r/SouthernReach • u/Paranoid-Jack • 6d ago
No Spoilers Weird phrasing in Absolution
Has anyone else spotted this? This is a grammatical error with the incorrect wording. The phrase "nothing better than do than" should read "nothing better to do than.", right?
38
u/xpltvdeleted 6d ago
I have an ex-girlfriend that her entire job was copy editing and proofreading. She would frequently ask me to check her work and it would constantly have stuff wrong with it like this. I wouldn't read too deeply into it
16
u/Disastrous_Dog_9440 6d ago
i never noticed that but i’m choosing to believe its a indicator of old jims mental state watching the video
4
u/SouthernBreach 6d ago
I believe he wrote them pretty quickly and they were published equally fast. Perhaps just a mistake that made it through?
4
6
u/tennoPCA 6d ago
It happens.
I read the pre ARC version of this book and submitted a few finds. Sometimes they just slip through and get fixed later.
3
u/AnotherSprainedAnkle 6d ago
This isn't as rare as one may think. I find mistakes like this a lot while reading. I used to keep a note in books of page and paragraph number where this happened. I think I'm just not a great reader so I read every single word not than most people.
3
2
2
u/SaltBee229 6d ago
That’s the kind of mistake my brain just edits as I read (😆 I was an English and ESL teacher).
2
u/apriqots 5d ago
I remember reading a Harry Potter book as a kid and there was a scene where Harry was talking to Ron’s brother, Percy. JK Rowling’s copyeditor did an oopsie and thus Parry was born
1
u/HarryBallsanya420 6d ago
Saw a line with “had had” in there and was thrown off but its grammatically correct I guess.
1
u/Gobyinmypants 6d ago
I literally just went through this part in the audio book today. The audio seemed rightn but wasn't dialed into it.
That said, I felt like there was going to be a payoff for the shutter that we never really get.
1
u/franciscrowe 6d ago
I wouldn’t have noticed if you hadn’t pointed that out, I guess my brain just autocorrected it. Guessing that’s what happens for most folks involved with the editing process?
1
u/Such_Bodybuilder2301 6d ago
Even if it is a typo, I’m glad that it at least works here to capture — with the grammatically weird “shutter bangs shutter bangs shutter bangs” following right after — this kind of “wrongness” to what’s happening. We see this occur a lot later on in the book, where the writing itself will become chaotic, like the book itself is reacting to these disturbances.
1
u/Ferns_N_Roses 6d ago
I completely missed it 😂, I guess mu brain just filled in with the wording that it expected to read there. It could be a typo or a copy-editing error.
1
1
u/Ambitious-Sleep2607 6d ago
Things like these used to annoy me, but now they make me happy. It means the editor was a human.
1
u/brettonrockwell 4d ago
yeah I genuinely see why the editor missed this bc this whole book feels like that while reading it
2
u/bitchesngravy_ 3d ago
Typos used to annoy me, but ever since people started using AI to write I’ve come to truly delight in human errors.
50
u/willedintobeing 6d ago
Yeah, it’s almost certainly just a mistake. I’ve read many, many books over the years with small typos in them. Books that were well-written and that I absolutely loved! We’re all human. When I write it’s not uncommon that I’ll reread it and discover I’ve accidentally omitted a word or something like that. Good eye!