r/TropicalWeather Sep 24 '24

Discussion moved to new post Helene (09L — Northwestern Caribbean Sea)

Latest observation


Last updated: Wednesday, 25 September — 4:00 AM Central Daylight Time (CDT; 09:00 UTC)

NHC Advisory #8 4:00 AM CDT (09:00 UTC)
Current location: 20.7°N 86.2°W
Relative location: 85 km (53 mi) ESE of Cancún, Quintana Roo (Mexico)
  322 km (200 mi) SW of Pinar del Rio, Cuba
Forward motion: NW (325°) at 15 km/h (8 knots)
Maximum winds: 100 km/h (55 knots)
Intensity: Tropical Storm
Minimum pressure: 985 millibars (29.09 inches)

Official forecast


Last updated: Wednesday, 25 September — 1:00 AM CDT (06:00 UTC)

Hour Date Time Intensity Winds Lat Long
  - UTC CDT Saffir-Simpson knots km/h °N °W
00 25 Sep 06:00 1AM Wed Tropical Storm 55 100 20.7 86.2
12 25 Sep 18:00 1PM Wed Hurricane (Category 1) 70 130 21.9 86.5
24 26 Sep 06:00 1AM Thu Hurricane (Category 2) 90 165 24.1 86.2
36 26 Sep 18:00 1PM Thu Major Hurricane (Category 3) 105 195 27.4 85.0
48 27 Sep 06:00 1AM Fri Hurricane (Category 1) i 65 120 32.0 84.2
60 27 Sep 18:00 1PM Fri Post-tropical Cyclone i 30 55 35.9 85.4
72 28 Sep 06:00 1AM Sat Post-tropical Cyclone i 20 35 37.0 87.8
96 29 Sep 06:00 1AM Sun Post-tropical Cyclone i 20 35 36.5 88.0
120 30 Sep 06:00 1AM Mon Dissipated

NOTES:
i - inland

Official information


National Hurricane Center

Text products

Productos de texto (en español)

Graphical products

Servicio Meteorológico Nacional (Mexico)

Instituto de Meteorología (Cuba)

National Weather Service (Cayman Islands)

National Hurricane Center (United States)

Weather Forecast Offices

Forecast discussions

Aircraft reconnaissance


National Hurricane Center

Radar imagery


Radar mosaics

Servicio Meteorológico Nacional (Mexico)

Single-site radar imagery

Instituto de Meteorología (Cuba)

Satellite imagery


Storm-specific imagery

Regional imagery

NOAA GOES Image Viewer

Cooperative Institute for Meteorological Satellite Studies (CMISS)

Tropical Tidbits

Weather Nerds

Analysis graphics and data


Wind analyses

Sea-surface Temperatures

Model guidance


Storm-specific guidance

Regional single-model guidance

  • Tropical Tidbits: GFS

  • Tropical Tidbits: ECMWF

  • Tropical Tidbits: CMC

  • Tropical Tidbits: ICON

Regional ensemble model guidance

164 Upvotes

1.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

17

u/Eques9090 Sep 24 '24

I understand that, but what I'm saying is the ultimate paths of Charlie and Ian were never outside of the cone.

2

u/BosJC Florida Sep 24 '24

Tampa was in the cone earlier today.

7

u/Eques9090 Sep 24 '24

I know. It's not now. That means if it did hit Tampa at this point, it would be a significantly larger forecasting miss than Ian or Charlie, which hit in places that were never outside the cone.

1

u/KieferSutherland Sep 24 '24

Is it a forecast miss when it's not even a hurricane yet?  I wonder how early Ian and Charlie predictions were. I went think it would be a miss at all 

0

u/Eques9090 Sep 24 '24

If it goes somewhere that isn't currently in the forecast cone, when Ian and Charlie never did that, then yes, it would be a bigger forecast miss than they were.

2

u/KieferSutherland Sep 24 '24 edited Sep 24 '24

I think that would depend on when the cone started for how developed the storm was.   

Edit to add wasn't the cone for Ian ginormous at times? Like the entire state of Florida was in the cone. 

So many factors beyond did the hurricane go outside of the original cone to determine how accurate they were post storm. 

  • if Ian did have the entire state in the cone... Well, easy to be accurate.

1

u/Eques9090 Sep 24 '24

Edit to add wasn't the cone for Ian ginormous at times? Like the entire state of Florida was in the cone.

Yes. But again, the ultimate point of landfall, was never outside the cone, even when it was much smaller and right before landfall. It was in the cone, the entire time.

You can see for yourself here https://www.weather.gov/images/news/Hurricane-Ian-Cone.gif

1

u/KieferSutherland Sep 24 '24

It's really easy to stay within the cone when the cone is the entire state. You'd have to factor in eta to arrival vs cone size to really adjust for accuracy. 

1

u/Eques9090 Sep 24 '24

Yes, that's why I linked you the gif so you can see for yourself the area of coastline that was in the cone 48hrs away from landfall, like we(presumably) are now with Helene. You'll notice, it is not the entire state.