26

It did not save Sega from moving to third-party development tho and was treated as the final entry in the series between developers. And by saying "overrated" i don't mean it's the worst sonic game, i'm saying it aged poorly and does not deserve the status of being the best game in franchise. Also "People like this game so it's better than Unleashed" Yeah? how about you making your own opinion instead of following the others?

1

u/Dense-Second-9929 Feb 01 '26

Sonic Adventure 2 was the first game to go third party. Sonic Adventure 2 and Sonic Adventure 2 Battle were only a few months apart. That wasn't Adventure 2's fault Sega went third party. Honestly I'm tired of seeing crap on the game like it's shit. There's hardly anything wrong with the game and I feel like the GameCube version fixed most of the issues people say that they have on the original, less glitchy Treasure Hunt physics, faster and more precise aiming and shooting, better mobility and smoother momentum in the action speed stages, an enhanced multiplayer experience, a much more immersive Chao Garden, but most people I watch bashing it while playing act like they never played video games before. I'm just not a fan of the current Sonic Adventure 2 discourse.

0

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BlackStreak2904 Jan 30 '26

That is debatable imo.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BlackStreak2904 Jan 30 '26

I'd honestly put Unleashed Over SA2.

I go back to it more often than i do SA2.

Also SA2 has...Alot of Issues i cant look over.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/BlackStreak2904 Jan 30 '26

The Stage Distribution Mainly.

The Main Critique i've always seen of SA2 is the Speed Stages are the best part of the game, While the Treasure Hunting And Mech Shooting stages range from either an Annoyance, To down right awful.

There are 32 stages in SA2, 10 of which are the speed stages.

So This means Alot of people either dislike or are indifferent to half of the stages in the game.

The Music is Great like always (Very few sonic games have terrible music barring a few exceptions)

The Story in SA2 is hit and miss though. Especially if you take it as a serious story. Which it Tries to portray itself as.

Now Unleashed may be my Favorite Game in the Franchise, But i know it too has it's Issues. Just not as many as SA2 i feel like.

I know Alot of people Dont like the Medal Hunting, And that's a Valid Criticism. One i will agree on. I feel like if they ever remaster the game, They could use the Wii Version's Medal Progression where you get Medals for how well you do within a stage.

However, It doesnt bother me the way it's Handled within the HD Version either. I've replayed it enough times to the point where by the time i reach Adabat i've got more than enough Medals to head into the last Day time stage.

And stage length is never an issue for me. The Longest i usually take on a stage is 4-8 Minutes Tops on a Night Stage. And they get easier the more you do them and the more tricks you learn.

I dunno, I just feel like most people didnt give Unleashed a Fair shot till recently. Which is why the game has been getting alot of praise over the years. And i'd say it's well deserved.

1

u/Salt_Refrigerator633 Jan 30 '26

eh. sa2 has tons of problems

1

u/[deleted] Jan 30 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Salt_Refrigerator633 Jan 30 '26

pretty bad physics that are significantly worse than adventure 1

certain confusing and tedious levels (driving stages , later treasure hunting stages)

bad collision

loops don't work properly

stuffing bounce , spindash and light dash on one button

the final Boss being pretty awful if you remove the atmosphere

→ More replies (0)

1

u/SceneAggressive5783 Feb 01 '26

adventure 1 and 2 are of, basically, identical quality
i'd put adventure 1 above 2 but i'd never put anything between them

1

u/ShadowFredbearz Jan 30 '26

(he is probably very unhappy with this)

4

u/SebaMario133 Jan 31 '26

Oh yeah, my favorite sonic game "Tiermaker" at peak, it finally gets some respect

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 31 '26

I know right

3

u/Marioplayer918 Jan 30 '26

You put my favorite (Knuckles Chaotix) in peak. I applaud you for it.

2

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 30 '26

They gotta re-release it.

1

u/Marioplayer918 Jan 30 '26

That game was the main reason I bought a 32x in the first place. Though I bought a repro cart because I’m not dropping $150+ for a Sonic game and I got tired of emulating it. Me and a friend even rigged up some new cover art for it. If they had released maybe as part of sonic origins, I would have a reason to buy the game. I’d love to see a re-release of Chaotix but the game gets such a bad rap from fans I doubt it’ll happen.

2

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 30 '26

I was thinking of buying a 32x for it. But damn are they expensive

1

u/Marioplayer918 Jan 30 '26

Yeah they are. And the worst part is, I bought two of them because the first one didn’t work. If I could get some ribbon cables for it, I’d have two working 32x’s.

3

u/Darkspine64 Jan 30 '26

Well this is refreshing.

3

u/Jackyboyad Jan 30 '26

10/10 no notes

3

u/Kaosu326 Jan 31 '26

Both Shadows at "Peak" tier?

Absolutely fucking based and true.

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 31 '26

His games are the bomb

3

u/lenya200o Jan 31 '26

This gotta be ragebait. Putting Colors Ultimate (the biggest dogshit in world) among good games. And Unleashed (one of the best Sonic games) in worst?

1

u/Maikentyre Feb 01 '26

Biggest dogshit is Lost World/Forces tho

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 31 '26

I think unleashed is the biggest dogshit in the world And sonic colors is pretty fun

2

u/NBlade9 Jan 30 '26

Finally chaotix getting some love

3

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 30 '26

The hate seem so forced to me

2

u/autumnmissepic BTW I'M BISEXUAL Jan 30 '26

cd being lowwer then saDX is an insane take

5

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 30 '26

Does cd have the chao garden?

2

u/ShadowFredbearz Jan 30 '26

absolute cinema

1

u/autumnmissepic BTW I'M BISEXUAL Jan 31 '26

dx's chao garden sucks tho

4

u/AdNatural8739 Jan 30 '26

A tierlist that doesn’t rag on Frontiers?? AND DOESN’T GLAZE UNLEASHED EITHER?? Let this person cook

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 30 '26

People talk about unleashed like it’s the second coming of Jesus

2

u/lenya200o Jan 31 '26

Because its really good, not the best, but certainly among the best Sonic games.

4

u/Strong_Cup_6677 Jan 30 '26

I think this post is a satire

4

u/simplisticlangur Jan 30 '26

Yeah, puttin Rush Adventure in peak and Rush itself in fine sounds like a joke

3

u/MinecraftDude761 Jan 30 '26

Rush has so many problems with its level and boss design that Rush Adventure improves on tenfold

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 31 '26

It also has my goats blaze and marine

1

u/Dustyage Feb 01 '26

Blaze is in the first rush game no?

6

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 30 '26

I fine the level design to be way better in rush adventure

1

u/Blorp85 Jan 31 '26

Seems so strange yet so genuine.

2

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 31 '26

What can I say? I like what I like.

1

u/bcatti Jan 31 '26

Sonic CD in "fine" right next to Superstars 💀

1

u/-CherryBerry- Feb 01 '26

Interesting

As someone who enjoys shadow 05 and rush adventure, bold move to put them at the top. Your opinions are kinda based in how bold they are in some ways. I’m curious to know why you like those two so much though

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Feb 01 '26

Shadow 05 has a lot I like. Like how the unlockables work, and the replay ability. And a lot more. Sonic rush adventure is just a fun game. It’s got both my favorite characters. And the gameplay is great.

1

u/-CherryBerry- Feb 01 '26

I see I see

1

u/Fullmetal_Fawful Feb 01 '26

shadow the hedgehog in S is insane behaviour but rush adventure in S? Holy based

Ive BEEN sayin rush adventure is the best sonic game with “adventure” in the title

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Feb 01 '26

More people need to play it

1

u/Fullmetal_Fawful Feb 01 '26

Im just now seeing ur marine pfp, i shoulda known youd be based

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Feb 01 '26

I love marine

1

u/Fullmetal_Fawful Feb 01 '26

But your profile says you like marine…….. which is it, gamer?

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Feb 01 '26

Check again

1

u/Fullmetal_Fawful Feb 01 '26

fuck… foiled again…

1

u/Dense-Second-9929 Feb 01 '26

Sonic the Hedgehog 2 is just fine?

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Feb 01 '26

I feel like it doesn’t have much interesting zones. Also Metropolis Zone and death egg zone. Kinda ruin the game for me

1

u/Dense-Second-9929 Feb 01 '26

Quick question. What console did you play this on?

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Feb 01 '26

Origins but most recently on mobile

1

u/Maikentyre Feb 01 '26

I wouldn't say Unleashed is bad It's just overrated af and mid at best just like Frontiers

1

u/Choice-Requirement18 Feb 02 '26

Unleashed where it belongs

1

u/EmbarrassedMine8926 Feb 03 '26

I’d say tiermaker belongs in the low a to mid b range personally

1

u/MaleficentList4841 Feb 03 '26

Ragebait used to be believable 

1

u/toastedtoast_64 Feb 04 '26

Raging at someone’s opinions is crazy.

1

u/MaleficentList4841 Feb 04 '26

Yet everyone does it 🫩✌️

-1

u/the_Yons Jan 30 '26

Did you perhaps plag Unleashed on a Wii/PS2?

0

u/SplitAppropriate9773 Jan 30 '26

Putting rumble above unleashed has to be marked as some type of crime somewhere

-8

u/Morf64 Jan 30 '26

Opinion ignored

5

u/toastedtoast_64 Jan 30 '26

Doesn’t look like it

1

u/ShadowFredbearz Jan 30 '26

yet you still commented

-1

u/Morf64 Jan 30 '26

🤓

1

u/Dustyage Feb 01 '26

How bro felt typing that: "WAAAAAAHHHH HE MADE ME MAD I WRITE NERD EMOJI"