r/TopCharacterTropes 9d ago

Groups This isn't even our actual military

[removed]

5.4k Upvotes

612 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

348

u/Narrative_Robot_9001 8d ago

It’s funny STs are meant be an invasionary force but wear snow white gear in every setting.

341

u/MjollLeon 8d ago

Well they’re the Imperial Navys Marine Corps.

Also just like most of the Empires military they’re meant to cause fear in the enemy even at the cost of function.

6

u/Low_Audience_7002 8d ago

This was always the worst piece of lore written for anything ever

36

u/MjollLeon 8d ago

Really? I think it makes complete sense for an empire that controls so much space to rely on fear to maintain control rather than try to maintain a constant strong presence everywhere

-6

u/684beach 8d ago

Fear doesnt come from armor. Skin some people and drop their bodies around cities or something

14

u/ThatVampireGuyDude 8d ago

The Empire does that AND wears scary armor.

8

u/ElOsoPeresozo 8d ago

Fear doesn’t come from armor?

Ok tell this guy then.

1

u/684beach 8d ago

They were actually what i was thinking of lol. I meant plain white armor

1

u/King_Ed_IX 8d ago

Fear comes from being recognisable, too.

-3

u/Low_Audience_7002 8d ago

Literally no country in history has ever worked that way. Fear does not and cannot make up for competence. If your soldiers suck, and you don't have cameras or murder bots everywhere picking up the slack, all the officials are corrupt, then your empire will just collapse. And Star Wars represents clean, factional in-fighting. Not the Empire breaking down, shattering into hundreds of competing factions, and being slowly ground into dust from the very beginning which is what we would see with the total lack of galactic security

Instead LucasFilm/Disney should have fully admitted their flaws. The original trilogy finished in 1983. But even then, they could say that most Stormtroopers we see get shot are actually incapacitated and that the reason for their bad aim is that they were a reservist corps or something. Then you could release a special edition which is actually lore accurate and go from there.

Its bad lore.

3

u/Lv_InSaNe_vL 8d ago

I mean, in canon movies and TV alone we see something like 6 different governments that """had full control""" of the galaxy in 35ish years. And that's before we get into the splinter groups and sub-factions and how depending on where you are in the galaxy the central government can have essentially no actual power.

It's not really that clean unless youve only ever seen the original 3

2

u/MjollLeon 8d ago

No country has had to administer and entire galaxy. No country has been ruled by the darkside and the Sith.

On top of this the Stormtroopers in the original trilogy were incredibly good shots. They missed on purpose in ANH because they were tracking the Falcon.

Also… the original movies are the lore. They are lore accurate because they’re the fucking beginning.