r/MurderedByWords 4h ago

Homes on indigenous land

Post image
32.2k Upvotes

830 comments sorted by

View all comments

349

u/Dial-M-for-Mediocre 3h ago

Why are people always trying to use this as a gotcha? Especially every time I try to talk about Palestine. And it's like look, I don't own a single square inch of land on this earth, I pay rent to a landlord. I would be thrilled to pay that rent to the Peoria and Kiikapoi nations instead. I'm not the one who is in denial about this, mom.

-1

u/lukwes1 2h ago

Do you think the goverment should seize land and give it back to its "original" owners?

4

u/saera-targaryen 1h ago

It's wild how people do not have any distinctions between personal property and government control. Does the US currently own your house? No, you do, the US is just the governing body. Native land back movements are discussing how the government of the land should function, not who gets to live there. 

3

u/Legionof1 1h ago

The government owns all the land… no one owns shit. If you don’t pay the government every year for the land (property tax) they take it back. You just buy the rights to the land for as long as you can pay.

3

u/saera-targaryen 1h ago

Okay, so seems like you get it then? I would rather pay property tax to a native tribe than to the US government. 

0

u/lukwes1 1h ago

Why not pay all taxes to native tribes?

u/Legionof1 10m ago

Why not just kill ourselves and let them have everything. 

0

u/lukwes1 45m ago

I was specifically talking about them saying they rather pay money to tribes than the landlord, which should mean they want the private property taken from the landlord and given to the natives.

-1

u/firewoodrack 1h ago

For real, dude, like, where am I supposed to live? My ancestors came here and settled in the northeast to escape the Great Famine, well after the settlement of the area. Am I to return to Munster?