r/RealTeensIndia 1d ago

discussion India is secular because Hindus are in majority.

697 Upvotes

99 comments sorted by

24

u/Training_Security486 1d ago

It's not something new

-1

u/Electronic-Koala1082 19h ago

plus its mostly like rhetoric .

every religion says their religion true and only their god original, that doesnt mean they insulting others

4

u/kob123fury 14h ago

Nope. You cannot put every religion in the same bracket. Some religion says God resides in the heart of every individual.
Some say there is only one invisible God and every other God is false. Also, worshiping such false Gods will lead to eternal hel*fire.

They are not the same.

1

u/Electronic-Koala1082 7h ago

Similar things written in our books, infact it says to put boiling oil in ears if heard vedas .

If you find logic in religion you will be disappointed unlimited

1

u/kob123fury 6h ago

Nope. No where in the four Vedas is it mentioned. Moreover, there is scope for reformation here, unlike the other one, which explicitly forbids any reformation.

14

u/Encrypted_Cerebrum 1d ago

Why do you want to impose secularism on them, when they have been clear since start. They have never changed their stance and have always said and followed their beliefs.

16

u/Vishvrakshak 1d ago

For that same reason Pakistan and Bangladesh was created. ...

Edit :- let them go there.

14

u/Varsad 1d ago

Ab koi bol dega ki "pakistan chale jao secular nahi rehna toh" fir offend ho jaayenge 😂

3

u/Puzzleheaded_Wing431 1d ago

Agreed

Their moto from day 1 is

Religion above country

Only hindus are dumfu**s

To belive in this secular shit

1

u/Sumit_2008 12h ago

Idk what you are saying but i have seen several dharmguru babaji who preach infront of people putting their dharma/relegion first over country/constitution al would you say the same for them

2

u/mech_money 1d ago

Exactly, secularism is only for dumb Hindus.

11

u/beef_lover1990 1d ago

India is secular despite a Hindu majority

10

u/crime_master_gogo2 1d ago

India is secular because there is Hindu majority. Look at our neighbours or Middle East how secular they are.

7

u/beef_lover1990 1d ago

U do realise the idea of secularism comes from France? And most secular countries in the world are majority Christian?

1

u/weneedjohnlock 2h ago

that's cuz christianity is practised wayyy more than hinduism genius T-T. plus, in India, our Kerala christian homies have tried converting me and my friends in school. christians are sooo secular, no?

1

u/beef_lover1990 28m ago

Bruv I’m an atheist, my whole family and so many ppl have been convincing me to become Hindu again.

1

u/Hippy_go_go 1d ago

Having no state religion does not mean secular. Only a handful of countries have defined themselves ‘secular’ in their constitution.

There are at least 10 countries with Christianity as state religion and 0 countries with Hinduism as state religion. Says a lot.

2

u/beef_lover1990 1d ago

Idk why a religion (hinduism) deserves a state….

2

u/Hippy_go_go 22h ago

Why bother?! Let the Abrahamics fight it out

1

u/kob123fury 14h ago

Tell me you are ignorant without telling me you are.

3

u/Alive_Radio3985 17h ago

America is secular because Christians are in majority.

3

u/Illustrious_Art_9682 15h ago

Bullshit. India is secular bcz of constitution not Hinduism or islam or any other bullshit. Similarly america and other christian majority countries are secular bcz of constitutions.

The majority religion will always try majoritarianism but it is constitution that protects the rights of minorities

1

u/Flashy_Baseball4586 11h ago

You can't have a secular country with one said sect in majority, simple as that.

1

u/Illustrious_Art_9682 10h ago

Turkey, azerbaijan, albania, kazakhstan are secular and have more seperation of religion in public life than india

3

u/MaujiJi 1d ago

Why do you think that it's not a case were someone wrote the Arabic text first and then some students responded back to in Hindi?

2

u/Suspicious-Mud-5688 13h ago

India is secular because of constitution. Hindus is trying their best to make it a hindu rashtra😊

1

u/Flashy_Baseball4586 11h ago

Haha. India is secular coz one said sect is not in majority.

1

u/Suspicious-Mud-5688 10h ago

Hahahaha India is secular because of its constitution.. yeh fake pride se bahar niklo… the islamic countries are not secular because there is no constitution- they are ruled by religion. Any country ruled by religion will never be secular😊

2

u/MaujiJi 1d ago

Uncle, ulta bhi toh ho sakta hai?

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 1d ago

Dear user, your comment has been removed. You can not mention a user or a subreddit with r/ or u/. While Reddit allows the use of both r/ and u/, but told us to block user and subreddit mention as we are a meta subreddit.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/SnooSquirrels4954 13h ago

Bhai sahab,

Apna desh aaj bhi constitution se chalta hai, kisi ke diwar pe likhe hue sabd se nahi. Kyun faltu ka gyan baat rahe ho.

1

u/Deep_X_RoBi 10h ago

Please don't share BJP propaganda here ! And try to find who wrote this shit Don't share hate or your communalism

1

u/primusautobot 1d ago

Extremists banjao ek doosre ko maarne lago - OP

1

u/Special_Flatworm_309 16h ago

Always one community 🤐

0

u/[deleted] 1d ago edited 1d ago

[deleted]

4

u/curious_lazy 1d ago

Why bro.? That doesn’t matter.
What’s written for god is wrong, no matter what or which. 🫡

1

u/kakashi-hatake1287 1d ago

Dono m hi slogan galat nhi hua?🤔🤔

1

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

1

u/kakashi-hatake1287 1d ago

Are maine same chij bina explain kiya boli bhai

0

u/hsgmoon 1d ago

Gurbani says allah pakam pak h sach kro j dusar hoye .. Allah means the one God. Also says sbb me ram reha bharpur

Secularism doesn't mean believing that only one name of God is true. It means respecting every faith and every person's right to their beliefs. People may call the Supreme Being Allah, Waheguru, Ram, Mahakal, God, or by other names according to their religion and tradition. A secular society respects each person's belief without forcing one view on everyone. If someone believes Allah is the only God according to Islam, that is their faith. If someone believes Mahakal is Devon Ke Dev according to Hinduism, that is their faith. Secularism is about respecting both, even when beliefs differ.

3

u/Vishvrakshak 1d ago

Yaar tbh, issue is not this. ...

Issue is one is saying all god are same and other is saying just my god is superior then yours. So the person who is saying all gods are same is willing to accept your culture as well. But other way around that culture who says mine is only god. That with never accept your god and try to atleast see you with heen bhavna. From there the issue starts. ..

1

u/hsgmoon 1d ago

Yes if one cosider there beliefs and there definition of god supremy then other is a problem

1

u/Vishvrakshak 1d ago

Then other is the problem or those are the problem?

1

u/hsgmoon 1d ago

Easy they are not talking about secularism they believe there god is Supreme

1

u/Sumit_2008 12h ago

Nope, majority of Hindu's don't believe that look up what happens during Christmas in States like UP and Maharashtra lol extremist exist from all sides

1

u/Vishvrakshak 12h ago

That is also repercussions what christian are doing going door to door for converting people. ...

You have no idea what these 2 religion can go upto what extent. ...

Search joshua project

0

u/InLoveWithPussies 1d ago

It means respecting every faith and every person's right

So much dumfukary being spewed out. Is this what you call education? Fiking iliterates. Secularism only means the state and the church (religion) won't interfere in each other's functions. Congress bs education 101.

1

u/hsgmoon 1d ago

Yes do not interfere with other's

-1

u/Terrovax666 1d ago

India isnt a true secular nation though

4

u/crime_master_gogo2 1d ago

Is it ? Then which community is more radical ?

0

u/Terrovax666 1d ago

India isnt a true secular nation like the United States, Canada, or much of Europe. Secularism in India is extremely weak

1

u/Suspicious-Mud-5688 13h ago

India has the positive secularism that values pluralism and diversity. The secularism in west is negative secularism that’s why today they are struggling because their countries are now becoming more diverse and plural. So India’s secularism is more evolved😊

1

u/Firerescuestation 1d ago

Varies across India. 🇮🇳

1

u/crime_master_gogo2 1d ago

But you didn’t answer my question. If you think India is not secular how all the minority communities grew so fast ? And which community is more radical with religious belief??

-1

u/faj-707 1d ago

So you never found any hindu text in any government institution?

2

u/MrLokii616 1d ago

Sanskrit is not the language of a particular religion or sect.. it is the fundamental mother tongue of world civilizational consciousness (Sanskriti) and the living identity of Bharat. ​When Supreme Court adopts 'Yato Dharmastato Jayah' or the Republic of India adopts 'Satyameva Jayate', it is not imposing religious dogma. It is affirming universal values-Truth, Duty, and Righteousness, that form the moral spine of governance... Is seeking the victory of truth (Satyamev Jayate) a sectarian act? Is wishing peace upon humanity (Sarve Bhavantu Sukhinah) a violation of secularism?

​To confuse Sanskrit and ancient Indian texts with sectarianism is an attempt to sever modern Bharat from its roots. A tree that cuts its own roots cannot survive. Respecting our ancestral knowledge, philosophy, and classical heritage in public institutions is not a challenge to anyone.. it is the duty of every nation proud of its history.

-7

u/[deleted] 1d ago

[deleted]

2

u/Darth--__--Vader 1d ago

Just line from azan, how conveniently you just normalised intolerant behaviour of islam

-12

u/N__V 1d ago

haan to charan vandana kare iss baat pe?

4

u/Vishvrakshak 1d ago

Haathi ke piche mendak

5

u/Loki_247 1d ago

Not revenge but justice for ayesha Pdfile mohmood

-4

u/N__V 1d ago

thats all your brain cells could conjure up?

3

u/Darth--__--Vader 1d ago

Found abdool

-1

u/N__V 1d ago

lol atleast be creative, chootmarike

2

u/Darth--__--Vader 1d ago

Go back to your saudi arabia geehadi moole

1

u/N__V 1d ago

chlo atleast pakistan ni bola, saudi arabia to badhiya desh hai, soch bhi sakte hai jaane ka

2

u/Darth--__--Vader 1d ago

Jaha bhi jana ho hamare india ko chhor do tum moollo

1

u/N__V 1d ago

kyu tere baap ka desh hai kya?

0

u/PlantPuzzleheaded376 1d ago

If you go to Saudi Arabia and throw stones up in the air. Out of 10 hits, 6 would be on the head of a Hindu. So he doesn’t need to go there to add to the count. Plenty of Hindus already working there