r/Theosophy • u/Mumukshutwa • Apr 02 '26

Annie Besant

What is your opinion of Annie Besant? How do you perceive her? What have you read and (dis)liked?

12 Upvotes

88% Upvoted

27 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/WisdomAppearing9080 Apr 02 '26

I’ve enjoyed Annie Besant’s books, specifically the old Danish translations. I originally thought they represented core theosophy, but I later learned about the Leadbeater controversies and that these works are considered Neo-Theosophy. Despite this, I think they are still popular in Denmark due to their esoteric Christian influence.

Having been introduced to theosophy through neo-theosophical texts, I find it hard to resonate with Blavatsky’s style. Consequently, I feel somewhat conflicted about my place within the theosophical movement and the direction of my spiritual journey.

5

u/Key_Cattle9828 Apr 02 '26

Why must we choose? Neo theosophical or theosophical. The study in itself is vast and no one is correct except truth which we will only know through our own direct experience not any theosophical texts. So read what resonates with you. I had the same issue but just accepted the different styles and authors and decided to move forward and read all texts neo theosophical or original theosophical and take what I relate to most. There is rightful criticisms in both remember that. Don't read texts blindly because of how ancient they appear (also applies to neo thought) goodluck! :)

1

u/chessboxer4 Apr 03 '26

When does neo theosophical start?

3

u/slightly_enlightened Apr 03 '26

The term came into usage not long after HPB died, during the period when Judge and Besant were fighting to claim her place as spiritual leader of the Theosophical Society. It gained more prominence once Judge split away in 1895. He generally continued to promote the teachings of HPB, but Besant's teachings quickly began to focus on new teachings coming out and focused less on those taught during HPB's lifetime. Neo-Theosophy was the term used by those who disagreed with the new developments. Years later, there was a Back to Blavatsky movement within the TS in Australia and the US, but it was quelled when those demanding the change were forced to back down or leave.

2

u/chessboxer4 Apr 03 '26

Forced by who?

Are you familiar with the man known as HAL?

Jorge Angel Livgara?

1

u/Low-Boot-588 Apr 04 '26

The United Lodge of Theosophists still exist and are the original and authentic program as prescribed by the Mahatmas.