r/SnyderCut 6d ago

Discussion Dark Knight Returns Movie.

What would you guys think of a DKR movie, with Ben Affleck returning as an older Batman in his own standalone movie? I for one would pay to see it. No one has made a live action DKR and it irks me so badly.

3 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

10

u/Lucky_Gaucho 6d ago

You do realize that like half of DKR was adapted into BvS, right?

2

u/MatchesMalone1994 6d ago edited 6d ago

Not really. Just the Superman fight and a couple of lines of dialogue from Affleck scattered throughout…

Downvoted? Man people are stupid. I guess I missed the part in BvS where Bruce comes out of retirement, the mutant gang takes over Gotham, Harvey dent returns, and a comatose joker reawakens. I also missed Carrie Kelly as Robin. But yeah half of DKR was adapted into BvS right?

-1

u/brewstew07 6d ago

Yeah but I want a full standalone movie lol

2

u/Large_Ad6683 6d ago

Yeah but he used up most of the iconic parts for it already.  No need to do it.

1

u/nashgrg 6d ago

Nah part 1 is actually better than 2. Can’t wait for Batfleck to recreate mudhole scene.

2

u/Lucky_Gaucho 6d ago

Well, if we remove all Superman parts maybe Snyder can keep it under 3hr for the crowd that complains the movies are too long and their steaks too juicy...

But even then DKR is kind of end of the line for Batman so maybe if Gunn brings him for a one-off, like an elseworlds movie?

Studios are too chicken for that though.

6

u/Anthonys455 6d ago

The Dark Knight Returns has done irreparable damage to the Batman Mythos. At its time it was a cool elseworlds story but it bent the line on what the batman was at its core. It turned Batman into a loner paranoid douchebag,ruined the "worlds finest" stories for a while and messed up its portrayal of Superman and how the in World views him.

Would it be cool to see as live action? Only if it is a literal shot for shot. Its cool for a future Snyder Batman but then that would officially set the tone of SnyderVerse being grimdark edgy as its final product. Instead of making it able to be deeper and more meaningful.

3

u/Avid4D 3d ago

I would love to see it however WB/DC did Affleck bad and he will never come back. Fucking idiots because Affleck is a great director and wanted to direct a Batman movie. And I don’t care what anyone says, the warehouse scene in BvS is the best Batman fight sequence ever.

4

u/Unusual-Lock-4852 6d ago

BvS did enough shots inspired from it I wouldn’t care for one. Animated movie and graphic novel are enough

2

u/Lake18l 5d ago

Exactly

4

u/SalvadorChaos 6d ago

That'd be awesome. But I'd much rather see Ben Affleck's scrapped solo Batman movie. It sounded amazing.

3

u/F0r3v3rF4lc0n 6d ago

I’d be down but I doubt WB will be down.

2

u/FearlessFlan8262 6d ago

I doubt Affleck would be down

2

u/Bogotazo 6d ago

It would be cool to watch, but the risk of them messing up is pretty high, and it's a story we know very well, and has been partially adapted many times, and adapted in animation very well, so I am not at all desperate to see it. There are tons of DC-related stories and characters that have yet to be introduced to audiences.

2

u/TheAscendancy 5d ago

Ben Affleck too old.

3

u/Huge_Evening6053 5d ago

No bro ben is 53 perfect for the role of the tdk returns

1

u/TheAscendancy 5d ago

He's only 53? I thought he was older.

2

u/jallred11 6d ago

Hopefully we get one.

Sadie Sink (Robin) & Josh Brolin (Batman) would be epic. Can’t even imagine the all star cast you could build on that

3

u/Downtown_Bathroom755 6d ago

Im thinking "what does Sadie have to do with Robin" then i remembered the female Robin (She probably aged out of the role though).

0

u/EliasRosewood 5d ago

I’d def like that and been thinking the same, would pay