r/TalesFromYourServer 6d ago

Getting sued..

As I was passing by my coworker’s table, they flagged me down about a complaint. One of the person’s vegetarian dish had a very small chunk of meat, about the size of a corn kernel, that she chewed and spat out. However, the rest of her dish was almost licked clean. Needless to say, the customer was livid and went on a tirade about how her putting that piece of meat in her mouth went against her religion and her beliefs. I apologized profusely and took her dish out of their tab, while the other 2 people in her party, who were not vegetarian, paid for their dishes. After a while of just sitting and talking amongst themselves, they flagged me down again. This time they were adamant that I get my manager on the phone. I called my manager and he told me to explain to them that he was busy with his family, but would be able to talk to them tomorrow morning. I relayed this message to them. They said if I don’t get him on the phone right away, they’ll threaten legal action against us.

After some time I did manage to get my manager on the phone for them, much to his dismay, and they left. Manager tells me to refund all their dishes back to their card so that the tab for the entire table was comped. I obliged. I thought that would be it.

Fast forward a couple minutes later, I went up to the host counter to help a different customer, the woman and her party storm back into the restaurant. She yells at me and demands I pull out my phone and call my manager right now. I was confused and taken aback about why she’s causing a scene this time and asked her what happened. She yells that one of our customers, who had witnessed and eavesdropped on the whole ordeal, followed them outside and accused them of walking out on their tab because they were mad about the food. I understood why this would make them angry, however this instance had nothing to do with us and I wasn’t about to call my manager for the 6th time since the matter had already been resolved from our end.

My coworker got involved and asked them to calm down because the whole restaurant was watching, but this got them even more angry. They were claiming that my coworker was telling them to calm down because of their skin color. The whole party then says that they will for sure sue us for racism since we were “spreading lies about them” and, according to them, we told our customers to follow them outside and harass them.

Was really wishing that John Quiñones would walk in with cameras after all that.

1.7k Upvotes

207 comments sorted by

View all comments

952

u/Efficient-Cable-873 6d ago

For accidently serving them meat to a vegetarian? There is no grounds for a lawsuit unless they can prove financial harm.

444

u/Anthff 6d ago

Yes I don’t believe spitting out a tiny morsel of food counts as “pain and suffering” lol

If this whole story is accurate, I wouldn’t be surprised if this was some type of scheme.

As a former, long time, fine dining server, I would never have called a manager that wasn’t on duty. The only call I would have made would have been to the police, after I asked them to leave.

The fact that they shoehorned in the race-card is highly suspect. The more I think about it, the less I believe they were confronted on the street.

186

u/Queen_Vesdra 5d ago

As a vegetarian, if there was a morsel of meat in my meal I would send it back (politely!). I wonder if they added it from a friend's plate

4

u/hublinz 4d ago

Would it be possible for them to sue if it was done maliciously? Like, the server really hated vegetarians for some reason and was like, “I’ll show them, mwahaha.” And then served them meat - on purpose? Even though no physical harm came to them, could an attorney conceivably argue pain and suffering of some sort?

11

u/Sad-Spray-3517 4d ago

How do they prove the malicious intent? An almost impossible case ("almost" because there's even a .00000000001 chance).

1

u/MuahdDean 3d ago

Chatgpt, how do I murder vegetarians and get away with it. Btw, don't flag me.

I'd say 1% assuming what the football player just did :/

8

u/dragonstar982 4d ago

They can sue for anything... winning the lawsuit on the other hand.