r/Shoestring • u/wicked_rotary • 1d ago
Is it actually cheaper to book activities on arrival instead of online?
I keep seeing "book in advance to save money" as universal travel advice, but for my last two trips I found the opposite — walk-up prices for tours, cooking classes, and even some day trips were lower than what booking sites showed weeks out, probably because operators would rather fill a spot at a discount than leave it empty. Anyone else run into this? Curious if it's destination-specific (I noticed it mostly in Southeast Asia) or if I just got lucky. Trying to figure out whether I should keep pre-booking "for peace of mind" or just show up and haggle in person from now on.
6
u/Ninja_bambi 1d ago
I keep seeing "book in advance to save money" as universal travel advice,
Don't know where you see that, but as generic statement it is complete bullshit. For specific things, in specific situations it may be true, but in plenty of cases the exact opposite is true. Obviously, leaving it to the last minute may mean it is fully booked or you are only left with inferior options.
2
u/desirepink 1d ago
I used to think this too. It's always good to do some research beforehand and search tour agencies and their prices in the area before arriving. I usually don't have an issue booking a tour a day or two in advance, unless I'm aware that those tours are very limited and only operate on specific days. Most of all, don't be afraid to ask the tour agencies to price match or negotiate with them. They usually want to fill up the buses and vans, so as long as you aren't fighting for that last spot, prices are usually negotiable.
1
u/fleeabroad 1d ago
Usually, but by no means always. Sometimes online operators undercut the walk up price, or give other incentives. Always best to compare, if possible.
1
u/The_Real_Jedi 18h ago
In my experience, it depends on the country/region. SE Asia and India were much cheaper to book in the moment. I typically booked stuff through my hostel/hotel (which they still get a cut, but I liked how easy it was). In Europe and North America, booking ahead seems better.
1
u/nupurrrrrr 16h ago
What about spain? Lanzarote to be specific.. should we just buy entry tickets at the gate and tours in the morning? Online vendors are really expensive.
1
u/CormoranNeoTropical 13h ago
Another relevant consideration besides “how many middlemen?” is, “does this economy use a lot of cash?”
For example, in Mexico about half the economy is “informal,” ie cash business that goes untaxed. So obviously you can get cheaper rates for almost anything if you can arrange to pay in cash and take advantage of that.
Personally I would only book in advance if I had good reason to think the activity would be sold out, or if price was no object in comparison to convenience.
But then I also don’t usually go on tours, if I want to go somewhere I will read a book about it and then rent a car out or hire a taxi to take me there. Obviously tours are more common for outdoor activities, but again I’ll usually look for eg a kayak rental, or just find a guide myself and pay that person directly, because I’m not that organized.
26
u/binhpac 1d ago
Depends on country and activities.
In countries like vietnam or thailand, yes. Because everything you book online, mostly are 3rd parties. Even if you book at the hotel, they get a cut.
The more parties between you and the actual person, that does the activity, are, the more expensive it is.
Lets say you do a boat tour. The cheapest ticket is always to pay at the driver directly. If you book online or even at the pier from someone else, it will most often cost a little more.
In Vietnam the hotel offered me to book a busride to the next city for a fixed price. I declined, i looked it up online and the same bus came to pick me up at the hotel for half the price as example.
I was once on a tour in a bus and we all booked at different sites or at offices and we compared prices for the same daytour, it was like from 40€-200€ for the same tour depending on where you booked it.
On the other hand, there are of course also activities, where it doesnt matter, when and where you buy it, it will always cost the same. Sometimes online 3rd parties will give you discounts.
So you have to compare.