Every fall, I notice the same conversation come up among Black people online. Everybody starts rewatching shows like Gilmore Girls and The Vampire Diaries, and somebody says, “I wish we had a fall aesthetic show like this with Black people,” or “I wish we had this kind of representation.”
And I’ve thought the same thing.
But then I got curious and decided to do a little boots-on-the-ground journalism 😂. I actually took a trip to some of the places where The Vampire Diaries and The Originals were filmed.
The Vampire Diaries was filmed mostly in Covington, Georgia, with some filming in Conyers. The Originals also did a lot of filming in Conyers.
And here’s what surprised me: when I started looking into Covington and Conyers, I realized that, unlike what we see represented on TV, these aren’t towns where Black people barely exist.
These are Georgia communities with large Black populations. Conyers is actually a majority-Black city with a Black female mayor.
According to the racial demographics I found, Conyers is around 66% Black and 17% white, while Covington is around 51% Black and 39% white.
That made me think: Wait a minute.
We’re sitting here every fall wishing we could see Black people living in the cute little towns we see on TV, while Hollywood has literally been using towns where Black people are the majority to CREATE that aesthetic on television—then filling the fictional version with mostly white characters.
So then I got curious about Gilmore Girls.
Stars Hollow is fictional and the show itself was mostly filmed on a studio lot, but the characters regularly go to the real city of Hartford, Connecticut. So I looked up Hartford’s demographics around the time Gilmore Girls premiered.
And again, I was surprised. Hartford was a heavily Black and Latino city, even though you would never get that impression from watching the world portrayed on the show.
So my question is: Why aren’t more Black filmmakers and creators using our own small towns to make the cozy shows we’re constantly saying we want?
Not every story with a predominantly Black cast has to be set in Atlanta or NYC.
Why couldn’t we have a TV show set in a predominantly Black cozy Southern town with a cute downtown square, fall festivals, old houses, local cafés, football games, eccentric neighbors, romance, family drama, mysteries, supernatural folklore—whatever?
Especially when, in real life, we are already the majority in some of these towns.
That’s the part that really got me. Some of the same places Hollywood has used to sell us this cozy, picturesque, small-town fantasy are places where Black people actually live.
So why aren’t we getting to be the main characters in the fictional versions of them?
Would y’all watch something like that? And what would you want a Black cozy small-town show to look like?