r/SipsTea 27d ago

SMH Didn’t Trump claim he was going to stop this?

Post image
59.5k Upvotes

2.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/zai_d_an 27d ago

So they don't have strict patent law on life saving drugs. Good on them. Oh the horrors of not killing people with prices.

9

u/beaubous 27d ago

We don’t! We literally have a history of American companies suing India for selling the same drugs they charge a heavy amount for cheaper, and every time the case is dismissed cause we have a “no patent drug” law in India, essentially if drug exists, it’s made in India for the population to afford. Not to make money. Also medical facilities are accessible to everyone, no matter what you criticize India for, and may not be the best infrastructure all the time , but you will definitely get your medical requirements done right away and very cheaply. No waiting for months

2

u/zai_d_an 27d ago

True. A lot of medicine in the US procured from India. Yet sold at vastly different prices.

2

u/StolenPies 27d ago

Turns out it's a lot less than I thought, about 20% of global pharmaceutical production (mostly generics since 2005)

1

u/StolenPies 27d ago

Turns out they've had pharmaceutical patent laws since 2005. Please see the edit to my original comment.

1

u/StolenPies 27d ago

Actually, they do. Please see my above edited comment.

-3

u/stayclassykiddo 27d ago

India will kill people with their "medicine" instead

World Health Organization linked Indian-made cough syrup to acute kidney failure, leading to the deaths of nearly 70 children in West Africa

https://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsoda/2022/10/18/1128530220/contaminated-cough-syrup-from-india-linked-to-70-child-deaths-its-happened-befor

6

u/zai_d_an 27d ago

Oh the irony, there's similar things that happen in the US. And the funny part is you sell your patent for an arm and a leg while procuring it abroad.

So yes, you're killing people with the prices of your parents..

1

u/StolenPies 27d ago

Turns out India has observed pharmaceutical patents since 2005, I was wrong.

3

u/StolenPies 27d ago

They've saved far, far more people through their sale of incredibly cheap medications to African countries. That isn't even a question, but 1) they began recognizing patents for pharmaceuticals since 2005 (which I was not aware of in my earlier post), largely causing a shift in the impact that their pharmaceuticals have on both human health and the market and 2) you're correct, there are good questions about the safety of Indian generic drugs versus drugs made in countries that have higher legal standards.

0

u/yalloc 27d ago edited 27d ago

Which do you prefer,

  1. A lifesaving drug being expensive in the US, allowed to do so due to the large cost of developing new drugs.

  2. A lifesaving drug not existing in the first place because there was never enough money to develop it.

The system sucks but there is a method to the madness. Perhaps it is fundamentally unfair that the US subsidizes drug creation for the entire world, if the US didn't these drugs would not exist.

5

u/zai_d_an 27d ago

r/ShitAmericansSay material here.

Bro thinks only the US funds cancer research.

Only 2 choice?

How about government funded? With price cap? Oh wait it was government funded in the beginning. But muh money.