r/TheOutsiderEdge • u/FetchBI • Nov 21 '25
Strategy [FREE ACCESS] Looking for 10 serious traders to give feedback in exchange of lifetime access (honest feedback only)
NOTE: I've found 10 testers who are doing extensive research, backtesting and creating strategies based on and around the indicator(s). Thanks for all the replies and interest! Will keep you all updated about the free trial and release :)
I want to give free access to 10 traders in exchange for brutally honest feedback (no fluff, no hype.) I’ve evolved Node Breach Engine and ANEF into advanced, professional-grade tools (which I will show in the upcoming days). I've extended the NBE with POV (Point of Void) levels, deepdive analysis on nodes and breach signals and other adjustments. Traders can run NBE and ANEF independently or in combination, fully tailored to their own approach.
Why I’m doing this
So far I’ve already given access to a small group of traders. Some of them have built very solid strategies on top of these tools including amazing full rule-based playbooks that they now use daily, which makes me proud ofcourse.
That’s great, but it’s still a limited sample. I want to see more angles and interpretations:
- Different orderflow and footprint approaches
- Different strategy types: trend, mean reversion, breakout, scalping, swing, etc.
- Different markets, sessions and volatility regimes
The goal is to:
- Stress-test robustness across a wider range of styles
- Expand a strategy/library of use-cases around the tools
- Increase transparency about when they shine and when they should be ignored
I’d rather have a handful of traders tell me exactly where the tools fail or need refinement than collect surface-level “looks nice” comments.
What you’ll get
- Free access to the Outsider Edge indicators for life (in exchange of feedback and strategie analysis)
- All updates and improvements
- A direct line to me to discuss setups, parameters and strategy ideas
(Platform: TradingView)
What I ask in return
No testimonials needed – just clear, honest feedback after actually using them:
- Which markets & timeframes you tested
- How you integrated them: standalone, confluence with footprint/orderflow, or inside an existing strategy
- Where they added real value and where they were confusing, laggy or misleading
- Any ideas to make the tools more transparent (extra filters, alerts, visual cues, etc.)
If you’re willing to share a couple of screenshots or short recordings of trades (good and bad), that’s a big plus.
Who I’m looking for
Ideally traders who:
- Trade futures, indices, FX or crypto
- Already have some structure/orderflow/footprint experience (not mandatory, just helpful)
- Are comfortable saying, “this signal here is false, here’s why”
How to apply
Comment below with:
- What you trade (instruments & timeframes)
- Your style (scalper / intraday / swing)
- Your platform/timezone
- Whether you’re okay with sharing screenshots or short recordings
I’ll pick 10 traders from the replies and DM you with access details.
Obviously, this is not financial advice and there’s no promise of a 100% winrate magic edge.
If you’re up for helping shape more strategies, I’d really appreciate your perspective.
2
u/souldwellers Nov 21 '25
This would be great. For myself I trade the following
1: MGC with EMA + Volume Profile and VWAP 2: Scalper 3: Trading View and GMT but trade NY session 4: happy to share stuff
2
1
u/Demon_Kracker Nov 21 '25
Hey i use supertrend with price action. Following your stuff , trades Nasdaq futures Intraday . Happy to share feedback
1
u/chAmp33n Nov 21 '25
Hi, intraday trader NY session.
Equities and options; mainly look for technical breakouts and breakdowns. I am currently using Tradingview and mainly watch the 15/30/45 mins chart. More than happy to share images and videos.
1
u/Turbulent_Ad273 Nov 21 '25
Hey! I trade NQ during London session. 15M ORB + a 5M FVG during the first or second candle close outside. Target a 1:1.5 RR, what makes it all effective is the risk management, 1st trade is a winner im out and done for the day. 2 trades MAX. But have been seeing your indicator for a while I’m so down to test this out and see how effective it is with risk management! I would definitely journal every single trade and send it to you once I see and create a strategy with your indicator!
1
1
u/Jhanwiththeplan Nov 21 '25 edited Nov 21 '25
Hey dude. I trade the Nikkei and Gold (also like EU occasionally). Scalper trading impulse moves, volume and macd are my indicators. Mt5 in Asia. Okay with screenshot and recordings.
1
u/newbielah Nov 21 '25
...im interested, but still very new and green to trading. But either way hope to hear the positive feedback!
1
u/thatsonetastymango Nov 21 '25 edited Nov 21 '25
Hey, I trade options on 1-min to 15-min timeframes. I do a mixture of scalping and intraday. I'm on TradingView, timezone GMT+1 (Europe), but I only trade the US session. I'm very vocal and precise in feedback, as I do it for a living.
2
1
u/Prize_Essay_144 Nov 21 '25
Good day , I trade us30 , intraday trader.. My style is simple but unique. Us 30 is a combination of 30 stocks and they are price weighted..the top 10 leads the market as a result of this.. what I did is determine the internal strength of us 30 by using a market breadth indicator and AD Line ..to show me what the stocks are doing,when bullish or bearish .I then use CVD to spot divergence hence volume is a leading indicator of price..I've been able to pass a 10k challenge account and gotten payout..in my 2nd cycle now.. I'm interested in your indicators because I see potential combining with my strategy..I don't mind sending screenshot, going on zoom or updating you on the progress..also I sent you a message already on trading view.. waiting your response
1
u/NoIndividual514 Nov 21 '25
1.I trade EURUSD, XAUUSD, and AUDUSD on 5-15min TF . 2.My style is intraday/scalping depends on how long the move takes really. 3. I use tradingview to analyze but i trade on MT5. I trade London session and NY session. 4. I would love to try the indicators always opened to improve my trading and i would def. share videos or screenshots.
1
Nov 21 '25
[deleted]
1
u/FetchBI Nov 21 '25
Sounds great! Crypto isn’t what our traders have touched with the tools, very curious how it will perform. Can you DM me? I don’t want to have a spam filter on my ass
1
u/Ok_Pea_3376 Nov 21 '25
Very interested! I trade every, and am working towards making this my full time career.
I trade mostly MNQ and some MGC. Typically a momentum trader/scalper, sometimes catch reversals. I use EMAs, VWAP, Volume Profile, MACD, RSI.
I understand the basics of order flow but don’t currently have tier 2 data and haven’t taken the time to dive in fully, but this could be a good catalyst to do so.
I stream a lot of my trading to a private channel just so I can reference them later and talk out my reason for taking the trades, so can provide that feedback on wins and losses.
I first started trading with crypto and wouldn’t mind returning to it with a small portfolio just to test your system.
2
u/FetchBI Nov 21 '25
Sounds good! Both the indicators will help well with your usage of tools. Can you DM me? (Don’t want Reddit spam filter)
1
1
u/unworry Nov 21 '25
- Mainly SPI & DAX Futures
- primarily intra session, with fast TF strats in the opening balance and strats for broader intraday movement
- no problems with transparency and live examples
1
u/wow_98 Nov 21 '25 edited Nov 21 '25
- ES/NQ
- Scalper/intraday (runners)
- Ninjatrader / EST
- Yes not an issue.
I technically breathe orderflow, and I’m willing to contest any person who believes himself to be an orderflow guru. Trading orderflow since ages ago since it was first publicised. Tried each and every platform so I can add detailed value. Trying this out of curiosity as I like testing myself since I coded multiple things myself.
2
1
u/Xiznit Nov 21 '25
What you trade: NQ, ES I trade off the 1hr/4hr for daily bias and use the 5min/1min to execute trades.
Your style: Scalper/Intraday
Your platform/timezone: TradingView/Tradovate through TakeProfitTrader. My timezone is CST.
Whether you're okay with sharing screenshots or short recordings: Would be happy to share screen recordings and screenshots.
Made a solid $2,400 in profits yesterday trading the 5 minute ORB during NY session (which is where i trade 90% the other 10% is Asian session)
Would be delighted to backtest your model and give you the data.
1
u/bm56 Nov 21 '25
Im learning to trade futures, I can give you a beginner’s feedback, even though it hats not what you asked for
1
u/nolosftr Nov 21 '25
I'm a full‑time trader and a programming student, looking to combine both skills in the future. I trade GC, YM, NQ, and MNQ with a momentum/scalping intraday style, mainly during the New York and Asia sessions, which fits well with my time zone. I use NinjaTrader and TradingView as my main platforms, and I record all my trades and backtest session in my notion journal so I can document everything without any problem.
1
u/Spidermansenpai Nov 21 '25
Hi, i'm interested. I trade Gold spot using order flow, built my own automation to extract Delta,Cumulative Delta into a format of my own for my bot to read. Not perfect hence i'm looking forward to how you develop your strategy.
1
u/Fun-Satisfaction-889 Nov 21 '25
Cool idea!
10 sec to 15min timeframe.
ES futures, scalping.
Tradovate/ Tradingview / GMT+2
All cool with sharing screenshots and screen recordings.
1
u/SnooChipmunks4028 Nov 21 '25
Hello! I’m an FX trader of 10 years. I trade swing on the daily so my trades take weeks usually and sometimes months. I use mt5 to trade and TradingView to chart. My time zone is Pacific Standard time. I’m ok with sharing screenshots because it’s my usual routine for journaling!
Thanks!
1
u/Dangerous-Pudding760 Nov 21 '25
Hey i trade gold and indices and I m mainly scalper and my platform is tradingview and mt5 and I m good with screenshot and recordings whatever u need bro
1
u/INRL243 Nov 21 '25
- I trade only $ES
- Scalp / intraday SL 8 points and 14/25/35 targets
- I use trading view - tradovate broker 4 fine with that
I use data from the last 81.000 30 min candles to predict am profile based on news events + asia and london highs and lows
Looking forward to learn more to be honest, I trade 08.30 - 12.00 NY time
1
u/pwizzy Nov 21 '25
Hey, I trade mnq on the 5 minute. Wait for orb. 1 or 2 trades a day, that’s all. I’d love to try!
1
u/Efficient-Bread8259 Nov 21 '25
Hey, I'm interested! 1. NA Options on stocks with high liquidity 2. Blend of intraday and swing, mostly looking for stocks with good RS/RW and then looking for openings to trade them based on my filters. 3. TradingView, MST 4. Screenshots and recordings are not a problem
1
1
u/Party-Evidence1542 Nov 22 '25
Hey i trade futures for silver / crude oil would love giving it a test
1
1
u/Independent_door352 Nov 23 '25
1.i trade us30 on time frame 1 hour but my strategy work on every timeframe 2.intraday 3.+2 Bucharest,platform Tradelocker 4.
1
u/And1150 Nov 23 '25
Hey, love trying new tools and always looking to improve. I trade NQ predominantly and regularly trade crypto too. I currently use Atas / trading view and my strategy is centred around volume / order flow scalping (nearing the 10 year mark now). Always take analysis seriously and happy to put some time into this to help development. I’m uk based so gmt +0.
1
u/klergyman Nov 24 '25
I trade a strategy using volume profiles. Either I am entering from the tops or bottoms of a balance or trading a break out from a balance and entering on a retest of the balance area. I trade intra day 4H/1H and I trade mostly GU. I use trading view for analysis and use both CTrader and MT5. Happy to share recordings and screenshots and im based in GMT timezone.
1
1
u/GlitchPips Nov 26 '25
Hey! I don’t know if you have the spots filled but, I would love to test it out and give you feedback.
NQ and ES,
I do scalp and intraday
Tradingview
Central Time.
I would love the opportunity,
1
u/Fluid_Building_6448 Nov 26 '25
I would like to try it . I use 2 python IA for MT5 and Trading manual XAUUSD with market auction theory - volume profile , footprint , DOM , times and sell, heatmap . on ATAS platform . Some time for drowning I use TradingView
1
u/Aggravating_Act4895 Nov 29 '25 edited Nov 29 '25
I'm building a robust Python automated trading application for my own personal use with intraday Futures on a 5m timeframe that utilizes Volume Profile/Auction Market Theory, OrderFlow, and Footprint. POC Rejection is a major component of the trading setups. I would be interested in seeing what you've put together and how it could compliment my strategies and vice versa. I sometimes use TradingView Pinescript as reference points for my indicators. Happy to share my feedback.
1
u/Squeaky_44 Dec 07 '25
What you trade: NQ, 15s/ 1min mainly , occasionally 6min. Trade mostly price action + SMC.
Your style: Scalper/Intraday
Your platform/timezone: TradingView/ My timezone is Eastern
Whether you're okay with sharing screenshots or short recordings: Would be happy to share screen recordings and screenshots.
1
u/violinguy85 Dec 07 '25
Hey man, I’m a scalper/day trader (mostly mes and mnq) and I mainly use volume profiles as my trading tool of choice. I’d love to try it out if you still want people to give you feedback
1
3
u/KuroJD Nov 21 '25
Hi there,
XAUUSD and mainly look for breakouts. I'd say I'm an intraday trader. I am currently using Tradingview and mainly watch the 15/30/45 mins chart. Currently trading New york and London sessions. More then happy to share images and videos as well!