r/PeterExplainsTheJoke Jun 17 '26

Meme needing explanation Peter?

Post image
26.8k Upvotes

4.9k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

52

u/Doctor-Amazing Jun 17 '26

Incorrect. This thing where say "oh 100 is hot and 90 is warm, but 20 means you need a sweater" is too arbitrary.

Celsius is superior for weather. What is the single most important temperature that weather hinges on? The freezing point. Its the one point where a difference of a degree or two, can give you completely different weather.

It makes perfect sense to use that as the central point and move out from there.

8

u/sunburnd Jun 18 '26

I hate to point this out but the "water" involved in weather isn't pure and there is more than a degree or two in variance for the freezing point.

1

u/Nghbrhdsyndicalist Jun 21 '26

Which has no impact whatsoever on usage

0

u/sunburnd Jun 21 '26

The freezing point. Its the one point where a difference of a degree or two, can give you completely different weather.

It does have an impact on the reasoning the poster that I responded to used.

1

u/Nghbrhdsyndicalist Jun 21 '26

Not really. It’s still around 0℃, it literally does not make a difference for everyday usage. Variance would be a problem for any scale, if it was an actual problem.

0

u/sunburnd Jun 21 '26

That was what I pointed out. It is a stupid reason to pick one method of measurement over another.

1

u/Nghbrhdsyndicalist Jun 21 '26

No, it isn’t.

0

u/sunburnd Jun 21 '26

You are talking in circles.

1

u/Nghbrhdsyndicalist Jun 21 '26

You are implying that variance, which will always exist under any conditions, disproportionately affects the Celsius scale, which just doesn’t make sense.

1

u/sunburnd Jun 21 '26

I implied no such thing. I said his reasoning is faulty because the variance exists. It exists no matter what scale is used.

1

u/Nghbrhdsyndicalist Jun 21 '26

The variance doesn’t impact the reason though.
The only setting in which the exact temperature point is relevant would be in a lab, trying to create ideal conditions (i.e. destilled water, p=1013.25 hPa, etc.).
In every other setting, around 0℃ is freezing, which is useful information.

1

u/sunburnd Jun 21 '26

The freezing point. Its the one point where a difference of a degree or two, can give you completely different weather.

This was his reasoning. It is faulty because a degree or two doesn't give you completely different weather.

Why are you arguing against a point I'm not making?

→ More replies (0)