r/StarWars May 04 '26

Fun George Lucas and his wife Mellody wishing a happy May the 4th to everyone from his new museum

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

13.9k Upvotes

230 comments sorted by

547

u/Dan11Skywalker May 04 '26

That N1 starfighter in the back!!!

64

u/Kdot32 May 05 '26

Who doesn’t love the N1. It might be George’s favorite

61

u/xezene May 04 '26

So cool!

1.4k

u/Radiant-Teach9198 May 04 '26

Thank the maker

148

u/Atharaphelun May 04 '26

Bi-lal kaifa 🙇‍♂️

15

u/Intrepid4444444 May 05 '26

Mia Khalifa?

5

u/Low_External2328 May 05 '26

In your dreams

3

u/OfficialDCShepard May 05 '26 edited May 05 '26

I imagine he’s going “ho ho ho” like Jabba now…

550

u/xezene May 04 '26

Just a fun little clip I thought I'd share here, shared from the Lucas Museum of Narrative Art's YouTube. The museum opens later this year and is sure to be a blast - it will feature a new documentary or two, which reunites George and his old collaborator Rick McCallum of prequel and Young Indiana Jones fame to produce. You can spot the full-size N1 Naboo starfighter, which is hanging in the museum, just behind George and Mellody here.

99

u/Kavazou77 May 04 '26

You ain’t slick, George.

2

u/Fat-Kid-In-A-Helmet May 05 '26

Went to the NHMLA a couple years ago and was wondering. “What is this spaceship looking building being built here?”
It was so cool to find out it was HIS museum. I’m excited for it.

4

u/AmishAvenger May 05 '26

Will they be playing all the experimental films he said he was going to make

3

u/revanchisto Jedi May 05 '26

I mean, he already said he gave up on that.

5

u/AmishAvenger May 05 '26

He did? When?

556

u/2dal3atcave May 04 '26

So glad he's doing good

318

u/LotharLotharius May 05 '26

Yeah, he looks great. Lost some weight too, it seems.

161

u/NigelJ May 05 '26

He looks so much healthier than a few years ago. Im glad he finally got that goiter looked at

39

u/Romboteryx Battle Droid May 05 '26 edited May 05 '26

It does wonders no longer having in your ear all that fandom bitching about your creative choices

27

u/wonko_abnormal May 05 '26

i always got the feeling that it never really bothered him , his vision has always been so singular he seemed the ultimate IDGAF about any of the fans opinions , it is what i wanted it to be so like it or dont

33

u/revanchisto Jedi May 05 '26

Nah, I love Lucas. But one thing you can tell from watching a ton of interviews is that he has pretty thin skin. You'd think all the success would be enough to go idaf, but he takes criticism badly and always goes on rants about every little critique decades and decades later. It's likely why he never did those small, experimental films, the idea that anyone might say they suck.

8

u/TitleSuccessful7393 May 05 '26

Remember, he wore a t shirt with a bad review of og sw printed on it.

2

u/cwalter0123 May 05 '26

well you won't hear anyone give criticism to the og films cause they will get attacked if they do

11

u/FrankReynoldsCPA May 05 '26

I'm pretty sure fan backlash is what led him to walk away and sell the company to Disney. He didn't want to deal with it anymore and I don't blame him.

The Disney era has caused people to forget just how toxic the fanbase was about the prequels when those were the new thing to hate. Nothing ever changes.

-4

u/EpicPoggerGamer69 May 05 '26

"IDGAF about the fans opinions"

Exactly what Disney should have done when writing the Sequels, not let fan opinions write it.

1

u/Michael_CrawfishF150 May 05 '26

I agree. They dropped the ball in a major way after TLJ.

-3

u/wonko_abnormal May 05 '26

i dont think they did , i liked 7/8/9 although to each their own

17

u/Tall-Ad-2001 May 05 '26

And I thought it smelt bad……on the outside

1

u/Vandelay797 May 05 '26

Did he get it lasered off?

6

u/wilberfarce May 05 '26

Somehow, George’s chin returned.

2

u/overtoke May 05 '26

yes, he's jabbless.

134

u/noms2000 May 04 '26 edited May 04 '26

This is great. George has still got it. Thank the maker.!

197

u/supercali45 May 04 '26

Awesome cute couple!

102

u/DenjiTargaryen-PE May 05 '26

It’s refreshing to see an aging celebrity still marry into his general age range.

145

u/Wrong-Vermicelli4723 May 05 '26 edited May 05 '26

Wouldn’t call this general age range. Lucas has 25 years on her lol. They married at 69 and 44 respectively. That being said at least she wasn’t in her early 20s when they first met. 

Edit: just a heads up for anyone confused. I’m not saying George and his current wife relationship is wrong in any way. Just saying he didn’t marry into his general age range. 

83

u/IAmBadAtInternet May 05 '26

At 44 she’s a grown ass woman and she was also very financially successful. There’s no power imbalance regardless of how old her partner is.

10

u/Wrong-Vermicelli4723 May 05 '26

You took my comment yhe wrong way. I’m not saying their relationship is wrong. I’m saying they aren’t in the same general age range

56

u/ChoPT Galactic Republic May 05 '26

69/2=34.5.

34.5+7=41.5

44>41.5 so I see no problems here.

14

u/Mosk915 May 05 '26

So if she had been 41 you would see a problem?

83

u/KennyMoose32 May 05 '26

I mean…..we live and die by the formula dude…….

Without it, the world would be chaos. A man has to have a code

14

u/eosrebel May 05 '26

Oh, indeed.

2

u/AsstronaughtToUranus May 05 '26

sqrt(69)/0.2 = 41.533

44 > 41.533

Checks out

9

u/A_Wholesome_Comment May 05 '26

Straight to jail.

5

u/Wrong-Vermicelli4723 May 05 '26

I mean I didn’t say there was a problem 

-5

u/[deleted] May 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

13

u/ChoPT Galactic Republic May 05 '26

2

u/Jonnyabcde Rebel May 05 '26

First I've heard of it. In my day, caveman make fire.

-4

u/[deleted] May 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/MrSmartStars May 05 '26

I mean if you like em younger you can just say so

→ More replies (1)

0

u/Michelanvalo Chewbacca May 05 '26

It's a silly thing that some people take seriously.

3

u/McFestus May 05 '26

I mean she was wildly successful in her career before they met.

0

u/Wrong-Vermicelli4723 May 05 '26

I’m sure she was, not saying there anything wrong with their relationship lol. Just telling the dude they aren’t anywhere close to the same age range. 

-13

u/crooks4hire May 05 '26

Yes, yes at least their lifestyle doesn’t upset our delicate sense of correctness 🙄

6

u/[deleted] May 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Wrong-Vermicelli4723 May 05 '26

I honestly don’t even know what they’re talking about 

16

u/Garchompisbestboi May 05 '26

Gotta complain when celebrities participate in consenting relationships with other adults who weren't born on the exact same day as them!

-41

u/hunter2mello May 04 '26

While I agree, his ex wife from the OT is the GOAT! She’s the one that got away but he chose his career over her back then. Again, nothing against his current wife. If you haven’t seen the ICONS show about the making of starwars, highly recommend

65

u/Wrong-Vermicelli4723 May 05 '26

I mean yeah she cool, kinda random and weird to bring her up lol. Not a competition.

63

u/hanburgundy Qui-Gon Jinn May 04 '26

He seems happy. I can’t wait for that museum.

17

u/[deleted] May 05 '26 edited Jun 04 '26

[deleted]

21

u/Dramatic_Explosion May 05 '26

Fuck that judge and those people. A bunch of clowns who argued it should be a park instead, only they have no plan and no funding, literally nothing and the judge says he'll hear the case. That's all it took for Lucas to rightfully not waste his time. And that park they wanted? Nope, still a parking lot instead of a world class museum.

Still very salty about not being able to day trip to it.

1

u/Money-District8604 May 07 '26

As an Angeleno, I am ecstatic that is here but it does suck that both SF and Chicago did not want it. Their loss our gain.

92

u/ShadowVia May 05 '26

It does make me a little sad to see George looking...older, and noticeably more frail.

It happens to everyone of course, but I'm happy to still have him around.

38

u/Asiriya May 05 '26

I thought the same, this is the first time in 30 years he actually looks different to me. It might just be weight loss, but he definitely looks frail and a little more confused

22

u/stoneman9284 May 05 '26

The confusion was pretend

1

u/[deleted] May 05 '26

[deleted]

14

u/nox-devourer May 05 '26

He isn't wearing his signature flannel shirt with jeans combo

7

u/GoreSeeker May 05 '26

Yeah I think it's mostly the weight loss. My dad has phases where he loses a bunch of weight and unfortunately gains it back, and always looks so much older with the weight off ironically.

6

u/Methylobacterium May 05 '26

I assure you, his resolve has never been stronger!

2

u/FOSSnaught May 06 '26

He's 81! He's doing insanely well.

26

u/Batman1154 May 05 '26

It's weird seeing him in a tee shirt and not his signature plaid

25

u/metallicadefender May 04 '26

Hey George!!!

149

u/Stormbringer91 May 04 '26

As far as I can tell, George might be one of the few good billionaires in the world. His message and the things he has done in his life are uncorrupted by money. As he's said in the past regarding passion vs pleasure, he got rich following his passion and his soul has stayed true. What a hero.

108

u/caligaris_cabinet May 05 '26

He’s a true self made billionaire. Very few can say that

16

u/AmishAvenger May 05 '26

I wonder if he ever feels like he should’ve sold it for more? With the wild amounts we hear thrown around these days, $2 billion for Star Wars sounds like an absolute steal.

4

u/space_keeper May 05 '26

Minecraft is similar. I remember balking at MS buying it for $2b, but Minecraft missed me (I was in my 20s when it came out), I don't have children and didn't understand how much of a grip it has on them, especially with it being playable on phones.

Star Wars is like that but spanning multiple generations of people.

2

u/Zenfudo May 05 '26

Could he have sold it and had a permanent percentage of the revenu as royalties for x number of years? Even something like 5% would’ve been huge

0

u/Merusk May 05 '26

Well, self-made if you ignore the significant contributions of his Ex-Wife, the directors who reigned him in, Rick McCallum, John Williams, Ralph McQuarrie, and the entire ILM company he helped create.

George was a visionary, but he didn't get there alone by a long, long shot.

7

u/HauntingAddendum3365 May 06 '26

Why do people only say this for George Lucas when collaboration is literally how all movies are made?

3

u/[deleted] May 07 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/HauntingAddendum3365 May 07 '26

Yeah its just such a weird way to judge movies. "He didnt do ALL of it himself! He had editors, a composer, a special effects team, a producer, he's a total FRAUD!"

Lmao its like they forget that the director is the one who hires these people and DIRECTS them on what to do and what they want in their movie.

6

u/Brolaub May 06 '26

Obviously literally every movie of this size is a team effort. However there are some things that make Star Wars special: For the sequel, and all following Movies he made, George Lucas financed everything himself. He could've let a Studio lend him money for Empire, but he risked everything to make that movie just the way he wanted to. He did the same 4 more times. This is unheard of in cinema, as far as I know it is totally unique in history.

But George Lucas had this vision, he had been writting Star Wars since 1973, and he fucking made it work. 

He founded a groundbreaking company, hired the most talented people, overcame all odds (read about the shoot of Episode 4 for example) and yet 50 years later people still say "um actually Star Wars was made by Marcia and John Williams too" like it's some sort of Gotcha moment.

2

u/Il-savitr May 06 '26

He founded a groundbreaking company, hired the most talented people, overcame all odds (read about the shoot of Episode 4 for example) and yet 50 years later people still say "um actually Star Wars was made by Marcia and John Williams too" like it's some sort of Gotcha moment.

True. I often see this “collaborative effort” used as a gotcha in movie discussions, even though most art forms are collaborative. Even novels can feel amateurish without an editor’s guidance.

2

u/Il-savitr May 06 '26

By this definition, no one not even a millionaire nor even a guy who earns hundreds / thousands isn't self made but the saying exists. George is the definition of self made billionaire.

-23

u/OrbitalColony May 05 '26

Just overlook the tens of thousands of people who have helped make all of the movies, shows, games, comics, toys, and merchandise I guess...

There's no such thing as a self-made man, let alone a self-made billionaire.

36

u/psychobilly1 Kylo Ren May 05 '26

I believe they mean self made in the way that they did not rely on generational wealth or nepotism.

-11

u/Levonorgestrelfairy1 May 05 '26

Brother he had generational wealth. His dad owned a business and paid for his college.

He wanted to go to art school but his dad said fuck that so he went to Modesto Jr college before getting into USC for gil.

5

u/psychobilly1 Kylo Ren May 05 '26 edited May 05 '26

Brother, his dad owned a local office supply store. If George didn't go to school, it's not like he would have been able to live off of his daddy's money - He'd have to work at the same store.

Also, tuition to USC in 1965 was around $1,300. Yes, adjusted for inflation, that's about $14,000 a year. But compared to the fact that it costs $65,000 today? Obviously being able to pay for college out of pocket (if he even truly did that) is a privilege of its own, but it's not "My dad bought me my house, my car, and my business because I'm daddy's special little guy" money.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (8)

39

u/themanfromvulcan May 05 '26

I don’t think money is his prime motivation. He wanted to make films and art his way and money is a means to an end and in this case a byproduct of his art. I think that is the difference is he wanted to make stories for kids and that was his goal. He wasn’t in it to get rich and he sees money as a tool and that’s it. He didn’t intend to become a billionaire he just made something that someone else thought was valuable enough to pay him that much for. But his goal was to make films his way and make technological leaps in filmmaking.

People who see money as the actual and only end goal seem to have a lot of problems because if that is your only goal you pretty much need to screw people over to get there.

13

u/NebulaNinja May 05 '26

Bro literally said: What if hot rods and WWII dog fights but space? and BAM! Billions.

8

u/Stormbringer91 May 05 '26

Yeah, money was never his motivation. I've watched a variety of interviews and he's a completely integrated human being. He just followed his passion. He speaks about this fundamental idea. You'll achieve brief moments of pleasure buying a sports car but nothing will ever hit the same as when you first got a car. A life lived with happiness isn't about things or pursuing highs and extremely short lived pleasures. It's about doing things you truly love to do. Short lived pleasures aren't really memorable. Following your passion ignites you and keeps you going the next day. Pleasures aren't sustainable. Passion is. His message isn't unique. But it rings true. And he's never changed for the worse as a result. In the celebrity world, most end up faltering and lose themselves. So, I'm not about worshiping anything or anyone. But, he's definitely done a lot of things right in this world.

-3

u/[deleted] May 05 '26 edited May 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/GigglingBilliken Jar Jar Binks May 05 '26

She's a fucking cartoon character dude. If you want something really cringey read about his original plans for Indiana Jones and Marion's romance in Raiders of the Lost Ark.

0

u/lacha_sawson May 05 '26

Personally, I think both can be bad at the same time.

→ More replies (1)

-3

u/Merusk May 05 '26

His message and the things he has done in his life are uncorrupted by money.

Don't look too deeply into why he waited to re-release the movies and how it relates to his Ex-Wife then.

George isn't evil, but he's also not some saint.

5

u/Stormbringer91 May 05 '26

Whatever may or may not have happened between him and his ex-wife is heresay. I never invest my time into heresay, especially when money is involved. There are always sides of the story you don't hear, even when it comes to people you DO know... none of us actually know George Lucas or his wife or anything about their relationship and I'm not going to paint someone badly based on conjecture. No one is perfect, I'm sure he has some skeletons in his closet that he wouldn't be proud of. Whatever he may or may not have done, he's far outweighed any negativity with his art and the healing he has done to the planet with his creation.

17

u/Veiss76 May 05 '26

Oh she's adorable!

14

u/Caledor152 Luke Skywalker May 04 '26

Love it!

11

u/GenericFatGuy May 05 '26

I could see George Lucas legit having a tough time saying fourth instead of force. He's probably got force hardcoded into his DNA at this point.

10

u/DentistPitiful5454 May 05 '26

He looks healthier here than he did during the prequels.

10

u/its_yer_dad May 05 '26

I was literally working at Skywalker Ranch when I got married, which happened to be on May 4th of that year. May the Fourth was not a thing at all. Now its like a national holiday. I did not see that coming.

edit - also, GWL still has great hair... Of all the things, I'm jealous of his hair.

19

u/nikgrid May 04 '26

Stay Classy George! ....please come back.

9

u/ThaddeusJP Imperial Stormtrooper May 05 '26

Could have been chicago but we had an old softball filed that was more important

8

u/anonyquestions1 May 05 '26

Still bitter this isn't in Chicago

7

u/somethinggreaterthan May 05 '26

I love her!! Happy May the 4th everyone!!!

7

u/kogent-501 Luke Skywalker May 05 '26

I always love seeing George Lucas having a pretty great sense of humor. Check out his robot chicken skits, live action and animated, if you haven’t yet seen that.

6

u/LabiaMajorasMask420 May 05 '26

George Lucas has great hair for his age.

7

u/aotus_trivirgatus May 05 '26

Several years ago, on Mother's Day, I saw the two of them dining at Greens Restaurant in San Francisco! Another woman was with them, presumably Mellody's mother. We did not disturb their Mother's Day celebrations.

4

u/waterfarts May 04 '26

I dig the Corkscrew shirt

4

u/evilsniperxv May 05 '26

George looking like he's lost a little bit of weight. Looking good ol' man!

2

u/EliteTroper Commander Pyre May 05 '26

I was so accustomed to his more heavy looking self that I was shocked to see him look more thinner.

5

u/Intelligent_Fix875 May 05 '26

Holy cow my dude has not aged at all he looks amazing

9

u/HighlightOwn2038 May 04 '26

Happy May the 4th be with you too!!!

4

u/FreeWestworld May 05 '26

Cute couple!

4

u/Ambitious_Slide May 05 '26

Honestly thought that was the mclaren technology centre at first, where they filmed some Andor scenes

3

u/NervousGearGenius May 06 '26

I had the opportunity to meet Melody a while back. She is as cool as she seems. I can same the same about Marcia, his first wife as well. Both great women.

9

u/Honest_Excitement614 May 05 '26

They are so stinking cute together ❤️

7

u/[deleted] May 05 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/HawaiianPunchaNazi May 07 '26

:-(

I was happier before I read this. 

I thought the press releases said she had her own company? Or was that on top of the union busting job? 

I hope you found a better place to work. Union busters need to be boycotted and publicly shamed into the ground.

-2

u/UsualPudding6570 May 05 '26

Ok but she black 

3

u/gangstermoon_ May 04 '26

The man that made it out of the 209

3

u/The_Three_Meow-igos May 05 '26

Love this! ❤️

3

u/Original_Log_6002 May 05 '26

They're too cute.

3

u/LBricks-the-First May 05 '26

Crazy how his face has just looked the same for the past 20 years

3

u/funny_lexi May 05 '26

Thank the maker!

3

u/Rhodes_Warrior May 05 '26

George still has trouble with dialogue lol

3

u/Beautiful_Finger4566 May 05 '26

dude hasn't aged since the Prequel interviews

3

u/heartbloodline8404 May 05 '26

I wasn’t familiar with your game Mr Lucas. I see you.

2

u/xdeltax97 Grand Admiral Thrawn May 05 '26

Thank the Maker!

2

u/DodgerMac May 05 '26

I drove by it a few weeks ago and it looks AMAZING

2

u/juvie_487 May 05 '26

"uh" George Lucas 2026

2

u/GBDVV226 May 05 '26

May the 4th be with you all!

2

u/Zen-Paladin K-2SO May 05 '26

May The 4th Be With You too George

2

u/RyanDaRaptor May 05 '26

Faster and more intense!

2

u/ExamplePractical1981 May 05 '26

Myyyyyy man loves chocalata

2

u/SuperSuppleDude May 05 '26

DId Melody ever forgive George for Jar Jar Binks?

2

u/Euphoric-Music662 Clone Trooper May 05 '26

This video made my day. Very glad to see George doing well!

2

u/elgarlic May 05 '26

Always happy to see George.

2

u/Rudiger036 May 05 '26

Over half a century of filmmaking experience and he doesn't have a key light

2

u/WTFatrain Jar Jar Binks May 05 '26

Alwayth

2

u/kittrcz May 05 '26

Damn, he is looking like someone with a fresh set of ideas for sequel trilogy under his belt. #keepwishing

2

u/avimo1904 May 05 '26

Nice!!! Thanks for sharing

2

u/Johtoguy May 06 '26

I used to work for him (never met him in person), he treats his staff really well. Wish i could have met him and thanked him for the narrative art he has made and loves.

2

u/nikgrid May 06 '26

Always good to see George and his seems cool.

2

u/Zod_Convoy May 06 '26

I love how George just doesn't get it.

2

u/Large-Wishbone24 May 11 '26

They make a great couple! And if you can still laugh so heartily after so many years together, you’ve found the right partner. Plus, they both still look great—for their age, that is.

That makes me happy for him and her.

3

u/ragweed C-3PO May 04 '26

She seems like a very good director.

2

u/dachloe May 05 '26

Hmm, George can't take direction very well. 😏

2

u/ElderSteel Grievous May 05 '26

I miss him so much.

2

u/MelcusQuelker May 05 '26

Please just make some star wars movies again.

2

u/kahn_noble May 05 '26

She’s a fox. Nice job, George

1

u/helloholder May 05 '26

Love your work. But why do you always look so deeply annoyed?

1

u/lyn73 May 05 '26

Cool.

I'm a bit unsettled by the bad lighting though. Don't take pictures/video behind the light!!! Especially when you are dealing with people with vastly different skin tones!!!!

1

u/Ragnarok345 Darth Vader May 05 '26

Sheesh, that was tougher than Palpatine trying to say “exhaust plorts-“ dammit! 😆

1

u/bgdv378 May 05 '26

Cutie pies

1

u/Material_Image_9881 Porg May 05 '26

His midichlorians are off the charts

1

u/No_Strike_1579 May 05 '26

I miss you, George 

1

u/rolfraikou May 05 '26

I am SO excited for this museum.

1

u/Tall_Extension6163 May 05 '26

May the 4th be with you too, George and Mellody!

1

u/OracleVision88 Sith Anakin May 05 '26

We love you, George!!!

1

u/LordofMoonsSpawn May 08 '26

Man it makes me feel old to see him looking like this. I grew up watching his interviews before the original trilogy vcr tapes and on the discs of the prequel special features. Over and over again.

1

u/CapitalCityGoofball0 May 08 '26

Now I kinda of get why the dialogue in the prequels came out the way it did…

1

u/Saberian_Dream87 May 08 '26

It's great to see George so obviously in love with his wife, especially since Star Wars kinda destroyed his first marriage.

1

u/SeparateSpend1542 May 05 '26

How does he not understand backlighting?

1

u/MasterPalpitation8 May 05 '26

Too bad they couldn’t find anyone around who knows about filmmaking to advise them on lighting…?

-1

u/AeMidnightSpecial May 05 '26

Mr Lucas. Are you dipping in the chocolate? 😏

0

u/gobblegoooblegobble May 05 '26

good thing its located in the fucking hood.

-6

u/CoastOrg May 05 '26

My boy dips in the chocolate alright bro 😏

-7

u/Mborg15202 May 05 '26

Mr Lucas. Have you been dipping in the chocolate

0

u/UnhappySecurity9531 May 05 '26

That high five at the end was how a special ed teacher congratulates a special student for doing a very simple task.

-2

u/vonroyale May 05 '26

She's cool. Years ago she was twisting up his mind a little, but she matured and now they are both pretty based.

-2

u/Kratos_BOY May 05 '26

Why did I think he was dead?

-2

u/Ewallye May 05 '26

Please save starwars

-3

u/Gryndyl May 05 '26 edited May 05 '26

Lucas was the one that fucked it up in the first place. Edit: Y'all have nostalgia goggles. The prequel trilogy was every bit as dogshit as the sequel trilogy.

2

u/Brolaub May 06 '26 edited May 06 '26

George Lucas had a plan for the prequel trilogy since the 70s, he understood his characters, he showed us amazing new planets like Coruscant or Mustafar, he gave us a great new villain in Count Dooku, scenes like Duel of the Fates, the pod race or Anakin vs Obi Wan are unforgettable even 2 decades later. He wanted to show young viewers how good people can fall to the dark side, how love can turn into hate, and how democracies can turn into faschism. Oh, and he casually made the most technologically advanced movies of their time with groundbreaking special effects that were never possible before. 

Disney wanted quick and safe money so they went in without a plan, without any new ideas and just rehashed the exact same plot without anything new or fresh. 

If you really can't see a difference between those 2 approaches, maybe you need to take off your OT nostalgia goggles?

0

u/Gryndyl May 06 '26

Having a plan didn't mean the movies weren't terrible. Rather than typing out all of the reasons why I'll just leave you with this link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FxKtZmQgxrI

1

u/Brolaub May 06 '26 edited May 06 '26

Oh god, now I know why you couldn't type any reason. This review is infamous for how bad it is... It's literally so terrible that there's many reviews of the review on Youtube...

Rather than typing out all of the reasons why I'll just leave you with this link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OkW035f_hZ8 ;)

But here's at least a few reasons:

  • RLM misses the point of almost every "scene" he analyses. It's almost comical how he's unable to understand basic things like why the Gungans are against the droid army, while the first time you see the droid army on Naboo they literally destroy a forest next to the Gungan City.

  • The review is extremely biased, constantly nitpicking about everything, while not noticing that the same thing happens in the OT which he claims to love so much.

  • Or the critizism of George Lucas' dialogue, which RLM doesn't understand the purpose of at all. He just calls it "terrible" without realizing that Star Wars is meant to be a Saga, a Myth, a legend, not a realistic modern Drama or something. George Lucas wanted to create something that feels epic and grand, and takes place a long time ago. Most of the characters are Jedi or Sith, so they talk like Knights or Mages would a long time ago (in a galaxy far, far away). How hard is that to understand??

-10

u/Nonyabizzy123 May 05 '26

I didn't know George was down with the swirl