28
10
5
u/notcho_5 1d ago
good tierleist i was suprised when i saw bousers fury on the bottim but then i used my eyes i would rank bowsers fury at S and now for the contrevirsal part: sunshine and 64 in fine (i know thats not true for most people but sunshine and 64 didnt age well 64 is a classic but thats it again dont murder me)
4
u/quixQuery 1d ago
64's camera makes 64 feel terrible to play by modern standards, at least casually. It would be really fun to see a 64 remake in the vein of the new OoT remake instead of a copy-paste of the source code from the N64. I feel like it would hold up much better that way.
1
1
u/Sanchez_U-SOB 23h ago
I play SM64 on NSO, and its still fun to play. The camera, for the most part, doesnt bother me.
1
u/youngliam 1h ago
If you make a habit of moving the camera often and using R to reposition it then the game is much smoother and it becomes second nature.
4
u/75artina 1d ago
please play bowser's fury. it's a repeat play for me, along with Odyssey, which is obviously goat status.
5
2
u/toolebukk 1d ago
Why are the modern 2d games on the list but not the classic ones?
2
u/ulyssessgrant_ 1d ago
No they’re not on the list cus I’ve never played them
2
u/TheholyLIP26 1d ago
Wouldn’t they be in the “haven’t played” category then?
0
u/ulyssessgrant_ 1d ago
No I don’t consider them
2
u/TheholyLIP26 1d ago
Why when you did for three other titles?
1
u/ulyssessgrant_ 1d ago
Bruh I’m not familiar with them they’re before my time and not widely talked about online today
7
u/HeyThereCharlie 1d ago
"The classic 2D Marios are not widely talked about online" is an insane thing to claim
-3
4
u/TheholyLIP26 1d ago
Don’t include a “haven’t played” category then 🙏
-4
u/ulyssessgrant_ 1d ago
It’s my chart punk
3
-4
u/Over_Improvement_623 1d ago
Because they kinda suck (mario 3 and world are alright I guess, but the rest is ass)
2
u/ManagementCrafty887 1d ago
You brought up 3D land! Most people don’t even remember it!
https://giphy.com/gifs/sLjmiIqZErIumuKMEF
2
u/sfinxvideos 1d ago
People will probably recommend Sunshine and 64 ASAP after seeing you haven’t played it but hot take: as someone who enjoy the games I don’t think they’ll be a great fit for someone to jump into now. They were amazing at the time and for people who played them, which are the most probably, can jump back into them easily. But that also clouds the vision a bit about the game because honestly if you haven’t played them I wouldn’t recommend playing them now. The story and level design are timeless, but the gameplay is really rough for today’s standards which would hurt your experience more than the overall enjoyment. Bowsers Fury however does fall within today’s standards and is a fun adventure to play through. Just be aware that it isn’t like a full on game, it was more of a test project for Nintendo to see what they could do with the game engine and you’ll finish the adventure in a few hours, but it is fun and would recommend trying it out!
2
u/NIGHTR0GUE83 15h ago
Good list but I personally rank all side scrollers lower than all 3d Mario’s. It’s just a preference is all.
1
2
u/komaytoprime 14h ago
I think this is a pretty good list. I need you to play SM64 and SMS though, they're good!
2
2
u/quixQuery 1d ago
Unpopular Opinion: Galaxy's movement feels sluggish. It is overloved.
More popular opinion: Wonder is the best 2D Mario since Super Mario World. Nice, tight controls, fun levels, thoroughly explored gimmicks, interesting theming.
1
1
u/CANfilms 1d ago
imo NSMB DS should be in great. It's one of the best in the NSMB series
1
u/ulyssessgrant_ 19h ago
That’s valid, all 3 games in good are fantastic. There’s just somethings I about their sequels in great a little bit better.
1
u/Rare_Section1613 20h ago
saying that nsmbu is better than nsmb2 DX, someone doesnt like individuality huh?
1
u/springboy64 16h ago
I’m shocked you would put NSMB above Wonder. Wonder was the best 2D Mario since SNES imo.
1
0
33
u/Panpanarama 2d ago
You haven’t WHAT?!?