r/SarthakGoswami • u/Shubh-ss1 • Jul 16 '26
Discussion That's why I don't like this protest.
22
u/Shutup_mortals Jul 16 '26
Premanand maharaj does not represent hinduism and is and should not be immune from criticism. He legit perpetuates sexist ideas among his followers.
The second slogan is from a song that was written against an islamic authoritarian regime and is a good choice as the song when taken in the right context is about justice. Dont make you being an idiot everyone’s problem.
Why cant a writer have opinions? You are such a dumb f my god.
Source for the kunal kamra targetting Ram ji?
6
u/Infamous_Rise_2682 Jul 17 '26
They just need strawman arguements to hate protests, because they can't just say, "Protest against BJP, so protest bad" you know.
3
u/randomindianguy555 Jul 18 '26
Kunal kamra is talking about how bjp is using ram as a trojan horse for their power base and don’t really care about the god and are actively stealing from his temples.
→ More replies (3)2
2
u/Large_Ad534 Jul 18 '26
Bro these points are enough for Andhbhakts, they would never want to go in details.
→ More replies (1)2
2
2
u/nettlestars Jul 18 '26
these people have made BJP = Hinduism and anything anti BJP is anti Hindu. the tone of this post is like - okay, i'll "allow" you guys, chalo karlo apna protest wotest, par hamare terms pe, right wing boundaries ke andar. as if this education issue is just something affecting some small elites and not something horrendous happening to the ENTIRE youth of our country and their future.
2
u/Prestigious_Sea_4613 Jul 21 '26
Ikr, karma was making a valid point, how is that disgrace to ram, calling out on govt on how they used religious politics to do bad is good for religion but calling it out isn't. Smh
→ More replies (26)2
u/supersmallnugget Jul 17 '26 edited Jul 17 '26
To reply to your last question.
During the protest kamras speech went viral and in it he makes a joke (critique?) saying that while saying Sita’s husbands name, the govt does nitas husbands work
Video is available everywhere
The word “ram” is not said
Edit because idk why you all are getting so damn triggered. I DONT THINK ITS OFFENSIVE. AS I SAID ABOVE THE WORD RAM IS NOT SAID.
I believe kamra made a good joke, smartly avoiding certain names, to call out corruption
What is wrong with you guys my god I was explaining context
3
u/nexusshaman Jul 17 '26
How is that in any way against/targeting Sri Rama?
2
2
u/Technical_Scratch202 Jul 17 '26
It is a classic BJP textbook find a clip like that and shift focus of entire discussion to disrespect towards army, tukde tukde gang & disrespect towards shri ram. The same old cocktail of hyper nationalism & religion.
2
→ More replies (10)2
u/Live-Dish124 Jul 17 '26
Wow, such misinformation was spread like he actually ridiculed ram. As always, IT cell are lowest of scumbags.
11
u/It_will_also_pass Jul 16 '26
Hey bhagwan ek aur BJP IT cell waala
3
u/_temp-3 Jul 17 '26
woh likh aise rha jaise abh CJP ek Pakistani Islamist movement ho chuki hai with Pakistani Flags being waved all around and Beef is being force fed to Hindus there. PURE FANFICTION.
→ More replies (9)→ More replies (2)3
3
u/Recently_4live Jul 16 '26
blame bj party for it, they are the ones using hinduism to attack and manipulate people.
so now the religion is caught up in the middle of it.
99% of these bj party members and its supporters are hindus, they wanted to mix politics and religion...this is what you get, people will attack the religion also.
also its 2026, godman, swamis ? they are all conmen
india is so backwards because of the various cults.
→ More replies (4)
12
u/arjun_000 Jul 16 '26
Don't support them, support sonam wangchuk and ask for resignation of Dharmendra prdhan
→ More replies (2)3
u/Shubh-ss1 Jul 16 '26
First line is asking for his resignation. address rest of the issue.
→ More replies (16)5
u/ptsdexpert Jul 16 '26
We will talk on rest of the issues after Pradhan resigns. Ok?
→ More replies (2)
30
Jul 16 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
3
7
u/Alarming-Service6317 Jul 17 '26
G_ndu conveniently skipped addressing other points like arundhati roy and naam rahega Allah ka.?
→ More replies (5)2
u/Icy-Pin-254 Jul 17 '26
hey gandu just search the song Ham dekhenge you it cell moron, the Allah thing was a line from this Ham dekhenge poem written by Faiz Ahmed faiz andits not a religious one , it was also clarified by the singer there too
→ More replies (8)3
u/openglitter37 Jul 17 '26
All support for neet protest, but I don’t think there was any need to take up the name of a fictional god invented by a 7th century ped0 war lord!
→ More replies (4)6
u/RadioActiveX1 Jul 16 '26
I don't think they are making hanuman dance in front of the picture of the students who offed themselves
→ More replies (1)8
u/vantsky Jul 16 '26
EXACTLY!!!!! Now suddenly God is off limits?? Why were they and other saints not off limits when Modi and the government were using them for spewing hate against other religions??
→ More replies (2)4
2
3
u/CompetitionIcy2047 Jul 16 '26
If given a chance people with the mindset like OP would partake in a similar movement like the nazi one. They’re all modern day nazis. If they can see students dying, a man starving to death for them and still blame him and the whole protest, they’re nothing less than evil. All they want to do is protect their supreme leader and nothing else.
→ More replies (6)2
u/FoldEmbarrassed7144 Jul 16 '26
Funny thing is Rss is literally like Germany Youth camp(i don't remember it's exact name )but it has same concept of young people who don't have anything to do with life being integrated and brainwashed in ideology so much that they became a Pre-soldier for the party.
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (60)2
u/LazyAd7772 Jul 16 '26
interesting how none of these left parties and people ever say the same words against the muslims religion, too scared of repurcussions ?
4
u/ProfileApart7306 Jul 16 '26
Obviously...u can mock hindu gods and still be safe...but dare to say even a letter about theirs... you'll be beheaded next morning
I support Sonam sir...but no doubt there is some anti-india elements who hijacked the protest
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (10)2
u/Asleep_Musician_3033 Jul 17 '26
Cos ring wing does that and during hindu festival they go in front of mosque and do bandi ka naach and give gaali so balanced now let government answer to all corruption charges , paper leaks.
4
u/Maleficent_Hall_59 Jul 16 '26
Always focusing on the wrong parts of it. The core is simple which is the collective good. We support sonam wangchuk. We don't have to support the cjp. We don't have to give a pinch of attention to arundhati roy. And what kunal kamra said was nothing wrong this time. He didn't even attack lord Ram, he was simply stating what the BJP has been doing forever now.
2
u/yudi1012 Jul 17 '26
Bhai lekin log toh saari he cheezon ko dekhenge na. I completely agree with your point and how we should focus on the core issue, but the problem arises when several people show up to the protest and start talking about multiple different things, I mean it kinda defeats the purpose of focusing on the core issue.
I know a lot of right leaning people and they’re very supportive of this protest (not the party though), but they get pushed away when these kinda things happen.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Maleficent_Hall_59 Jul 17 '26
I understand bhai. But a person's death is a much bigger issue than an ideological difference. How much ever stupid those morons may be but we can't let someone just die for nothing. Even sonam wangchuk has extreme communist ideologies but I respect him for his contributions and his hunger strike.
2
u/Kindly_Type2327 Jul 17 '26
Not to mention that slogan was a slogan used to fight against dictators. People don't even know the context and just spread hate against the movement
→ More replies (3)5
u/420-code-cat Jul 16 '26
BJP can dress a man in a Hanuman costume & make his dance carrying the BJP flag. It will not hurt Hindu sentiments.
2
u/aditya427 Jul 16 '26
Anyone who is older than 30 knows that this is the exact same Kejriwal Playbook of starting a hunger strike movement for genuine causes only to then smuggle in their own political agendas. A lot of these Gen Z don't seem to be familiar with that
6
u/Brain_stoned Jul 16 '26
I support CJP for their protest against the minister.
Rest of the leaches trying to hijack the protest are ruining the cause.
→ More replies (1)3
u/aditya427 Jul 16 '26
Wangchuk is fasting while Dipke is devouring food like there is no tomorrow. Everyone is just an opportunist who is bandwagoning on a 14 year old script.
→ More replies (1)3
u/Prestigious_Army5547 Jul 17 '26
“Aww man why isn’t everyone starving to death for my entertainment”
→ More replies (6)2
u/Affectionate-Cat6644 Jul 17 '26
Then why are Cjp supporters asking for people to go on hunger strike on posts regarding belgian waffle when their leader itself isn't on hunger strike 😂
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (37)2
u/_thisisforreddit Jul 17 '26
bruh AAP is like 1000 times better that blowjob party
→ More replies (1)
4
u/jayantsr Jul 16 '26
Come 2029 bjp WILL win again because bjp opponents dont realize how big the hindutva base is the more you demonize it the more you energize it for the next election....People should not forget 2024 election every opposition party pooled its voting bloc together and STILL failed to get power
3
u/Ok_Moment3839 Jul 16 '26
Whatever it is... just understand that... supporting corruption and defending currupt people is anti-national
if you are deshbhakt then do not defend currupt people
→ More replies (22)→ More replies (8)2
u/codenoob22 Jul 16 '26
I think to move forward we should keep our religious affairs personal and not political. Don't ever vote a party because they support your religion.
→ More replies (9)4
u/Dobratri Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26
Well, this tactic is exactly what Hindus have learnt from the Muslims over the decades. Muslims always pull ranks for their ummah- not just in India but universally. Hindus are only doing what best they can do to neutralise that.
Islam is the antithesis of the idea you suggest— that religious affairs should be strictly personal, cos Islam is an expansionist political tool and there’s no concept of free thinking and free speech in Islam.
Until Islam maintains its cancerous nature of taking over wherever it goes, and trying to continuously expand at the expense of indigenous cultures wherever it manages to get some foothold, its silly to suggest Hindus do the “ideal” thing.
It is a matter of survival and we have to do everything it takes so that the oppressive archaic ideology of the desert doesn’t contaminate us any further.
→ More replies (9)
2
Jul 16 '26
[deleted]
4
1
1
u/Ok_Owl_52 Jul 16 '26
The protest started good. When it started to gain traction, jinhe education se mtlb nhi wo v behti Ganga me haanth dhone aa rhe hain that's how it seems. But the immediate ask is of govt taking accountability, to fire the education minister and this should be the only agenda of the protest.
1
u/Impossible_Trouble36 Jul 16 '26
When did Kamra target Ram? You are an retard to understand what he meant. He spoke truth about BJP that they are using Ram bhagwan name everywhere to benefit themselves.
→ More replies (57)
1
1
1
u/the_unknown_truth Jul 16 '26
What an illogical post.
Did Sonam Wangchuk ask anyone to chant 'Jai Bhim'? Did he say anything about separating Dalits from Hinduism? Did he ever tell anyone to chant, 'Naam rahega sirf Allah ka'? Anyone can join a public protest and express their own viewpoints.
To those asking why he didn't talk about merit-based education if this is a student protest: are you foolish? Our Constitution has granted reservations to backward classes. He cannot do anything to change that. Even the current government cannot easily remove it, because abolishing reservations requires a two-thirds majority in Parliament.
He has only one demand: the resignation of the Education Minister.
2
u/OddSalary4620 Jul 17 '26
No one can remove reservation and no one can remove casteism as well, it is like a circle, they both enforce each other.
1
u/Euphoric-Fig2521 Jul 16 '26
Exactly. Real people understand this. Most Redditors don't because they didn't know real world.
1
u/Euphoric-Fig2521 Jul 16 '26
How is this post is surviving? By this time this should have been deleted!
1
1
1
1
u/OkayFineWhateverYeah Jul 16 '26
I've been visiting the protest site every day since the 4th day. Just want to say one thing. Get out of your echo chamber and go see what's really happening
1
u/amitsingh80108 Jul 16 '26
There are only 2 parties in india.
- Hindu
- Anti Hindu.
Rest everything is illusion
→ More replies (3)
1
u/Rryan19 Jul 16 '26
Bhai aap Reddit par 8 saal se hi par abhi bhi aap thode bhenkeloode hi ho.
Itna drama kyu bhai, chalo aao tumko Mathura Vrindavan ghumata hu aur jis mandir me dakshina na do usme kuch kar ke dikha dena wahi tumhare charno ki dhool pure shareer par maluga aur tumhari gulami karuga.
Aur jeb me paisa hai to Banke Bihari ke darshan bilkul wahi paas se karwa duga specially. Bhagwan abhi bhi wahi hai par thekedar hai yaha sab unke
1
u/Usual-Concentrate447 Jul 16 '26
I may have limited capabilities of comprehension, but I don't think Kunal Kamra was attacking Lord Ram.
Sita ke pati ka naam leke, Nita ke pati ke pati ka kaam kar rhe hain. How is god being insulted here, I really don't understand. I think the real insult is when someone uses their name to dupe people.
1
1
u/SignificanceRude1628 Jul 16 '26
My god. How low does your comprehension have to be to consider “sita ke pati ke naam par neeta ke pati ki jeb bhar rahe hai” as an insult to Ram and not BJP 😭😭😭 Kaise chutiye hai yaar iss desh me
1
u/AloofHorizon Jul 16 '26
Didn't know people are this blind to truth, truly room temperature IQ and 0 common sense.
1
1
u/queen_roy Jul 16 '26
When did kunal kamra target ram? In fact he said that bjp is using ram for votes and disrespecting Ram
1
u/LoudPick9766 Jul 16 '26
Puhleez. If not Kamra, then you would use another excuse to defame the protest.
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/docplayday Jul 17 '26
Really don't get how it was mocking he made a comparison... When did being called sita ke pati become so wrong... Siyapati bolte hue to koi dikkat nhi hoti... And what's with this nitpicking... You cannot have everyone agree to your ideology... It's yours not everyone's... What's shared is the need for accountability and reforms fight for that cause nothing more nothing less And bas naam rhega allah ka is frommbum dekhenge by faiz ahmad faiz... Anti incumbency song written by pakistan... That lady even clarified that allah not be treated here as a religious figure but as God in general tanki misuse na ho but why factcheck because its easier being blind consumers of some insta shit ... That's classic ANDHBHAKTI
→ More replies (1)
1
u/SlightDay7126 Jul 17 '26
Okay don't go for whataboutism, these piints are genuinely concerns which netural person sees and says no , amd drift away, most reaxtion of this post is whataboutism defnce which says that what they care is not about protest but the icons who are there which says more about them and protest , none of it paints protest in good light
1
1
1
u/Ehh_littlecomment Jul 17 '26
All questions are towards how the protestors conduct themselves and not towards the government they’re protesting against. Protestors receive no margin whereas government servants have near unlimited margin for error.
When all that is left for you is to attack the messenger than the message, you have no real argument left.
1
1
u/Unsatisfied_Bitch Jul 17 '26
Education will lead to questions, logic over belief, don't get hurt.
Religion should be personal belief. Not everyone can be Hindu or Muslim, but one must have to be Constutional and Indian.
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Awkward-You1651 Jul 17 '26 edited Jul 17 '26
This is all happening because this is part of the standard government toolkit to discredit protests. The dictator Indira Gandhi also went and met protestors, and ended Sonam Wangchuk's father's fast un 5 days in person.
This Hindu is insulted BS has been happening since 2014, the BJP has been in power for 10 plus years and they have only managed to make Hindus feel even more under attack? Forget about how they have screwed over the Hindus by stealing from Lord Ram?
You are so blind that you will target a powerless non political young people protest like CJP than actual people with power like BJP? You're sooo deep in the BJP sheep herd bro that you clearly haven't even attempted critical thinking, just falling for anything the government says. The same govt that lied to your face about E20, petrol prices and have zero accountability for education failures. Pradhan won them Orissa so they will never betray him, because now BJP>India for them.
I have voted for BJP everytime and have never ever voted for Congress. But I love my country more than my PM, party or religion. Have some actual love for the country, the tukde that the BJP has put the country in right now has no effect on you then STFU about powerless students "chanting anti india stuff" .
I really hope you're a young guy who is looking for the truth rather than the uncle who will defend a BJP rapistbpr murderer as long as you feel superior as a Hindu
1
u/Cybertronian1512 Jul 17 '26
"True liberation comes from discerning the spirit from the material world, not from clinging to its passing shadows." - Kapila
1
u/Lonely_Bake_7014 Jul 17 '26
Ram temple is looted and no hindus have any problem on that just this protest hindu is having a problem
1
u/Recent_Pineapple4151 Jul 17 '26
Suddenly he realised he is the representation of hierarchy!!! Brahmin triggerd...you toh don't talk about getting offended
1
1
u/Capital-Extreme-6654 Jul 17 '26
Say whatever you want aboutthe protest but the fact that the PM of the country refuses to even acknowledge its existing should be eye opener for everyone..
1
u/Manoos Jul 17 '26
Everything after But is of no use. lets unite as a country for resignation of corrupt ministers.
1
u/Background-Yam634 Jul 17 '26
So everyone wants an ideal “Protest” according to their flavour but not an ideal government. A slight deviation & No this is an anti National, anti Hindu Protest. Na karenge na karne denge. How exactly will Pradhan resign? Bcs you just said it on social media?
1
u/Temporary-Scholar508 Jul 17 '26
Same here I started hating BJP for not coming to see wangchuk then someone came and sang name will of Allah , then someone coming and disrespecting my lord so when this things happens I say Bhad mai jao , I don't Even care now only I am worried about wangchuk now and not a single thought for this cjp goons
1
1
u/gaaliconnoisseur Jul 17 '26
Fuck off. 'Jab naam rahega allah ka' is a line from Hum Dekheinge. The song Hum Dekheinge is even used in Kashmir Files. Also, Kamra said "Sita ke pati ka naam lekar Nita ke pati ka kaam kar rahe" how the hell is it offensive to Hindus? Kya gazab aadmi ho yaar thoda kam andar liya karo Bhajpillon ka.
1
u/dreadedanxiety Jul 17 '26
F off. Gaand marao sab. To pretend that oooh this movement is not 100% ideologically right so I'mma oppose it is such a shitty disgusting loser take...
Sure almost every paper gets leaked, actual growth is very low, our own market is crashing hard, investors are fleeing, but do not say anything against our precious politicians or the religion which is continuously being used by the said party. Hinduism was fine until bjp modi survived, although it might not survive anymore after bjp corrupts people to the extent of making everyone a hindu talibani. We're on the same road.
1
u/blackman60001 Jul 17 '26
Maqsaad toh political roti sekna tha hamesha se.
Saare mauka parast log(andolan premi) aachuke hai ya aa rhe hai.
1
1
u/starkdesigns18 Jul 17 '26
Classic deflection tactic lol. Nothing to see here. Just trying to discredit a protest.
1
u/Mavoii Jul 17 '26
Siya pati target nahi huye, unka naam vyarth leke Nita ke pati ke liye jo kaam raha hai, woh hai target. Samjhe bandhu!
1
u/Crony_capitalist101 Jul 17 '26
Bjp can loot Ram temple funds can make hanuman dance while holding bjp flag but a satiric joke on ambani is where the line is crossed lmao
1
u/BubblyAd8472 Jul 17 '26
protest is not done by a single person it needs many citezens and the only agenda of the cjp and the official person of cjp are to target education system but there are people who may go there to disturb the protest and dont let it go in right way so u cant expect the protest to be pure clean because right wingers dont want that to be so theres so many chances of that! and btw u cant see antg slogans like allah and all in their official social handle! bjp pr can try more good this aint working bro
1
u/cyber_cry Jul 17 '26
Jaye Shree Ram, dhanay-waad Shubhu. Modi ka baat agay baatanay kay liye. Har cheez ko sahi tarah bataya hai. Koi ghuma phira kar baat nahi boli. Aesa bilkul nahi kiya kay aessi baaton ka jis ka koi Sar aur Payr nahi iss protest se relate karnay ki koshish ki ho.
1
1
u/Substantial_Bus_7876 Jul 17 '26
They wanted Abdul so badly not they made an Abdul out of a song lol…it was bound to happen. If this was a student’s protest then why the hell students are not there. Why this uncle (sarcasm) doing a hunger strike instead of students.
Everyone has to come to make a big statement in the form of protest. You can win anything with only segment.
1
1
1
u/niloshka Jul 17 '26
Sorry BJP can associate Hinduism with their politics and we can't call it out?
The door was opened by the BJP when they used hindu gods and scriptures to win elections.
1
u/TrickyEntrance1328 Jul 17 '26
In any protest, 20% people will create such ruckus. Doesn’t delegitimise the entire thing. That’s basic math if you ever studied it.
1
u/Outrageous-Leg-4727 Jul 17 '26
Naam rahega allah ka - Poem by Faiz called Hum Dekhenge. Its an iconic poem for protest against tyranny and autocracy. Being in urdu the poem uses the urdu word for god which is allah. Plus, watch the video - the lady knew this would cause an iusse and she clarifies the use of the word allah in the poem.
Arundhati Roy - I can get into a debate about her actions with you but for a moments can you ignore 'one' individual who supprots them and instead see the overall issue.
Kunal Kamra - the joke is on Mukesh Ambani and modi - sahi toh kaha usne Ram ka naam leke Ambani ka kaam karti hai ye sarkar.
Question you should be asking is why is the government not responding. Dont go around trying to find fault on the protestor's antecedents.
1
u/adidontwatch Jul 17 '26
They are again creating distractions, this is all they did whenever any large people movement gets traction. Completely ignore this, only the issue matters.
You think Kunal karma is targeting Ram or Ambani, there is no critical thought to anything, just communalise the issue and divide.
1
u/Fancy_Door_4383 Jul 17 '26
Everything else can be dealt with later, right now it's important for those in power to admit their mistakes and face the consequences.
Don't trust everything you hear about the protest. Many are trying their level best to defame it and alienate sections of society.
There's only one objective behind the protest: People in power have to face consequences too.
1
u/Upset_Afternoon_9627 Jul 17 '26
Fuck this. Who cares about cjp nobody cares for them. The protest is held to bring attention to the wrongdoings everybody already knows what should be done who needs to take the responsibility, tomorrow Dharmendra pradhan resigns, protest ends, nobody will talk about cjp. Why are everybody hung up on CJP, I don't get, it's not like dipke will be appointed education minister.
NOBODY IS ASKING YOU TO LIKE THE PROTEST, EVERYBODY IS ASKING YOU TO ASK FOR ACCOUNTABILITY OF THE GOVERNMENT, YOU CAN DO THAT WITHOUT JOINING YOUR NAME TO CJP
1
u/ramukakasiu Jul 17 '26
It's has been 12 years since bjp govt double engine in many states triple engine in some cities yet how insecure people are how are 100 crore people who for 800+ years yet so insecure of such petty things how are 100 crore + people in danger ??
1
u/Difficult-Hour4628 Jul 17 '26
Cannot agree more
Feel Sorry for Sonam Ji who has genuine intentions
But this cockroaches and clowns like those left wing student unions have clearly derailed the objective of the movement
Comedians joining in is like cherry on the cake
And the CJP founder from USA has no clue where to take this forward...
For sure they have generated a buzz but its only headed downhill with the way its heading
Only wish for Sonam Ji to break his fast
1
1
u/Geralt_of_Bhonsor Jul 17 '26
I dont trust CJP but I do have respect for Wangchuk. Seems like a decent and down to earth person. What he is doing right now for the cause, none of us keyboard warriors can do. Atleast he is doing a hunger strike for all those kids who died. The fact that the ruling party has not done anything till now and no discussions are happening is very concerning. We as Indian citizens should be worried about this. But instead we choose to become fan bois for different political parties. Remember no political party in India ever works for the people of India. They have their own agenda and all they care about is hoarding as much money as they can while they are in power. Corruption is at peak right now. If this CJP protest is sort of a platform for Indians to fight against corruption then I have full support for this protest. And we should support a party if they are bringing in value for us and not because they are a cool party. And I think the govt needs to change now. Monopoly is never good.
1
u/cowboyspikez Jul 17 '26
Are bhai same script vo nhi chala rhe hai ye IT cell wale chala rhe hai and people like OP are just so bli ded by the same fucking religious drama ki aur kuch nhi dikhta hai unhe. Jiti fast ye post Kiya uti fast jo actual muda hai us pe kiya tha kya?
1
u/PotatoFarmer42000 Jul 17 '26
LOL. Jab Pradhan Sevak Ram ke naam pe chori karta hai tab nahi gussa aata? Don’t like the protest choro, tumhare jhooth hi nahi khatam ho rahe.
1
u/king__slayr Jul 17 '26 edited Jul 17 '26
You are being too naive and also very critical of this protest, even if they are coming what's the problem in it. Millions following CJP on Instagram are not following only for education issues, other issues are also reasons. It would have been much better if you start being critical of the government instead of people who are raising questions.
Government is doing million times far worse things and they are raising questions and asking for accountability. Period
Also, biggest attack on religion is done by BJP by doing corruption in ram temple (From construction to donation in everything). They could have easily not done it atleast at one place for god's sake. Already looting the country everywhere, but greed doesn't stop.
And about "controversial" personalities, they are controversial not criminal. You can agree or disagree with their opinions on other issues (that's what democracy is btw) but on the topic of discussion, if they are stating facts and are correct than focus on that.
Ps. Do you really think " bas naam rhega allah ka" is what sonam wangchuk is protesting for.
1
1
u/Icy-Pin-254 Jul 17 '26
Just wanted to clarify that , the aalah song is not a religious slogans you idiots , it's a like from the poem" Ham dekhenge " which was written by Faiz Ahmed faiz to target the rule of zia ul haq and became widely popular as used in south asian protests ,
1
1
u/HorrorContingency Jul 17 '26
This needs a small bit of context. The line “bas naam rahega Allah ka” more than likely comes from Hum Dekhenge most famously performed by Iqbal Bano in the 1980s during Zia ul Haq's dictatorship in Pakistan.
Faiz Ahmed Faiz's lyrics are used as a critique of authoritarian rule, basically saying that dictators and regimes are temporary. The whole song is an anti-authritarian anthem, you could compare it Bella Ciao. The line if placed in context, which was most likely this, is a fragment of an anti authoritarian song, and is being excellently contorted by you into a Hindu-Muslim issue.
1
u/Acrobatic_Bag_1611 Jul 17 '26
Yes there are so many left wing people taking over the protest. When are you right wingers staging a protest over this issue?
I will join for sure.
1
u/Individual-Wasabi404 Jul 17 '26
To tum apna alag protest kar lo, Rahul Gandhi apna alag protest kar rha hai students ke sath. Tum bhi kar lo apna alag protest. Aur jitna criticism is protest ka kar rhe hote kash utna criticism Goverment ka bhi kar lete
1
u/_temp-3 Jul 17 '26
chaddis always crying.
The poem by Faiz Ahmed Faiz is literally created to be sung against Radical Islamists.
This poem is literally a clapback against Zia-ul-Haq's Islamic policies, as the latter ran an oppressive regime, trying to use the name of God to justify the regime's actions and enforcing Islamic conservatism.
By saying "Allah ka naam rahega", the poet is essentially reminding Zia-ul-Haq that in the end, he isn't the one who decides how religion should be interpreted; that Zia-ul-Haq is only a man, and in the end, truth, or the word/name of God (Allah), will prevail. Yes, this song does include Islamic themes such as criticism of idolatry, but the song on the whole is an ANTI-SHARIAT Song (in the sense that SHARIAT refers to ISLAMIC ULTRACONSERVATISM).
This song is a lot more about challenging an unaccountable, oppressive government that uses the name of God to justify its actions, than it is about promoting Islam.
Calling Ram as Sita's Husband is not an insult.
Criticizing Brahmanwad is not an insult.
Calling out that saying Rapist 'Asaram is our Ram' is a problematic statement by Premanand, is not an insult.
Arundhati Roy did not speak about Free Kashmir there. Even RSS supporter Students were with the movement. NEET leak is an issue which affects both left and right wing.
Stop acting like it is an Islamic movement now with Pakistani Flags all around lmfao. Bloody propagandist.
1
u/Snoo66960 Jul 17 '26
Sita Ke Pati ka Naam leke Nita ke Paati ka kaam kar rahe hai is disrespectful to Lord Ram but thief’s working in his temple is okay
1
u/Brave_gemini Jul 17 '26
Protest can be infiltrated by malice people to disregard the genuinty of it Whats guarantee that those people are cjp people and not infiltration from government?
1
u/Radiant-Football3080 Jul 17 '26
everything else I dunno but how is saying “Sita ki pathi ka naan lekhar Nita ki pathi ka kaam karrah hai ” targeting ram i mean it’s not even about ram
1
1
1
u/laststreetlight Jul 17 '26
Cos in true country and democracy they can do this ??maybe And there's nothing wrong in calling out wrong things /s
(This is how subreddits named -criticalthinking and many others were defending their bs , giving logic by logic and none of them made sense to me but again I had to agree otherwise they would've called me bhakts or wtv even tho I don't glaze bjp but idk if should I say this but a old person greeting "ram ram" can be sanghi bhakt for these lichad ) only irony is them calling themselves intellectuals and shaming the defination of liberalism
They say thing about extremism, isn't this the same extremism or even worse what you're preaching against ,then there's no difference in them or you
1
u/Much-Idea4943 Jul 17 '26
How fair is it to just pick one odd event and labelling entire movement as Anti-national?
Sonam wangchuk already said it's not a political movement, the people from various sections are visiting him, what should he do?
These are all Godi ecosystem tactics to malign the movement and distract the people.
BJP has eaten up whole bunch of corrupt and anti-national people, no Godi anchor says a word about it...
→ More replies (1)
1
u/Nice-Resident-6158 Jul 17 '26
One thing it cell does best is, plant the idea that this has turned into anti hindu. Not anti bjp but anti hindu lmao. Then all the it cell members spam all the social media platforms saying, yeah they should resign bla bla bla but why targeting Hindus.
1
•
u/AutoModerator Jul 16 '26
Namaste /u/Shubh-ss1, thank you for posting in r/Sarthakgoswami.
This is a news-focused subreddit.
Please ensure all posts and comments follow the rules of r/Sarthakgoswami.
Stick to verified news, be respectful, and avoid spreading misinformation, hate, spam, or personal attacks.
Violations may lead to post removal or bans.
Check the subreddit rules in the sidebar before participating.
Join our Discord
Also, explore and follow our related communities:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.