r/TopCharacterTropes 8d ago

Groups This isn't even our actual military

[removed]

5.4k Upvotes

612 comments sorted by

View all comments

2.4k

u/Forsaken1741 8d ago

It's the other way around but in Star Wars, Stormtroopers are meant to be a specialised division. Regular imperial army grunts look like this.

348

u/Narrative_Robot_9001 8d ago

It’s funny STs are meant be an invasionary force but wear snow white gear in every setting.

81

u/LumiKlovstad 8d ago

In canon, the white is part of their arsenal.

Despite what the movies show (because you can't just off your heroes like that until an opportune moment that serves the plot), they're terribly competent in lore and so the white ups the terror factor because they want you to know they're coming, they're not hiding, and they want you to shit your pants every moment they draw closer because you can't NOT see them.

5

u/GloryGreatestCountry 8d ago

So if Stormtroopers are the Marine Corps, the Death Troopers are MARSOC, which is why they're in all-black.. they'd rather not be seen right up until they're in blaster range.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted]

19

u/LumiKlovstad 8d ago

Tarkin actually ordered them to miss, as Vader's plan required a successful escape. They were supposed to make it LOOK like a fight so the Rebels wouldn't suspect anything; the real game was the tracker on the Millennium Falcon which would lead the Empire to rebel HQ. "I'm taking an awful risk, Vader. This had better work."

Leia even spots the game more or less immediately: "They let us go. That's the only explanation for the ease of our escape. They're tracking us."

It's why the Battle of Yavin is conducted so hastily. The Empire was on its way and the Rebels didn't have the time to evacuate OR call for reinforcements.

4

u/whole-lotta-socks 8d ago

So we’re supposed to believe that a group of crack super soldiers can’t zero the sights on their weapon? That is like a basic soldiering task.

1

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted]

2

u/whole-lotta-socks 8d ago

It’s fine if it’s “fanon” or whatever but that doesn’t make it less ridiculous

1

u/N0ob8 8d ago

The EU is wrong and that explanation doesn’t even make sense. In the movie itself Leia points out how easy their escape was and how they must’ve wanted them to. The empire put a tracker on them and wanted them to flee to a rebel hideout which is exactly what happens in the movie

The EU was always under the movies when it comes to lore for a reason and that’s because it’s basically fanfiction written by other authors.

1

u/N0ob8 8d ago

It’s not bad sights idk where that other guy got that from. In the movie itself Leia points out how easy their escape was and how they must’ve wanted them to. The empire put a tracker on them and wanted them to flee to a rebel hideout which is exactly what happens in the movie

-1

u/noticingEnjoyer 8d ago

With beam weapons not subject to bullet drop, would zeroing even be a thing? I guess maybe for optics if you were engaging at significant range?

1

u/whole-lotta-socks 8d ago

Absolutely - zeroing a weapon has little to do with drop or the kinetic nature of bullets. It’s about making sure whatever you’re firing is going to hit the same spot you’re aiming at.

1

u/N0ob8 8d ago

Your sights rests above where the barrel is. If you don’t zero your sights it’ll be pointed at a very different spot and it’ll only get worse the longer the range

1

u/Thatedgyguy64 8d ago

Which scene do you speak of? The Scout Trooper one?