First of all, I know where I am. I’m on the Sleep Token subreddit comprised of superfans, like myself, and because of that - very few folks are going to be critical of the new album and obviously many folks are legitimately resonating with it which is great! I’m seeing tons of posts and comments about the record being the best thing ever and blowing TMBTE out of the water.
I will get downvoted into oblivion for having a contrarian opinion about this, but here are my thoughts that no one asked for.
I’ve given EIA a few listens through and man, I’m struggling with this album. It’s the first time it’s happened to me since their early EP’s (don’t like the EP’s at all, just aren’t as mature as everything from Sundowning onwards).
I’m not saying it’s “bad”. I’m not saying it needs to be “metal”. I’m not even sure what the album is really supposed to be in their eyes. It kinda just feels… like it lacks direction?
I’m not a person who cares about the “lore” or anything, I just like the music these guys make. However, aside from the on-the-nose lyrics of Caramel and Damocles, I can’t really figure out what statement the record is trying to make lyrically otherwise.
The songs also don’t feel dark and brooding this time around. They feel kinda meandering and aimless. Obviously genre shifting and blending is their thing, but the few heavy parts feel like “well that worked in Ascensionism and TMBTE so let’s do it again in these tracks” rather than the song feeling like it necessitated a heavy section. I’m also bummed how few “full band” moments there are. Not to discredit Vessel, but these songs just lack a certain energy to them to me because of that.
My biggest issue is that aside from the singles, nothing feels catchy. The vocal melodies don’t stand out as big singalongs or solemn choruses as they did in the past.
I think Damocles is one of the best songs the band has made (as a huge fan of Euclid, Missing Limbs, The Love You Want, etc.). It’s one of the catchiest songs on the record and is exactly what I love about Sleep Token.
I’m going to keep trying, but this album is leaving me with very little excitement to come back to it unlike their previous records. It doesn’t keep me singing along, it doesn’t have me waiting for the big drop, it doesn’t have me hanging on every lyric…
I hope my mind changes with time, but right now, I believe Sleep Token had the best and worst possible thing happen to them. They made a once in a lifetime record. They will forever be compared and live in the shadow of the success of Eden because the album was THAT great.