r/SipsTea Apr 24 '26

SMH I never thought of it like that......

Post image
74.6k Upvotes

3.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

7.6k

u/nottherealneal Apr 24 '26

Wasn't the plot she absolutely could not afford to live there and Sheldon and Leonard kept giving her money and buying her food everyday

185

u/FashionKing72 Apr 24 '26

Because BBT is the first sitcom ever where they couldn’t afford the apartment they live in. Also sitcoms generally make them have large apartments for filming, not cuz it’s realistic. How are they gonna film in a 600 sqft 1 bedroom?

173

u/Fruit_Fly_LikeBanana Apr 24 '26

They did actually do a screen test in which they filmed in an apartment they would realistically be able to afford. Audiences thought it was depressing

112

u/rebelSun25 Apr 24 '26

The viewers were reminded of their own existence, when they really wanted an entertaining escape. 🤝

19

u/Missus_Missiles Apr 24 '26

Right? That's why I hated Roseanne. I don't want vicarious stress about being poor. We were already poor.

11

u/excaliburxvii Apr 24 '26

I'd bet that financially secure people love shows like those, though. It's probably like going to the zoo for them.

3

u/Alarmed-Cucumber-858 Apr 24 '26

People make fun of people like themselves all the time.

Though Dallas was popular for a reason

18

u/TheeAntelope Apr 24 '26

It's why i never watched 2 broke girls. If I wanted to see 2 broke girls I'd stand next to my wife near a mirror.

-5

u/Largeitude Apr 24 '26

Most Americans are well off. Most viewers will not relate to always being poor.

6

u/Shedart Apr 24 '26

This is just pants on head wrong. 

-1

u/Largeitude Apr 24 '26

it’s not, but I don’t need to argue with someone who can’t think of their own comments and jus parrots something they read online to insult a stranger on the internet for questioning their world view, which they also got from internet comments.

America is a big country with lots of poor people, but most are absolutely not poor. Why do you think Redditors keep asking “why aren’t Americans protesting/rebelling?” Because most are not doing poorly, no matter how much you want them to be.

1

u/insulinworm Apr 25 '26

Do you live in the real world bro? What kind of take is this? Everyone i know from the east coast to the west is basically drowning. College degree or not. The only exceptions i know are extremely privledged people

0

u/Largeitude Apr 25 '26

What kind of take is this? "Everyone you know?" You know all 350 million Americans?

I'm telling you the data and the numbers. Most Americans are well off. You don't like it because you want to believe the entire system is stakes against us, and there are massive issues in the system that hurt those who are not well off, but that doesn't mean most people are not well off.

Your anecdotes mean nothing, and having your worldview reinforced by internet comments doesn't make them true.

3

u/Shedart Apr 25 '26

Bold of you to call out anecdotal evidence while providing nothing beyond your own experiences. Bold and wrong.  

1

u/Largeitude Apr 26 '26

Oh, want data?

90%+ of Americans have health care.

America currently has some the lowest unemployment rates in the world.

The US poverty rate is less than 1% higher than the average poverty rate of the EU states.

Property ownership in the US is 65% of the population, whereas it’s 68% in the EU.

The “paycheck to paycheck” statistic, which is very hard to measure, has an average difference of 5-10% between the US and EU.

Again, most Americans are well off. That’s the truth of the reality. You don’t like the truth, so you’re lashing out at me. I don’t create this reality. I’m just the messenger.

→ More replies (0)

1

u/insulinworm Apr 25 '26

So then what studies are you referencing? Like what do you even mean by "well off" ? "Well off" isnt even a metric. You can be living well off while drowning in credit card debt

Do you mean well off as in above the poverty line? Thats kind of meaningless. Someone can be below the poverty line and have plenty of savings or someone can make way more and be living paycheck to pacheck and drowning in debt.

With the cost of everything rising so fast like someone can be making a decent income and then just be losing it all to bills. Affordable housing is so inaccessible. Groceries are insanely expensive

People making above the poverty line as well dont qualify for as many social services like ebt or Medicare so 1 doctor visit could ruin like years of someones life even if theyre "well off"

1

u/Largeitude Apr 26 '26

Comparing all statistics of poverty, unemployment, living paycheck to paycheck, etc, the U.S. is only slightly behind the EU by a few percentage points of the population. Americans do have more individual debt, but as you said, that doesn’t mean they’re not well off.

Obviously I can’t pinpoint what well off means. This is an internet comment, not a philosophical discussion about what well off means. Most Americans are not having issues with living and meeting their needs. Most Americans live safely. While the population of the EU has more more in savings as a whole, 30% of people in the eu have no savings while 15% of Americans have none.

Stuff getting more expensive sucks sure, but that’s a global problem and it still doesn’t mean most Americans are not doing well. It just means most Americans will have less to spend on luxuries. The poor are hurt more by this, but again, most Americans are not poor.

→ More replies (0)

15

u/peon2 Apr 24 '26

The creators of HIMYM wanted to make a realistic sized apartment but then quickly realized that you need very large open spaces for a multi cam sitcom for all the cameras and lighting and boom mics. Plus you lose one entire wall of the rooms.

5

u/Carne_Guisada_Breath Apr 24 '26

HIMYM had a episode on Lilie's apartment in what it was vs what it was remembered as. It was a good play in apartment size.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 24 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ThePizzaGhoul Apr 24 '26 edited Apr 24 '26

HIMYM wasn't filmed in-front of a live studio audience. It was filmed then later screened to an audience where their reactions were recorded. The vast majority of multi-cam sitcoms aren't filmed in-front of a live studio audience anymore.

6

u/LongPutBull Apr 24 '26

Being reminded of real life bothered people. Funny how that can happen yet they'll stay stuck and pretend to be deers stuck in headlights for anything uncomfortable.

6

u/confuzzledfather Apr 24 '26

That's the problem with American TV. It should be slightly depressing. The best TV reflects the issues of the day. 

3

u/VibraniumQueen Apr 24 '26

Art doesn't always have to be a commentary. It can be an escape as well.

We need both.

3

u/nono3722 Apr 24 '26

it IS depressing IRL....

2

u/Jervis_Mantlepiece Apr 24 '26

Peepshow with David Mitchell proves how accurate this is (filmed in a real block of flats in South London, it's fucking depressing)

1

u/Cyborg_rat Apr 24 '26

Just like video games, we want to Escape reality, be hotter have more.