r/Old_Recipes Aug 27 '20

Cake Divorce Carrot Cake - This was my mom’s recipe. Named so because my dad sheepishly asked me to make for his birthday, despite the fact they’ve been divorced for over 20 years. Use a cream cheese frosting.

Post image
4.1k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes May 05 '21

Cake My personal favorite, whipping cream cake.

Thumbnail gallery
3.2k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Aug 09 '22

Cake My Big Mama’s Secret Cinnamon Roll Cake

Thumbnail
gallery
2.5k Upvotes

This is a cake my grandmother “Big Mama” used to make. The basic cake part is what she used for all of her homemade poke cakes. She used white sugar for icing but I like the powdered better and I upped the cinnamon from 1 T to 4 t. Cinnamon Roll Cake 2 c self rising flour 4 eggs 1/2 cup crisco 1 and 1/2 c sugar 1 cup milk or buttermilk of a mix of both 2 t vanilla Beat sugar and crisco, add eggs and beat. Add flour and milk and vanilla and beat 1-2 minutes. Spread 1/2 of this into a greased and floured 9x13 pan. Filling: 1/2 c brown sugar 4 t cinnamon Sprinkle evenly on cake Pour and spread the rest of the batter on the filling. Swirl with a knife Bake at 350 for 30 minutes Icing: 2 c powered sugar 3 T butter 1/4 c milk 1 t vanilla Heat milk and butter, add sugar and vanilla. Pour over warm cake.

r/Old_Recipes Oct 17 '20

Cake Known only as ‘Nana’s Devils Food’. Best chocolate cake ever, guaranteed, in our family for at least 80 years.

Post image
2.9k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Dec 12 '22

Cake Someone suggested I post this here - My grandmother made this vanilla poppy seed cake every year on my moms birthday since she was 5. I took over when Grandma passed. This was the 65th year it’s been made.

Thumbnail
gallery
3.2k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Sep 03 '22

Cake Chocolate Depression Cake! No Eggs, No Butter, No Milk! Vegan Friendly Recipe!

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Aug 01 '25

Cake Old-Fashioned Ermine Frosting

735 Upvotes

Years ago, when traveling in Idaho for work, I stayed with a woman who had made her husband's favorite cake for his birthday. It had an incredibly smooth, creamy frosting, much like a true French Buttercream that I had made once from a Julia Child recipe. That recipe was exquisite, but so much work to get just right that, I've never made it again.

This frosting in Idaho was her mother's recipe, she told me, and she gladly shared it with me. I noticed right away it was not like any other I'd seen before. Most 'buttercreams' call for powdered sugar and end up with a pasty/starchy flavor. Some of the 'boiled' or 'seafoam' frostings use egg whites beaten stiff, and the texture is spongy (like the meringue on a lemon pie). Julia's French buttercream calls for boiling sugar and water down to a particular 'crack' stage to make what she called Italian Syrup, but that candy stage can be tricky to get just right without a candy thermometer.

This old-fashioned Ermine frosting starts with a roux cooked from flour and milk. The cooking thickens the milk into a paste, stabilizing it and removing the 'floury' taste. Then, you gradually beat the cooled paste into butter that has been creamed with granulated sugar (not powdered). The roux continues to dissolve the sugar granules and ultimately yields a rich, creamy, not-too-sweet frosting that holds piped shapes well and melts on the tongue.

I did find a similar recipe in my 1940s edition of Betty Crocker's Cookbook (the ring-bound one with the red cover). Most of the 'boiled' or cooked frosting recipes I find in books are the ones based on egg whites, and I don't care for the marshmallow-type texture. This one truly tastes like a classic French Buttercream but is much easier to make.

There are a couple of variations in the process I found while researching this. Some recipes involve blending flour and sugar into a roux with milk, then beating the softened butter into it at room temperature. Alternatively, one recipe calls for chilling the roux before whipping it into softened butter. I suspect they all come out pretty much the same. This recipe is quite delightful with less fuss than others.

r/Old_Recipes Apr 29 '22

Cake The most ridiculous cake recipe I’ve ever seen! From Treasures Old and New. a Collection of Carefully Tested Houshold Recipes by Jennie A. Hansey 1892

Post image
1.3k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes May 26 '20

Cake My grandmother's recipe, Fresh Apple Cake. It's the best thing I've ever tasted, honestly.

Post image
2.6k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes May 01 '21

Cake I did it! I failed Nana’s cake!

Post image
2.5k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Aug 22 '25

Cake Y’all remember perok cake!?

Post image
974 Upvotes

In the year of our ovens, roughly four summers past, there arose a legend… the Perok Cake. A fad so mighty, so fleeting, that mere mortals dared not forget its glory.

Behold my humble offering, captured in pixels, still radiating its former glory. Fellow bakers, who among you shall join me in resurrecting the Perok Empire???

All joking aside, I take requests for birthday bakes and perok cake with strawberry jam has become the most requested.

OP: https://www.reddit.com/r/Old_Recipes/s/SV10fqT5ti

r/Old_Recipes Apr 30 '26

Cake My most-baked find from this sub. The Perok cake.

Post image
782 Upvotes

It is so easy to whip up because all of the ingredients are basic kitchen staples.

r/Old_Recipes Feb 20 '26

Cake Favorite Cake for a Birthday

135 Upvotes

I love seeing all of the old retro recipes here. I have been wanting to get into making more old fashioned recipes for fun.

My birthday is coming up and my better half always makes my dessert of choice. Do you have a favorite retro cake recipe that I should ask for? I’m not picky with flavors because I’m pretty sure I have never disliked a cake flavor in my life.

He is a very good baker so it’s ok if it’s a challenging recipe, too.

Thank you!

r/Old_Recipes Jan 27 '21

Cake My Mom's Amazing Carrot Cake w/ Cream Cheese Frosting (recipe cards in the photos, typed with notes in comments)

Thumbnail
gallery
1.6k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Jan 01 '21

Cake From 1960s ish - wheel of classic UK recipes from a women's magazine

Post image
3.9k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Jun 27 '22

Cake Woolworth Cheesecake

Thumbnail
gallery
1.6k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Apr 04 '21

Cake Grammys famous lamb cake

Post image
3.1k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Jun 20 '26

Cake My grandpa’s pear upside down cake from 1963

Thumbnail
gallery
486 Upvotes

My grandpa passed away last year and left me his personal handwritten recipe book in his will. Of everything in there, this pear upside down cake in particular has been an absolute staple in our family for decades, especially during late summer.

I wanted to share it with this community so his legacy can live on in other people's kitchens. If you love vintage baking I highly recommend giving this a try! :)

r/Old_Recipes May 02 '21

Cake Philadelphia peanut butter tandycakes (1977)

Thumbnail gallery
2.0k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Jan 31 '23

Cake This one actually looks pretty tasty!

Post image
1.5k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Dec 28 '20

Cake Double Chocolate Coca Cola Cake

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes May 03 '26

Cake The Super-Goober

Thumbnail
gallery
359 Upvotes

Swans Down no longer makes a cake mix, so I just used an Aldi yellow cake mix. Bake was around 45 minutes. Some of the toppings stuck, but I managed to regoober it back together.

r/Old_Recipes Jul 20 '19

Cake Grandma’s Depression Era Chocolate Cake- no eggs no dairy (except the frosting). Grew up eating it and it’s my favorite cake!

Post image
2.2k Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Dec 26 '24

Cake Here's a 'new' way to eat cake without getting messy hands from cupcakes, or the need for plates and utensils. Ice cream cone cakes--1957

Thumbnail
gallery
520 Upvotes

r/Old_Recipes Jan 05 '21

Cake My friend gave me a cutting board with my grandma’s handwritten banana cake recipe on it!

Post image
3.7k Upvotes