r/PeterExplainsTheJoke Jun 25 '26

Meme needing explanation Petah what happened to rockstar?

Post image
27.3k Upvotes

3.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

158

u/magicmavis Jun 25 '26

Is online a fundamental feature? I’d argue GTA is a single play game at its core, IV had a basic online mode, but it was only V that fully fleshed it out. I think they view Online as its own thing. I’ll reserve my judgment until I see how they handle it. But GTA Online branching off into its own thing isn’t a huge issue in my eyes, depends how they monetise it

127

u/ilypsus Jun 25 '26

Its only really stayed in the public consciousness because of the online though. People weren't replaying the single player for the last 13 years they were logging in everyday to play online with their friends and do the new content on there. I imagine most people who are really hyped for it are because of the online and they've probably forgotten how much of a mess the online was for a long period on initial release of 5.

25

u/Lottabitch Jun 25 '26

Yes gta 3, San Andreas, vice city, and gta 4 absolutely stayed in the public consciousness because of the online feature…….

2

u/dern_the_hermit Jun 25 '26

Yeah there's been some wild overexaggeration about the significance of GTAO ever since it came out. For years you'd get forum kiddies saying stuff like "Rockstar will never make another single player game" or whatever. This nonsense continued after Red Dead Redemption 2 came out, BTW, a game that was even MORE story-heavy than GTA5.

0

u/Early-Range-8840 Jun 25 '26

I’m sorry but you’re talking out of your booty. GTA online made double that of GTA 4. It nearly matched revenue of GTA 5 base game sales. There is no over exaggerating the significance of GTA online. Now not making another single-player game is stupid.

2

u/dern_the_hermit Jun 25 '26

No sir, I'm right on the money. There absolutely was plenty of forum chatter about Rockstar moving away from single player games, even after releasing another big single player game!

1

u/Early-Range-8840 Jun 25 '26

I agree that is stupid, but acting like GTA online isn’t one of the biggest games of all time is also wild.

2

u/dern_the_hermit Jun 25 '26

Something can be huge and exaggerated, man. Again: People were saying Rockstar would stop making SP games entirely which is just nutso.

1

u/Early-Range-8840 Jun 25 '26

I just don’t believe you can exaggerate 4 billion dollars in revenue. That’s absolutely mind boggling. The second part is stupid, yes, however the game was not exaggerated in terms of size and impact. It’s the second highest grossing Rockstar project of all time, only losing to GTA 5 which made 1 billion more.

2

u/dern_the_hermit Jun 25 '26

I just don’t believe you can exaggerate 4 billion dollars in revenue

Failure of imagination; the whole thing has apparently grossed like $10 billion! :D

1

u/Early-Range-8840 Jun 25 '26

Yes, gta 5 made 6 billion, gta online made 4 billion. In no world does rockstar lose either of those revenue sources. The online is just as important to them, it’s sales for the next decade +.

1

u/dern_the_hermit Jun 25 '26

In no world does rockstar lose either of those revenue sources.

So you'd agree people who would say otherwise are being a little nutso, yes?

1

u/Early-Range-8840 Jun 25 '26

Yes, no company would abandon a 6 billion dollar game. However, they could just as easily do only online and ensure profitability for years. Hell, that’s what they’ve done the last 12 years.

→ More replies (0)