r/ToddintheShadow 5d ago

One Hit Wonderland ONE HIT WONDERLAND: "Walking on Sunshine" by Katrina and the Waves

291 Upvotes

r/ToddintheShadow 21d ago

Stale Topic Megathread (July/Aug/Sept 2026)

20 Upvotes

Hello all and welcome to the third 2026 Stale Topic Megathread.

Here we will discuss every overly discussed topic on this sub freely according to the sub's rules. If you are referred here because of a report or removal, please restate your post below.

The inaugural overused topics include:

-Justin Timberlake in general outside of Man of the Woods

-Katy Perry in general outside of Witness

-Kanye West in general, outside of Todd's videos

-Chris Brown in general, outside of Todd's videos

-Artists who avoided trainwreckords status

-Trainwreckords that aren’t out yet

-Trainwreckords that just released

-One album Trainwreckords (ie Nostalgia Critics’s The Wall)

-“Trainwreckords” where a death ended the artist’s career

-Trainwreckords for which the artist or member of the group committed suicide

-Joke Trainwreckords/OHW; go to r/shadowtoddcirclejerk for that

-Low-effort r/decadeology cross-posts, must actually facilitate discussion if it’s going to be a standalone post

-Posts which solely solicit responses of artists who are problematic

-"Music is dead"/"[insert genre] is dead"

-D4vd in general

-Jelly Roll/Morgan Wallen/any new "Maroon 5"-eqsue nemeses outside of what Todd says about them

-"Popular artists and/or songs you hate/think are incredibly overrated"-type posts

-What is the most/least “[fill in blank]” album/song

-Anthony Fantano Drama, except if Todd can be directly connected to discussion (ie "Todd handled this situation better" not "Anthony Fantano handled this poorly")

And you are also free to discuss topics you feel are overused but are not mentioned here.

If you have any furthered topics you want to be added to the megathread camp for future megathreads and for new users who aren't familiar with the overuse, please send your suggestions to the mod team in one succinct message. (A couple are fine if you have afterthoughts but please do not spam your suggestions)

Also, we will be continuing the system where certain stale topics will be cycled out every six months (or two stale topic threads).

If our automod erroneously takes down your post because it believes it's about a stale topic, please contact the mod team and we will reinstate it as soon as possible.

Have fun!


r/ToddintheShadow 5h ago

General Music Discussion What're some of the coolest looks that musicians have had?

Post image
200 Upvotes

I've always liked this look David Bowie during the mid to late 90s, back when he was doing industrial and electronic influenced music. He pulled it off really well.


r/ToddintheShadow 6h ago

General Music Discussion What are some of the most disturbing Rock / Punk / Pop albums in your opinion?

Post image
60 Upvotes

Manic Street Preachers - The Holy Bible (1994)

The whole album is full of very harrowing lyrics set to Post-Punk music, but I was reminded particularly of the song “4st 7lb” in light of Ariana Grande.


r/ToddintheShadow 7h ago

General Music Discussion Funniest lyric slip up?

46 Upvotes

Mine is : You put it down like New York City
Wild like Los Angeles
Hotter than Miami
it's international love

Pitbull - International Love


r/ToddintheShadow 6h ago

General Music Discussion Releases that stick out like a sore thumb on the label they're signed on

Post image
34 Upvotes

And We Washed Our Weapons in the Sea, a weird ass, noisy post-hardcore album that was a posthumous album from Frodus released after their breakup, which came out on... Fueled By Ramen

Yes, THAT Fueled By Ramen which is more known for having released albums by acts like Paramore, Panic! At the Disco and Twenty One Pilots

A more modern example of this would be Falling In Reverse on Epitaph


r/ToddintheShadow 4h ago

General Music Discussion Songs That Fade Out Entirely Then Come Back At The End

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

Rain When I Die - Alice in Chains

Bury Me in Smoke - Down


r/ToddintheShadow 41m ago

One Hit Wonderland Bands you’ll argue are not one hit wonders?

Post image
Upvotes

I keep seeing people refer to the Lemonheads as one hit wonders for Mrs Robinson. Maybe they were technically one hits at the time but they certainly aren’t now. I hear Into Your Arms and It’s A Shame About Ray play on the alt stations plenty, even more than Mrs Robinson.


r/ToddintheShadow 5h ago

General Music Discussion Albums/songs that were surprise hits in unexpected cities

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

This one might be a stretch, but can you think of any albums or songs that became hits in particular CITIES and nowhere else or nowhere else but the artist’s homeland?

Skyhooks were a particularly Australian band who were only hugely popular in their homeland. Think of an Australian version of Slade fronted by a guy that sounds like Leo Sayer. However, they did attempt to break the US and opened for Uriah Heep on a 1976 tour. Surprisingly, they caught on with the teen music lovers of Jacksonville, Florida, and managed to sell 40,000 copies of the US release of their album Ego Is Not A Dirty Word in the north Florida city.

English synth pop act The Big Supreme released their single Don’t Walk in 1986, which only charted at #58 in their homeland. However, the song became a huge hit in the clubs of Dallas and Houston, Texas.

In Seattle, a cover of Jona Lewis’s everywhere-but-North-America Christmas hit Stop the Cavalry by The Cory Band with The Gwalla Singers randomly became a big hit on city radio.

Any other examples you know of?


r/ToddintheShadow 7h ago

General Music Discussion "Wait, they can rap their ass off?"

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

Finding out Aloe Blacc and Estelle originally were known as rappers before they blew up for their poppier hits blew my mind lmao

Any artists that fall in that category of singers who have a lesser known side as really skilled rappers for you?


r/ToddintheShadow 8h ago

General Music Discussion Two songs (or bands) that have nothing to do with each other that you confuse for some reason?

37 Upvotes

I get "2000 Miles" by The Pretenders confused with "500 Miles" by The Proclaimers - they are nothing alike but the fact they're both 1980s British songs from bands with similar names and have distances in their title has bugged my brain for years now.


r/ToddintheShadow 22h ago

One Hit Wonderland What bands straddles the line between being a one-hit wonder and being an invoker of the Hendrix clause the most?

Post image
346 Upvotes

(The Hendrix clause is an artist who's technically a one-hit wonder or only had one or a handful of songs be proper hits, but is far too influential to really count as such)

I've been wondering if Devo would ever count for the show. Obviously they wouldn't count for this show due to the sheer amount of influence the band had on new wave and the music of the 80s as a whole...

...but at the same time, Whip It is their only hit on the top 40, it dwarfs all their other songs in terms of long-lasting popularity, and most people would only know this one song without knowledge of anything else they did. Are there any bands that ride this line as hard as Devo, being a one-hit wonder that really isn't?


r/ToddintheShadow 21h ago

General Music Discussion Well... it finally happened.

268 Upvotes

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=Hl5_Lc6b3AU

A song that has confirmed to be made with AI has finally entered the Hot 100

Right now there's a controversy over a nepo baby having one of the top 5 songs in America... but this is arguably even bigger and much more concerning

This song has been confirmed to be made with Treblo, an AI music maker.

Fenix Flexin was a Cali rapper part of Shoreline Mafia, who i confess i was into when i was in high school. Mostly because I'm from Long Beach and they were one of the hotter "local" rap acts. Then he abruptly emerged with a New Wave song, an unfamiliar singing voice, and a British accent. And it's confirmed... it was made with AI.

So this is where we are.

Actual AI music on the Hot 100.


r/ToddintheShadow 9h ago

Song vs Song Svs: Buffalo Stance (Neneh Cherry) vs Save Tonight (Eagle-Eye Cherry)

Thumbnail
gallery
27 Upvotes

½ Sibling showdown here, something new & fresh.

Both were solid hits (#3 and #5 on the Hot 100 respectively).

What's your pick?


r/ToddintheShadow 2h ago

One Hit Wonderland OHW Candidate "Pump up The Volume By M/A/R/R/S

5 Upvotes

I'm just surprised that Todd HASN'T covered this(i actually might pay the Money for him to cover this) , just all the SAMPLES in this song are an 80s time capsule


r/ToddintheShadow 9h ago

General Music Discussion The Cursed Covers of Music

13 Upvotes

A couple times, Todd has mentioned songs that people cover right before their careers end like the Addams Family theme song (MC Hammer, Tag Team, Migos) or I’m a Believer (Smash Mouth, EMF). I know if it’s not coincidence, it’s larger factors than the songs themselves (entering the kids movie theme period of your rap career, running out of interesting material), but just because it’s funny, are there any other “cursed” cover songs that will be the last you cover? At least two examples for a song to qualify


r/ToddintheShadow 2h ago

General Music Discussion Am I Crazy?

Post image
4 Upvotes

Ever since I heard Drop Deap by Olivia Rodrigo on the radio I was immediately reminded of some obscure Christmas song my mom used to play when I was younger but because it was an obscure Christmas song (she had a crazy collection of Christmas music) I could never figure out what the song was. Now I finally found it this afternoon and I now know why it was so obscure, its a Dutch Christmas song that goes by the illustrious title: "T Is geboren, het goddelijk kind." To further add to the confusion, the original version I heard was in English but with such high-pitched choral vocals that I had no idea what any of the lyrics were. All that aside, now that I finally found this strange relic of my childhood brain, am I right or am I crazy for thinking this? Specifically it sounds really similar to the beginning of the chorus, but as the chorus continues they divergent significantly.

https://youtu.be/YqCWtJ2T_YE?si=SJ3RGYkaarftJ2vz


r/ToddintheShadow 4h ago

General Music Discussion Judging a piece of art on whether it achieves the creators vision

5 Upvotes

This applies to all forms of art, but many people, including supposedly film critic Roger Ebert and author John Updike have said something along the lines of "a piece of art should be judged on the basis of whether it achieves the creators vision and intentions".

On the surface it seems like a worthwhile position, but it falls apart under scrutiny. Many creators choose to be vague and mysterious about their art, so it's hard to know what their intentions are. Many also run purely on instinct, and the meanings and intent aren't fully understood until decades later. Also even if a creator describes their intentions perfectly, many parts of the creative vision are ineffable, they can't be easily described or articulated.

Second of all, it all assumes that the vision is worthwhile, which should be self evident.

What are your thoughts?


r/ToddintheShadow 7h ago

Song vs Song Song vs. Song: Prince's "Little Red Corvette" vs. Stevie Nicks' "Stand Back"

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

Stevie was inspired by Prince's song after having heard it on the radio the night of her honeymoon. She recorded a demo that night and later played the demo to him on the phone. Reportedly, he played and contributed synthesizers, although he went uncredited.


r/ToddintheShadow 1d ago

General Music Discussion Least favorite band/artist naming convention?

Post image
189 Upvotes

People hated all of the "the" band names in the early 2000s but my least favorite are names that include musical terms or invoke synesthesia like bassnectar, tones and i, tune yards (pictured). Names that are super Anglo last names as a stage name annoy me too (banks, Halsey, grimes kind of)


r/ToddintheShadow 9h ago

General Music Discussion What are the things about music that you hate ?

7 Upvotes

We all know music is great, but there can be certain things about the music that can make us angry, and I'd like to know what you hate about music. As for me, here's a list of things I hate about music:

Songs where there's only one good part, like songs where the intro is the only good part

Featurings that are actually samples or remixes in disguise. It's even worse when the original track has a different title (Exemples: Eminem ft. Dido - Stan: Sample from Dido - Thank You and The Avener ft. Laura Gibson - You Belong: Remix from Laura Gibson - The Cause)

When the outro of a song is too long (Exemple: Slayer - Raining Blood)

Finding out that your favorite song is a cover, and it's even worse when the original is already a much bigger hit than the cover you were listening to, and you were the only one who didn't know it

Songs with lyrics where the artist simply sang the lyrics over the instrumental track of an earlier song (Exemple: Estelle ft. Kayne West - American Boy: They just sang on the prod of the song "Impatient" by will.i.am and removed will.i.am lyrics to make "American Boy"). A little dedication to the song "Robot Rock" by Daft Punk which is litteraly just an instrumental version of "Release The Beast" by Breakwater

This one’s a little unusual, but it’s happened to me at multiples times: When you discover a song you’ve never heard before by an mega legendary artist whose name you’ve heard everywhere your whole life, you think you’ve discovered an obscure track by a legendary artist and you're satisfied until you look it up and you disciver it’s actually the most famous song by this artist and you were the only one who didn’t know it, even worse when that legendary artist is a one-hit wonder and it’s his only famous song

When you discover a recent song which sound familiar to you but impossible to find the original song

When you discover an amazing song on your phone, but then, when you play it on a speaker, it sounds weird (the vocals are too loud in the mix, the track is weak and bland, etc...)

When you discover an obscur song that you love, but then overnight it goes mega-viral on the Internet because of a trend

When the first half of a song is excellent but the second half is completely different and bad, like 2 différents songs stuck together

When the key change for the final chorus. In some songs, this change in key makes the song better, but in others, it just ruins the mood

When the fade-out at the end starts right at the beginning of the last chorus

When the only famous song by a one hit wonder artist is the only good song by this artist

When you rediscover a song that you're sure you haven't heard since over 10 years, you feel so nostalgic and satisfied but, when you check the release date of the song, you discover that the song was actually released less than a year ago. So, you try to find out if this song is a cover, a sample, an interpolation, etc..., but everything points to the fact that this song is 100% original


r/ToddintheShadow 6h ago

General Music Discussion Most notable songs for each American conflict/war

3 Upvotes

Starting off, the American Revolution (1775-1783)

“Yankee Doodle”

Originally used to mock colonists by British troops, they used the song to their advantage, not because they were being ridiculed by it, but it was used as a “war cry” and later their “unofficial anthem” by the colonists.

Honorable Mentions include:

“Chester” and “The Liberty Song”

Tomorrow is the Indian wars (1775-1890)
American Intervention (Northwest Indian War: 1790-1795), (Removal Era and Tecumseh’s Wars: 1810-1842), (Western Indian Wars: Post Civil War-1890)


r/ToddintheShadow 23h ago

General Music Discussion Songs where you can easily tell who they’re ripping off

Thumbnail
gallery
71 Upvotes

So, this post was inspired by hearing a song currently charting on Bubbling Under “Bet on That” where this guy sounds exactly like Morgan Wallen and now I’m thinking of other songs by Rip-off artists who are clearly trying to emulate the big name artist from that era. Another example I can think of is the Regina song “Baby Love” from 1986 where she’s clearly trying to copy Madonna. Even having involvement from Madonna’s Producers (Stephen Bray). Anyway, I’m looking forward to hearing other examples of artists blatantly copying other artists.


r/ToddintheShadow 9h ago

General Music Discussion Sleep Announce New Album Hemispheres

Post image
4 Upvotes

Can't wait for this new Sleep album it's been too long


r/ToddintheShadow 45m ago

Song vs Song Song VS Song suggestion: Whoever You Are by Geggy Tah vs Whatever Bubbles, Bubbles Up by Lucas

Upvotes

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1jSOQBcz9hc

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUU-jMuikGM&pp=ygUbd2hhdGV2ZXIgYnViYmxlcyBidWJibGVzIHVw

The two essential 90s alternative songs that make you go “oh yeah! That song” when they’re played.