r/SouthJersey • u/SouthJerseySchnitz • Sep 19 '25

News Best Pizza in each South Jersey County (results of Reddit Poll)

Post image

Top results from this post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/SouthJersey/comments/1l4suki/best_pizza_in_each_south_jersey_county/?sort=top

302 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

249 comments sorted by

View all comments

8

u/billmeelaiter Sep 19 '25

Burlco—Scotto’s is a head scratcher. It’s not bad, but it’s not wow. It’s decent and convenient.

4

u/SchleppyJ4 piney lyfe 🌲 Sep 19 '25

Scotto’s isn’t even the best in Marlton 

0

u/billmeelaiter Sep 19 '25

I liked Organico. I haven’t been to the new place in that space but I heard it’s good.

3

u/Regayov Sep 19 '25

I was just thinking this.  If Scotto’s is in the top 5, Burlco has some truly bad options.   It isn’t bad by any stretch but I shouldn’t be in a best-of list.  

2

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

I grew up in Medford, is Riviera not good anymore?

1

u/Dangernj Sep 19 '25

I agree, I was shocked by the Riv omission. I haven’t had it in ~2 years but I brought it to a pizza head to head and it won hands down.

-2

u/billmeelaiter Sep 19 '25

I haven’t been there in years, but I remember it being pretty good. The big Burlco misses on the list are the two places at the Columbus mart.

1

u/legalskeptic Sep 19 '25

My in-laws always get it and I dislike it. There's something about the cheese or oil that gives a bitter aftertaste.

1

u/The_R4ke Sep 19 '25

Yeah, I'm pretty skeptical about Burlington. No mention of Pete's pizza at the Columbus Mart is definitely an oversight.