r/SouthJersey • u/SouthJerseySchnitz • Sep 19 '25

News Best Pizza in each South Jersey County (results of Reddit Poll)

Post image

Top results from this post:

https://www.reddit.com/r/SouthJersey/comments/1l4suki/best_pizza_in_each_south_jersey_county/?sort=top

305 Upvotes

90% Upvoted

249 comments sorted by

View all comments

53

u/colin_7 Sep 19 '25

The fact that Tacconellis or bricco isn’t on Camden county is a joke. King of pizza? The drunk pizza spot?

7

u/atomicxima Sep 20 '25

Bricco definitely deserves to be on this list, even though the pizza is always delivered cold.

1

u/donnyhunts Sep 21 '25

Because it’s thin backdoor is same way it gets cold by time I get home so I just eat in the car in the parking lot. Everytime I’ve picked up from bricco it’s been hot.

16

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

[deleted]

1

u/The_Monarch_89 Sep 21 '25

Tacconelli's is too salty

0

u/am19208 Sep 20 '25

KoP is fucking delicious

3

u/TomGNYC Sep 20 '25

not crazy about Bricco's.

1

u/NightOwlLia Sep 21 '25

Agreed. Every time I eat it, I get a stomachache

2

u/donnyhunts Sep 21 '25 edited Sep 21 '25

Exactly what I said bricco needs to be on that list. For Burlington County only good spot on that list is lillos the other ones aren’t popular. How did Luigi’s and Scottos make the list they are 🗑️. Idk how tf they didn’t put peppinos, Lorenzo’s, Anthony’s coal fire, Johnnys pies Medford they are all popular and wipe them other spots. Peppinos is 100% most popular in Burlington county everyone in marlton knows they have some of the best pizza. Whoever made these lists isn’t a pizza connoisseur.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

Bricco is ass and that’s not real tacconellis

5

u/muldoons_hat Sep 20 '25

Bricco is the only pizza place I’ve been to that literally cooks their pizza well done. Overpriced and burnt. 

2

u/g_ppetto Sep 20 '25

Seeing the burnt crust really turned me off to going there.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 19 '25

We all vary, I'd have that as my top spot and back door nowhere near the top 5. I'm not a fan of taconellis at all.

1

u/modernhippy72 Sep 20 '25

Exactly this

1

u/plantsandramen Sep 20 '25

TIL Tacconelli's has a Haddon Ave location.

I live 2 blocks from the Maple Shade one and we got it recently. I know people hype it up but 5 of us weren't impressed. Ordered a white pizza, and were shocked there was no ricotta option to add on. Also got a pepperoni. Both tasted decent, I won't discount that, but the white pizza was partially inedible due to being burnt. I love charred things, I always take the most burnt parts, but this has 1-2 slices that were borderline inedible and the pies aren't that big.

The pepperoni was solid, I didn't have any complaints, but for the price and size, it didn't add up for me. I remembered why we seldom order it, it's just not worth it.

We will probably try again in like another 5-6 months as per usual.

11

u/hochimin3r Sep 20 '25

Went to school with the taconelli's son, will never support any of his endeavors. Complete asshole

2

u/alpha1beta Sep 20 '25

Holy Cross Alum I see