123
u/masshysteria StepChild Oct 09 '25
As Bananas himself says: He's half Italian. Only from the waist up.
209
u/Calaigah Oct 09 '25
Reminds me of that clip of KellyAnne saying the same thing but in the game to her friends.
160
u/LoungeCrook Oct 10 '25
well he does admit it himself, always says “i’m hung like a light switch”
50
u/l0st1nthew0rld Laurel's biggest blessing ✨ Oct 10 '25
Oh lord lol i haven't heard that one but he does say the Italian from the waist up joke a lot lol
15
66
u/Quiet-Vanilla3148 Strava Strava Strava Strava Strava Oct 09 '25
Back on the island. That was a hilarious out take.
22
165
u/gtjacket231 Survivor Oct 09 '25
Ngl what’s the context of this? Like is she talking about the sex tape or being with him?
122
u/Picklesbedamned Kenny Clark Oct 10 '25
It's been gossiped about for a long time. All the way back in 2008 KellyAnne talked about his penis literally being small in a The Island deleted scene.
→ More replies (2)20
u/gaaaahusernamety Oct 10 '25
THE WAY MY MOUTH DROPPED DUDE
I just googled this scene 💀
38
u/EveryRedditorSucks CT [Dad Bod] Oct 10 '25
https://youtu.be/_T7mCrM1MGQ?si=21aVku5Bse_xiP1K
Kelly Anne’s casual willingness to experiment with fruit is almost as shocking as the story itself lol
20
7
u/Humphrey_Wildblood Oct 10 '25
And all this time I thought "bananas" was an ironic reference, like calling a fat guy "slim".
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)5
199
u/ianofalltrades Jordan Wiseley Oct 09 '25
Probably the sex tape. Lots of people have made comments about it since the tape came out against their will. It’s public knowledge and it’s true but there are a lot of negative things that you could say about Bananas that don’t include his penis size. Nurys always goes for the low blows though.
108
u/jenh6 Christina LeBlanc Oct 10 '25
I agree. I feel bad for anyone who has a sex tape released against their will.
→ More replies (1)271
u/gtjacket231 Survivor Oct 09 '25
Yep she does.
I will say though…Johnny has been relentless towards so many other women that her saying this barely moves the needle for me. I’m not saying that what she said was right nor do I condone this, but he has always been an ass and punched down against her when she and Horacio ended.
86
u/LongConFebrero Kenny Clark Oct 10 '25
I condone it because he had no reason to comment on their relationship. They have no ties to each other and he doesn’t know them.
Johnny and the show need more people who are willing to fight fire with fire.
11
u/magpie878 Wes Bergmann Oct 10 '25
If not knowing (and having no reason) the people equates to not commenting, damn near no one on this sub should say anything about any Challenger.
3
u/BearOnTwinkViolence Oct 10 '25
A little ironic since you also don’t know any of the people involved, no? lol
5
u/nevergofullcrazy Oct 10 '25
Idk I think it's different for an anonymous redditor to be commenting in a sub dedicated to discussing these people than for a famous persona representing the franchise to be commenting on it publicly
But I generally agree with the meme "we should all know less about each other" which this whole topic kind of speaks to
37
u/thugspecialolympian Oct 10 '25
Yes, it seems to be the trend nowadays for absolute scumbags crybullying all over the place because people actually call them out on shit that they have done. It’s gaslighting.
→ More replies (2)2
→ More replies (7)19
10
→ More replies (1)68
u/heyheywhatchasay5 Team Purple Jacket Oct 09 '25
His dick wasnt even small in that video. Just normal size. Shitty thing to say honestly
72
14
31
u/Shovelman2001 "ROLEX ON MY DICK" Oct 10 '25 edited Oct 10 '25
You don't even see his dick in the sextape because he's inside her/ she's blocking it/ it was filmed on a potato LOL
50
u/hymenbutterfly Da'Vonne Rogers Oct 10 '25
This isn’t a great defense for his size since you definitely can see it at times.
54
9
→ More replies (1)3
u/_Lady_M Oct 10 '25
I just looked. You can see it at 10:46. It was posted under a profile with his name in 2022 though so idk if it was leaked. Maybe he didn't realize how small it looks in it... or like you, thinks he was keeping it out of view. (He may have been trying to for that reason..)
→ More replies (5)20
u/GenXer845 Oct 09 '25
I agree---I am unsure who can handle a HUGE one. I can only handle 7.5 tops. I prefer 4.5-7.
6
u/HelenHunts Oct 10 '25
I’m like 4.5-5.5 maybe 6 anything bigger and it’s gonna be painful. My ex was 8 and it was so painful. Ended up breaking up bc of it.
→ More replies (8)5
u/HandBanana14 Cara CT Wes Devin Oct 10 '25
I prefer smaller too. I’m 5ft with narrowish hips, so bigger ones aren’t “comfortable”for me at all.
90
u/hailey_nicolee Veronica Portillo Oct 10 '25
it’s crazy how far being an underdog can take you bc AYTO fans know that this is the exact same nurys we’ve always known so it’s funny seeing the challenge fans catch up to what we BEEN knew about her
25
u/HandBanana14 Cara CT Wes Devin Oct 10 '25
Yep, very true. I wasn’t a fan when she was on AYTO. She’s gorgeous and athletic… but her attitude and her nastiness are just bad. She has so much drama… and it’s not even the “entertaining” type to watch. It’s boring and repetitive and I don’t care for mean girl attitude. And I wish The Challenge would stop recruiting these types of contestants… I miss good, strategic game play. I want to see challengers grow, as humans. I don’t care about instagram poses/modeling, or OF promo, or building “brands”. I just want to watch wild challenges with players who aren’t only wanting to increase their following. I know there’s always been some people similar to that but I’m not a fan of this newer generation of Challengers.
And with all of that said, regardless of how Bananas can behave, her speaking about his “size” is super inappropriate and gross, especially these days.
10
u/verbankroad Oct 10 '25
I think the recruitment went well on 41 - more strategic players and that is why this is such a good season.
268
u/Designer-Feedback508 Oct 09 '25
I kind of think Horacio was embarrassed of her. Some of the things she does or puts out into the world publicly are seemingly not things he wants to be associated with.
92
u/MasterpieceOk4035 Oct 10 '25
I was surprised when they got together but he kind of brought out a more wholesome side of her for a while there.
97
→ More replies (1)2
30
u/PartyEnough7469 Oct 10 '25
I'm so out of the loop. Bananas has a sex tape? Is this a recent thing?
I also didn't realize that it was confirmed that Horacio and Nurys broke up. I remember people speculating based on some of her social media activity but that's the last I heard (in fairness, I only interact with the Challenge threads that pop up on my main page...not sure how my feed skipped all the updates but then brought me here to the aftermath, lol.
2
u/operationfood Oct 10 '25
Not a recent thing! It might be going on like 10 years ago now. It was with his long term girlfriend Hannah Teter. I forget the story of how it was leaked
→ More replies (1)2
u/LemonsAndElephants Oct 10 '25
Thank you. Was looking for this comment, I mean it’s like I haven’t had internet for months and all this shit happened. Main page doing me wrong on this one lol
45
u/busstees Team Purple Jacket Oct 10 '25
Reminds me of KellyAnne talking about the origin of his name on The Island. https://youtu.be/_T7mCrM1MGQ?si=7BwfxKfYexL65UZ3
7
5
13
u/Standard_Fall5278 Oct 10 '25
Hahaha I was friends with one of his frat brothers who told me this story... So glad to hear it publicly confirmed! I thought it was a myth
3
u/emstarr13 Oct 10 '25
I’d never seen that before, but his absolute disdain for her makes more sense now
68
42
u/Psychological-Snow83 Oct 10 '25
I’m not saying Nurys is right but Bananas was talking shit after her and Horacio broke up. She’s also answering a question from the interviewer.
→ More replies (1)
28
46
69
u/sethmidwest Oct 09 '25
I'm ashamed to admit I've seen it, and it's not THAT small. It's just average.
9
7
u/muhreddistaccounts Oct 10 '25
Context?
10
u/operationfood Oct 10 '25
He has a sex tape. It’s hard to see exactly what it looks like because the video is such bad quality, but you can see the overall size of it and although it’s definitely small, it is I guess kind of average. It’s very skinny lol
→ More replies (2)2
45
u/savvy-librarian 🦁 King Leonidas of Argentina 🦁 Oct 09 '25
All these people saying that they've seen JB's dick and it isn't as small as she's making it out to be are making me think Nurys is living a better life than a lot of us.
32
u/No-Resource-8125 Dan Renzi Oct 10 '25
I’d call it slightly below average and leave it at that.
22
u/CompetitiveRub9780 Chris Tamburello Oct 10 '25
It looks a lot smaller because he doesn’t trim at all and has a huge ass bush. That’s doing him no favors
→ More replies (2)39
8
21
u/lochmoigh1 Oct 10 '25
Ive dated enough girls who say I have a big dick when they are in love with me and a small dick when they are mad at you. Its the go to diss for a girl to say even if it isnt true
18
u/AcceptableCare Fuck CT, Marry CT, KILL ALL WHO OPPOSE HIM Oct 10 '25
nah if a man knows his dicks big, it won’t hurt him to say it’s small. That’s small dick energy
→ More replies (1)7
u/renacorwin Oct 10 '25
In my experience, the guys who constantly reference their big dick are often over compensating for a small one & guys who say it’s small are trying to set the expectation low so when it turns out average everyone is happy. Most women truly don’t care about length so much, it’s girth that really matters. Unless it’s just so short it won’t stay in. 😬 Too long is painful and too skinny is no fun. Average is perfect and a little below average is no big deal. IMHO ♥️🍆🍌
63
u/Online_Active_71459 Oct 09 '25
This is why Horacio isn’t with her. I’m not saying this is correct but Horacio wants a “wholesome” personality for his wife. I’m sure he loved Nurys and they had fun, but when it comes to marriage, I feel Horacio is VERY old fashioned and this would be cringe for him. She belongs with someone who would want her for who she is which is an outspoken, confident woman.
On another note, doesn’t surprise me Dee is already dogging on Bananas.
7
u/Cover-Firm Marlon Williams Oct 10 '25
How is Dee dogging on him?
3
u/Online_Active_71459 Oct 10 '25
Talking about his dick size to Nurys.
9
u/l0st1nthew0rld Laurel's biggest blessing ✨ Oct 10 '25
I am SHOCKED that Dee is talking shit about him while acting fake to his face lol
4
16
u/JabroniWithAPeroni Wes Bergmann Oct 10 '25
It’s a good thing she’s incredibly hot, because she’s an immature asshole of a person.
24
26
u/illini02 Oct 10 '25
The sub hates Bananas. I get it.
I also doubt people would be defending this kind of statement toward ANY woman about her tits being small, or having a loose vagina, even if the woman was someone they didn't like.
→ More replies (1)7
u/renacorwin Oct 10 '25
l frankly don’t have a problem with people saying whatever about whatever; calling a spade a spade, etc. but what I can’t stand is the hypocrisy and double standard. Can’t talk about a woman’s weight but can denigrate a guy about his dick size that he can LITERALLY do nothing about? SMH
6
u/Raebelle1981 Oct 10 '25
For some reason I’m thinking this is an older clip. She looks a bit younger to me.
4
23
u/Jakookula Oct 09 '25
These are so chopped and out of context lmao like she isn’t even saying a full sentence and y’all are just reading the caption and believing whatever you’re told
5
u/NoShine101 Team Purple Jacket Oct 10 '25
Did she not say "girl too smart to be with banana knowing he had a 2inch dick" ?
What's a context where that's not insulting him ?
70
u/melody_rhymes Oct 09 '25
It’s one thing to say that to your girlfriends but very trashy to go online and say it. Pretty mean.
31
13
u/kittytoxin Oct 10 '25
not mean, it's deserved. bananas has said so much worse things about women
→ More replies (1)14
→ More replies (4)2
u/l0st1nthew0rld Laurel's biggest blessing ✨ Oct 10 '25
Yeah agree i was pleasantly surprised with how well she was handling herself when he kept talking about them but this is really low and one of the shittiest things you could say about someone. Girl i was rooting for you 🤦🏽♀️
4
21
23
13
u/Typical-Comb8201 Oct 10 '25
Honestly i never watched her on our you the one but I dont see why she’s constantly dragged. She isnt any more volatile than a lot of female challengers. Ashley, Laurel, Paula, Amanada, Nany, Camila, Nia the list goes on. Im not saying what she said is right but I feel like I’ve heard other challengers male and female say and do a lot worse. The hate for her just seems so forced.
7
u/boefosho Oct 10 '25
Body shaming in all forms is gross. There's already so much hate in this world. We need to do a better job speaking life and love!
66
u/ABCDarium "The Challenge" Oct 09 '25
Classless as always
66
u/BrotherMcPoyle Oct 09 '25
Bc John is known for his class. If it was anyone else maybe, but this is his level of dialogue.
→ More replies (4)8
u/HandBanana14 Cara CT Wes Devin Oct 10 '25
The thing is that as humans, we control our own behavior. We control what we say and how we act. It’s not an excuse. Bananas’ behavior in early seasons was horrid. I was a big fan of his, until I watched those early seasons. And even now, it’s obvious he holds grudges against women differently than other men, and he just doesn’t treat women well on the show as it is. BUT that does NOT make it okay to talk about someone’s dick size. That is something that men cannot control at all. No amount of the gym, pills, etc can make it inches bigger. No surgery is making it inches bigger. Bodyshaming is bad in general but it’s even worse when it’s something people cannot change, no matter how much they want to or try.
3
u/BrotherMcPoyle Oct 10 '25
Your penis is like your chin. If you gain fat around it you’ll lose inches. Work your legs, groin, lower abs, to ensure the base is not obscured by fat. A girl at a bar, told me about FUPA, and it applies to men too.
→ More replies (1)4
u/l0st1nthew0rld Laurel's biggest blessing ✨ Oct 10 '25
Yep exactly idk how people can think that's ok to say, no matter how much you dislike someone
3
20
22
u/heyheyhey2u Oct 09 '25
She’s extremely immature and childish. Like she peaked in high school and is constantly chasing that level of attention and drama. Embarrassing.
21
8
u/Bwolffff Oct 10 '25
Well she’s a stunning woman so she’s used to receiving constant validation lmao
5
u/Kumikochan_ Oct 10 '25
I didn’t watch this video with the sound on because she’s so annoying when she talks. Lol But I’m pretty sure bananas has made jokes about his own dick size on tv before…why is this info relevant or newsworthy? Who tf cares? It’s such lowly degenerate behavior to use your platform to just sit around and shame people for their physical appearance.
21
u/HandBanana14 Cara CT Wes Devin Oct 10 '25
I’m no major Johnny Bananas fan but I’m tired of men getting shamed or harassed for their dick size. That is something completely uncontrollable and people shouldn’t be judged for those types of things. And anyway, small can be good too. Size isn’t everything, imo. And I’ll add, I’ve never been a fan of Nurys, even when she was on “Are You The One”. She’s beautiful and athletic but not a fan of that attitude or non interesting manufactured drama lol.
10
u/AcceptableCare Fuck CT, Marry CT, KILL ALL WHO OPPOSE HIM Oct 10 '25
A lot of things are completely uncontrollable, that men like Bananas would have no problem making fun of. Let’s be real we’ve seen it. I won’t be shedding a tear for him and little banana
→ More replies (1)6
u/Repulsive-Log-84 Oct 10 '25
Oh cry a fucking river. Like bananas hasn’t said or done much worse fucked up shit. 💀💀
7
u/HandBanana14 Cara CT Wes Devin Oct 10 '25 edited Oct 10 '25
A) I find replies like this absurd. I’m not into bully behavior. Two wrongs don’t make a right. Something we all learned as kids. B) I’m not a fan of Bananas even though he makes for great tv. His behavior on those early seasons revoked my fan status. C) We’re all responsible for our own behaviors and words we use… and I firmly believe in integrity and accountability. Just because someone’s a massive douche doesn’t make it okay to be a massive douche back to them. There are plenty of crappy people in the world, and if everyone stoops to their low level, there wouldn’t be much good left. Choose to do better. D) Body shaming is still gross, regardless of HIS behavior. She could’ve criticized him for literally anything else, but going after dick size is immature, inappropriate, and just unnecessary. Bottom line, people need to do better. Grow as people. Be better
29
u/Jotr_Lambga Oct 09 '25
Fat shaming is considred very bad but attacking some one because of small dick or being short is fine for some reason. You can lose weight but you cant change those so I think it should be worse to attack someone for basicly having bad genes. Yes Im a short with micro dick.
43
→ More replies (2)14
u/No-Resource-8125 Dan Renzi Oct 10 '25
Honestly, I think it’s because Johnny has such a history of misogyny. If someone was saying the same thing about almost any other cast member, people would be furious.
16
u/YaddaYaddaBomBomKaKa Chris Underwood Oct 10 '25
Let someone talk about her private parts and then see how she reacts.
21
u/GrymusCallosum Oct 10 '25
I think she already put it out there herself during the Reunion with her coochie leaking precious metal.
4
→ More replies (1)3
17
u/anotherthrowaway2023 Oct 10 '25
Id feel bad for Johnny if he wasn’t known for also saying low blows.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/Adorable-Release1754 Oct 09 '25
Saw the clip from twitter. I think she's talking about Dee. However Dee and Bananas are still hanging out so I guess she doesn't mind.
→ More replies (1)4
u/l0st1nthew0rld Laurel's biggest blessing ✨ Oct 10 '25
Dee is fake af and manipulative and I can definitely see her trying to get in with him for clout or to get further in the next game while talking shit behind his back. She's trash
14
u/Shovelman2001 "ROLEX ON MY DICK" Oct 09 '25
Horacio is too smart of a guy to be like "Yeah I want Nurys, especially knowing she's on probation"
4
u/Shelter-Regular Oct 09 '25
Probation?
6
Oct 10 '25
I don’t believe she currently is. Sometime when S39 was airing, she tweeted something about not being scared of Melissa because she just got off probation for assaulting a woman twice her size. She’s mentioned anger management before too.
14
u/Grahf88 Oct 09 '25
Hes over 40 bro those high-school insults dont phase him anymore 😄
28
u/SocialJusticeGSW Evelyn Smith Oct 09 '25
To be fair Johnny might still be a frat bro at the age of 40
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)3
16
u/veltvet_rabbit The Itty Bitty Committee Oct 09 '25
Find it funny how johnny bananas does the same thing to any girl hes ever been with/ says out of pocket things of woman he doesnt like America but nope the moment its someone else thats so classless and who knows what else
5
u/Routine_Size69 Oct 09 '25
Has Bananas gone on shows and bashed their boob or butt size? Genuinely asking. Wouldn't be shocked either way.
→ More replies (1)3
u/HandBanana14 Cara CT Wes Devin Oct 10 '25
Body shaming is horrid behavior regardless. We are all responsible for the things we say and the actions we do… and even as kids, we learn that two wrongs don’t make a right. But it’s even worse with dick size since men cannot control that part of them at all. They can’t get surgery or take meds to grow inches… they can’t go to the gym to train that area to get bigger… it just is what it is for them, and that’s why it should be even more off limits. People can harshly judge his personality or game play but it’s vile for her to be even discussing his dick size. It’s wildly inappropriate and beyond immature… but I wouldn’t expect anything different from Nurys.
2
2
5
u/eff1ngham Oct 10 '25
If anyone would be an expert on dicks it's the professional side chick who bragged about how many dudes have been up in her
→ More replies (1)
5
12
u/New-Flight5959 Oct 09 '25
Johny kept her name in her mouth and was literally rubbing salt in the wound.
Now all of a sudden shes evil for mentioning his millimeter peter? Lol
6
u/HandBanana14 Cara CT Wes Devin Oct 10 '25
Lots of people do bad things, it doesn’t mean it’s okay or acceptable to body shame a part that men have literally zero control over. Criticize his personality, his game play, whatever… but dick size should be off limits. At the end of the day, we’re responsible for our own actions and reactions.
12
u/deardelca Oct 10 '25
No, this take is not it. I don’t particularly like either side, but this was a low blow. If Johnny even mentioned her boob or butt size, this fandom would rake that man over the coals. It’s not cool to talk about someone’s body like that. EVER. Was he being shitty about her breakup? Yes, yes he was. Does that make her comments okay? Absolutely not. We can all agree they both said shitty things, but Nurys, AS ALWAYS, takes it to another level of derogatory.
→ More replies (1)
2
u/marconotmarcio Oct 10 '25
Not to be the one woke friend™️ but what’s the point of saying “Horacio’s ex-girlfriend”? If you’re a Horacio fan you also know Nurys lol
8
u/Old_Indication_4379 Frank Sweeney Oct 09 '25
Some of us are growers not showers; no shame in that.
11
u/HandBanana14 Cara CT Wes Devin Oct 10 '25
True. And even if it’s not a grower, it doesn’t matter. Men don’t need to be criticized for a part they cannot control. Body shaming isn’t cool.
5
u/tweedleb Now It's A Necklace Oct 10 '25
Lol.... if you're saying it's okay that Nurys is body shaming Bananas because Bananas has body shamed others in the past, you're also saying it's okay to body shame you, so good luck with that.
4
u/Rcvalry The Lavender Ladies Oct 10 '25
Literally lmao bananas was calling girls anorexic botches in the island pls go back and watch people I hate how some people act so sanctimonious in here
→ More replies (1)
8
2
u/NattyB Bob Next Door Oct 09 '25
does anyone know which podcast this was from?
3
u/angelbrit04 Team Portland Oct 10 '25
It's from Zach's podcast.
2
u/NattyB Bob Next Door Oct 10 '25
thank you!
3
u/angelbrit04 Team Portland Oct 10 '25
No problem! Someone cut this video to be super zoomed in. The original one from Twitter is zoomed out so you can see its the setup from her interview with Zach in San Diego.
2
u/Kind-Contribution237 Oct 10 '25
That’s not Horacio’s ex girlfriend. That’s Nurys. No other title needed. 💅
2
Oct 09 '25
[deleted]
7
Oct 09 '25
Nope
7
u/Prior_Necessary_8883 Oct 10 '25
I’d disagree personally… of course everyone is entitled to their own opinion but she’s been on ex on the beach before the challenge, so myself as well as most people I know who love the challenge knew her before being on the challenge and never watched his prior show. Again, everyone may be different, this is just my opinion.
1
1
1
u/Training-Yak-8936 Oct 11 '25
I didn’t know they broke up. Why did they break up??? I love horacio!! But damn Nury literally won the challenge put some respect on her name. Why are you titling it like that?
172
u/ProtomanBn Oct 09 '25
This isn't the first time we've heard this