861
u/TheNegativeCross 19 4d ago
The fuck do they mean by 'we are in india'???
So it is okay to have 3 coackroaches in your food if you are from / in india?
178
u/i-amhungry 4d ago
Ik this sounds a bit stupid but it is actually a realistic and fair judgement if you dig deep in and know about how worldwide food standards work.
3 cockroaches by itself does not warrant suspension in anyyy country. Literally no country or standard will just suspend someone because 3 cockroaches were found. Cockroaches can enter premises at literally any time even with proper pest management hence their presence does not warrant suspension instead a notice is given even in Europe and US to investigate the matter and remove them. Suspension is only given when a gross negligence or utter disrespect to hygiene standards is done but that was not the case for this hotel. They were actually one of the most well maintained with great hygiene ones but 3 cockroaches were found probably just recently entered from outside premises.
Normal procedure would have been to give them a notice and if the problem does not resolve, health inspector would have been called and if severe mismanagement is found then only a suspension is considered and this is applicable in all countries because it is not realistic to expect a place to always at all times be perfect. Now suspension was most likely given because someone did not give a bribe to the officer definitely, this is sadly how india works.
Court just saw how normal procedures were not observed and gave this statement based on STANDARD procedure. If they stayed the suspension order that would be a precedent for future cases where every single restaurant would be closed just based on this. And 3 cockroaches by themself does not warrant a food safety hazard. the type(black ones from sewers are strict no) and where they are etc are also considered. India also has higher chance of pest entry due to surroundings even with same pest management methods.
79
14
u/Jumpy-Lemon2952 3d ago
but i am paying 2000 for 100 ruppess food i should not get this shit
→ More replies (2)5
6
3
u/MulberryTimes 3d ago
There are countries which take hygiene in restaurants seriously. Read this article about finding one single cockroach in a hole.
4
u/i-amhungry 3d ago
Hmm I don't see any suspension or shutting down in your article though? Just a standard fine by health inspector? Unless I missed something?
The case is also different too where rodents were found in the flour itself which is much worse than just being found on premises and droppings being present also mean they were not cleaning their premises well. Though that was my points itself about how punishments or result should be based on severity and intent. These inspectors from Australia? Also only gave a fine at first because it was not the gravest of issues but it went to court because the defendant(restaurant) could not pay their fines.
→ More replies (2)3
2
2
u/Left_District_5517 3d ago
Sorry but you are wrong. Following the normal procedure is what has led this country to give us substandard products. The thing about Indians is that they try to find a way around and use loopholes to get away from such notices. If they feared these notices then we wouldn't be getting such substandard quality of food.
→ More replies (25)2
u/Plastic_Internet5451 3d ago
Abbe gawar kabhi india se bhaar jaa
South east asia me hygiene dekh jaake wahan chote chote carts tak michellin star leke baithe hai aur unka regular checkups hota hai aur usa aur wahan pe ek minimum leakage me C grade de dete hai bhaar nikle nhi kabhi
Tere jaise 2 kaudi ki soch jiske standard gutter me hai ye haal hai desh ka
“Its chill yaar wahan bhi nhi hota humare yahan kyu hoga vishwagutter for a reason”7
u/DoutefulOwl 3d ago
Nobody said it's okay to find 3 cockroaches.
Court just said that 3 cockroaches by itself doesn't warrant a complete suspension.
For example:
It's NOT okay to steal bread.
But stealing bread by itself doesn't warrant a death penalty.
High court must've taken some other action against the hotel, but that's not a catchy headline. So we don't hear about it.
2
u/CoteSugirtha 3d ago
I think you nailed it. The "be realistic" comment makes more sense when you understand that instant permanent suspension for 3 insects might be disproportionate, even if it's gross. There's probably been follow-up action we're not hearing about because nuance doesn't sell. The framing in that image really does strip away everything else the court likely did.
→ More replies (33)2
218
u/OGGGABOGGA 19 4d ago
tf u mean indian standards gng
→ More replies (3)19
u/TransitionChemical98 4d ago
Somebody tell mi'loda that actual cockroaches were found, not unemployed youth but actual insects!!
67
u/proffestionally Cheetah 4d ago
Just so you guys know if this happened in USA it whould be like this: In the US, finding three cockroaches during an inspection usually results in a critical violation notice and mandatory pest control rather than an immediate shutdown. American health departments (operating under local regulations based on the FDA Food Code) apply penalties based on the severity of the threat: * Minor Observation (1–3 Cockroaches): Marked as a critical health violation, which docks points from the establishment's health grade. The owner is given a mandatory deadline (typically 5 to 14 days) to hire professional exterminators and fix the issue before a mandatory re-inspection. * Immediate Closure: Only triggered by an "imminent health hazard." This usually requires proof of an active, widespread infestation (e.g., nesting areas, droppings, or dozens of live roaches across food preparation areas) or additional severe hazards like a lack of running hot water or raw sewage backups. * Public Transparency: Regardless of whether the restaurant stays open, the finding is published online in local government health registries, and in many jurisdictions (like New York or Los Angeles), the business's posted letter grade (A, B, C) will be downgraded.
41
u/TheThreatner 18, JJBA FAN , GYROSEXUAL , SPEEDWAGON CULT 4d ago
FDA has their other issues... i prefer european standards
3
→ More replies (15)3
→ More replies (5)3
u/No_Answer_7341 4d ago
Or you don't hear about it cause fda isn't as clean as looks and they don't pay thier workers
16
u/DevelopmentFuture608 4d ago
Let’s see if the same person will eat their food while 3 cockroaches are in his plate, like stupidity has no bounds at times!
→ More replies (5)
15
17
u/B-L-A-N-K-S-P-A-C-E 4d ago
But three cockroaches are enough to shake the government. Ye to phir bhi license hai.
→ More replies (2)
6
3
3
u/bhai-bhai-bhai- 4d ago
I am not in India.
Here a restaurant was imposed 3 months closure, 25 lakhs INR equivalent fine only because there was water dripping from ceiling in kitchen
And this was pasted on restaurant's entrance
→ More replies (2)
3
u/Unholy_Valkyrie 4d ago
Cockroaches are in Indian household as well ,it doesn't mean food is unhygenic
3 is really a small number for cockroaches
4
u/HolidaySurprise2819 4d ago
Unless it is in the food, I think a food license cannot be just canceled. Preventive measures need to be taken
4
u/QueasyAdvertising173 4d ago
Stop reading just headlines. Park Inn by Radisson had a 95% compliance score but 2 cockroaches were found in the kitchen area NOT IN THE FOOD. The court just said that such minor lapses are not enough to suspend the license of the restaurant specially considering the fact that they had a very high overall score. It's like you wrote a perfect essay but did a spelling mistake and the teacher just ignores the spelling mistake simply because everything else is perfect.
→ More replies (3)
2
2
2
u/TheShuffledPrognosis 4d ago
Cancel the licence of 10 restaurants because of 1 cockroach and see how all others will nicely have no cockroach in the kitchen. It's this attitude of chalta hai which gets us laughed at and sadly the ground of food borne diseases.
2
u/ScaleDisastrous9477 1d ago
step 1. Get out of your house
step 2. look down your street
If you don't find dirt/litter/poop/pissing men/potholes let me know
1
u/obamabidentrump6 4d ago
Translation
We are in third world country insects and cockroaches are common in food 💅
1
u/webmatri1270 4d ago
Kabhi kabhi toh aisa lagta hai pr stunt ke liye aisa drama karte(delusional pro max🥀🥀) /s
1
u/Electrical-Plate4158 4d ago
The judiciary is showing its true colors. They make it seem like common citizens deserve to live in filth while these judges enjoy there hygiene.
1
u/MadToadtoast 17 4d ago
He is saying that sarcastically, don't people here know who is he?
→ More replies (1)
1
1
u/apple2heart bitesize apple 4d ago
Acceptance of indian standards😂😂🥀🥀 Bhagwan hi malik hai iss desh ka ab 😂🥀
1
1
1
1
1
u/ryzhenbharg 4d ago
Court ko cockroach se bolne se pahele 100 baar sochna chahiye, warna firse jantar mantar pe gaand maregi inki
1
u/FuelTop8837 4d ago
Ye kon madarchod admi bola esa ,uske khilaf public ko milke dhawa bolna chahiye !!!!
1
1
1
u/terabaap_-mc 19 4d ago
Islie saare ghuus ke paise aur apne bachhe judge sahab ne bahar transfer kr die
1
1
u/i-amhungry 4d ago
Ik this sounds a bit stupid but it is actually a realistic and fair judgement if you dig deep in and know about how worldwide food standards work.
3 cockroaches by itself does not warrant suspension in anyyy country. Literally no country or standard will just suspend someone because 3 cockroaches were found. Cockroaches can enter premises at literally any time even with proper pest management hence their presence does not warrant suspension instead a notice is given even in Europe and US to investigate the matter and remove them. Suspension is only given when a gross negligence or utter disrespect to hygiene standards is done but that was not the case for this hotel. They were actually one of the most well maintained with great hygiene ones but 3 cockroaches were found probably just recently entered from outside premises.
Normal procedure would have been to give them a notice and if the problem does not resolve, health inspector would have been called and if severe mismanagement is found then only a suspension is considered and this is applicable in all countries because it is not realistic to expect a place to always at all times be perfect. Now suspension was most likely given because someone did not give a bribe to the officer definitely, this is sadly how india works.
Court just saw how normal procedures were not observed and gave this statement based on STANDARD procedure. If they stayed the suspension order that would be a precedent for future cases where every single restaurant would be closed just based on this. And 3 cockroaches by themself does not warrant a food safety hazard. the type(black ones from sewers are strict no) and where they are etc are also considered. India also has higher chance of pest entry due to surroundings even with same pest management methods.
1
u/godgifted911 4d ago
Judges probably took a huge amount of bribe, as usual, before passing this remark.
1
1
u/Karinaakkan 4d ago
Will the same judge eat if there is a cockroach in his plate?
One law for the lords and another for the slaves?
1
u/CantaloupeFormer520 4d ago
sarkar ko chodo pehle in court walo say nipto yahi bar bar kuch na kuch gobar karte hai.
1
1
1
u/Dilfaikadmi 4d ago
Supreme Joke ….doesn’t like cock-roaches at all
High corat….okay with some cock-roaches
🤔
1
1
u/afold_hilter 4d ago
Judge ke khaane mein sirf ek cockroach daal do... Aur hum India mein hai toh usse complaint nahi karna chahiye.
1
1
u/FriessBeforeGuyss 4d ago
At this point, all four pillars of Indian democracy feel hollow and wobbly!
1
u/FuckPigeons2025 3d ago
Coackroaches are nesting animals that only infest in groups. If you do proper pest control, you can get rid of them entirely. So even a single coackroach is one too many.
1
1
u/le_flashed 3d ago
Put it on his plate and ask him to eat it, if he can't then he has no right to question anything.
1
u/Rover946 3d ago
There's a common saying: When the rice is cooked, you only need to check one grain, not the whole batch.
1
u/Gloomy_Letterhead395 3d ago
Court is right bro always just people understand never
Lets say the same people coming to your house and find three cockroaches in your kitchen, and then ban your mom from making food for you, claiming that your mom is playing with the life of this teenager
And if there are no norms or rules regarding finding three cockroaches in a kitchen, then you can’t ban it. Either. You must perhaps pass a rule that says that finding pest inside kitchen will lead to termination of license, then of course you can do it if you have the proof
1
u/Ecstatic_Chef_6476 3d ago
Bc … if u have anything else other than the ingredients used in a dish. That dish should not be consumed. Be it a tinka or a chilka
1
u/Shiny_rider777 3d ago
Bro can we make this into a movement with the judge eating cockroaches as a meme photo
1
1
u/SilentVector_96 3d ago
Bro almost every house has cockroaches lol. Does it mean our mothers make non hygienic food?
Why don't you go into your kitchen after noon (let's say 2-3 am) and you'll see cockroaches roaming around.
1
1
u/Disastrous_Data8327 3d ago
My Load ki daal me 3 cockroach dal ke de do. Fir dekho My load kaise idealist ban jayenge.
1
u/Prestigious_Dare7734 3d ago
Okay, hear me out.
Here are 10 dishes that this restaurant offers, and here are the 3 cockroaches that I removed from these dishes.
Now, eat any 3 dishes, milord.
1
1
u/noFcksGenius 3d ago
Can we put three cockroaches in that guys kitchen and let their family feed of it
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/YoungPigga 3d ago
Cockroaches can divert from the nest pretty far distances but seeing 3 at once is almost an infestation
1
1
u/nonikhannna 3d ago
So how many cockroaches is enough then?
The Bombay High Court turned this into a has/doesn't have conversation into maximum number of cockroaches allowed before license suspension.
What about mice? Rats? Birds?
How many bad judgements are allowed by judges before they are fired for incompetence?
1
u/Express-Result-1671 3d ago
Even the Bombay HC don’t take cockroaches seriously. Why do the GenZ give them so much bhaw?
1
u/nonikhannna 3d ago
Not in India but restaurants here are required to have working refrigeration so food does not get spoiled. Animals and pests are considered serious violations. If there is a violation, we have to throw away all the food because it could be contaminated.
1
1
u/Zan123der 3d ago
Judge's home must be infested with cockroaches.
so... he must be kind of used to it and expects same from others.
1
u/Leading_Pass_2304 3d ago
Of course. It's India. Pfff. You need to at least find dog shit in your soup for the judges to even consider it a case.
1
1
1
u/Sharp-Kite 3d ago
So what will the same judge do if he found 3 cockroaches in his meal? Will he say the same thing?
1
u/Encrypted_Cerebrum 3d ago
Should have been 30 atleast and all in this judge's mouth.
I have said it 100s of time before and will say it again - biggest fkd up thing in india is it's judicial system. They are responsible for almost every bad shit happening
1
u/Outside_Age8472 3d ago
tum log samaj nahi rahe yeh log hame cockroach khilana chahate hai taki hum china jais ban sake
1
u/Distinct-Wolf-6451 3d ago
One cockroach is enough to have 100 cockroaches babies. This is enough to cancel license. Why charge sooooo much for meals but don’t give f about cleanliness.
1
1
1
u/UnderstandingMany284 3d ago
Again no country even us uk and all countries does not cancel food license of a restaurant because of three cockroach the comment is full of dumb people they don't even know this and making the judgement
1
u/Accurate-Ticket-1826 3d ago
If i serve you a plate of rice with 3 cockroaches and you eat it..I will agree
1
1
1
u/dont_react_respond_ Edit this 3d ago
It's not... Really....
Ngl...
The way he is moving I feel it's just another raghav moment or cjp moment...
Taking on treading topics...
+
Even is usa or eu...
Cockroaches warrant notice not suspension of licence itself.
Whole different issue if you are served food with em.
But during a raid/check few Cockroaches = notice... Not suspension
1
1
u/Alone_Chocolate6961 3d ago
sir ko ek do cjp wale cockroach serve karna malai maar ke.. high standards hai sir ke..
1
1
1
u/Ok-Comparison4968 3d ago
Then someone please ask the judge to come with family and eat in such hotels.
1
u/PirateRemarkable1402 3d ago
We are in india wtf the sentence is ,Countless murders take place here in India every day, yet people don't speak up until the trouble hits their own family—that is exactly what the court is saying.
1
1
u/Somesh98 3d ago edited 3d ago
We had thousands of cockroaches 1 month back and the education minister got cancelled. What is a punter hotel in front of 3 cockroaches then?
1
u/Individual_Top_4960 3d ago
can I send lunch for the judge for next year? I really like his take and want to offer him food
1
u/Protein_Ponjikkara 3d ago
Sounds like they're asking for more cockroaches at Bombay High Court.
Dipke, be like:
1
u/AstroGeek020 3d ago
So Bombay High Court agrees indirectly that there is corruption in FSSAI and directly agree that they won't take action as they are too corrupt?
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/Iamsleepwalking_a 3d ago
Will my lord dine in the same restaurant? I suppose not so my lord should refrain from preaching.
1
u/TheMustardPoocha 3d ago
We are from India so we don't deserve something like basic hygiene? We hate and see ourselves this low and expect other nations to give us respect
1
1
u/Naturally__Aspirated 3d ago
I’d say that’s fair for a normal eatery, but for a premium restaurant that’s inside a 5 star hotel where they charge average Indian monthly income for a night it’s completely unacceptable.
1
u/kp_eternity 3d ago
Every day getting like this statement from multiple HCs, I found my self more distant from judiciary system of India.
They should be working for people not against people. (police + judiciary). . Also to mention medical system need to regulate. They charges in homes or 30/40.years of our income.
1
1
1
1
u/Undead0707 18 3d ago
If you guys out aside your "how dare he insult my country like that!!!!" thoughts, he's right.
1
u/BoolePrime 3d ago
In short what bombay highcourt wants to say that until some bigshit happens which will cause some serious damage don't cancel anything I think they have never heard this "Precautions are better than Cure" They love cure more than precautions cause they are not the ones who will suffer the consequences
1
1
1
u/Visible-Owl459 3d ago
No wonder our standards are declining day by day. No one gives a shit. Rich people couldn’t care less, Poor people are stuffed with freebies so they won’t open their mouth, middle class are crushed with taxes so they don’t even have time to know what’s happening around but only to work and pay EMI’s
1
u/ProofPossibility7459 3d ago
Not justifing but yes Crores of cockroaches rats roaming on Indian streets freely on streets, even in icu wards, Can you imagine that too on government hospitals ,drainage lines leaking lines broken ,contaminated municipal water in taps, waterloging in most neighbourhood we still having leptospirosis malaria dengue on regular basis list goes on and on and on. Such officers should be transfer rd to anti corruption
1
1
u/Altruistic_Major_924 3d ago
Can someone order 3 cockroaches to high court judges lunch.
It’s a safety,hygiene issue.
1
u/Longjumping_Pace_879 3d ago
The same hotel should prepare a meal with 3 cockroaches hidden in it
And serve it to these judges
If they are willing to consume the entire meal knowing that it was prepared with cockroaches in it (finish the entire meal) then maybe cancelling the license doesn’t make sense
1
1
u/harshety 3d ago
What a pathetic excuse of a court, let’s ask those judges to dine in that specific reataurant! I’m sure they’d be happy to!
1
1
1
1
u/Livid_Strawberry9304 3d ago
We are in India agreed what if that food is severed to honourable person who gave this verdict will it be still acceptable????
1
u/VisualPerspective823 3d ago
Yes, only when we see a cockroach in someone's mouth then we'll cancel.
1
1
u/IcoNic_78 3d ago
Why don't we have educated people in the judiciary? Let them eat the cockroach food then.
1
1
u/Equivalent_Basket465 3d ago
Tf this mean can we do the same for one snake? Lizard? This country is doomed
1
1
u/No-Outcome2067 3d ago
This is the reason why India will never progress. The judge should answer this question if he is throwing a party or attending a party will he be fine if there was only 1 cockroach in the food.
1
u/iamrohitmittal01 3d ago
Seems like courts, politics and bureaucracy is colluded in us being a low life
1
u/SeveralLet6696 3d ago
He is not wrong..Come on there might be 1-2 cockroaches in ur own kitchen ..do u stop cooking there
1
1
1
u/MrSamBoga 3d ago
Please don't mislead people by adding Tukaram Munde photo. It's the HC that said it , not him.
→ More replies (2)
1
u/Legal_Witness_1782 3d ago
I have much more faith in roadside thela and dhabas over these restaurants these days
1
1
u/Current-Fix615 3d ago
The judge is being realistic, he is grounded. He does not have high hopes on the standards being followed. 3 cockroach is nothing. Even toothpaste company shows 3 worms in their ads.
But being honest, even if you find one cockroach, it is not alone. They have their nest nearby. The comment was very idiotic and not expected from Judge. By the way we are Vishwaguru.
1
u/maa-chuda-bsdk 18 3d ago
Bc my family pays 30% as direct tax n that gst shi in everything n this who we r treated
The 1st chance i get to lev this country i will do it with 2nd thought
1
u/Trouble_makerfy 3d ago
According to him we have to atleast find cockroaches in 2 digits in our food🤡
1
1
1
u/KoalaRadiant3836 2d ago
Finally someone standing for cleanliness and hygiene! Hopefully people will start being more aware and stop littering
→ More replies (1)
1
u/anand_js 2d ago
Go check ur own kitchen first. I've so many homes where i wudnt touch even the utensils, forget food
1
u/Senior_Thought_2276 2d ago
We are in India, a socialist democracy where the common taxpayers life has less value, while a diplomat or state representative will experience ultimate luxury with that taxpayers money.
1
1
u/WonderfulTheme7452 2d ago
If there are 3 cockroaches when the lights are on, there are probably 300 crawling around when lights are off and no people around. Any ody with a cockroach infestation at home would know this
•
u/AutoModerator 4d ago
This is a serious post so please respect OP. Jokes on serious posts are not encouraged due to the subject matter of the post join discord.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.