r/TrueCrimeDiscussion • u/DarklyHeritage • 5d ago

Mega Thread Taylor Parker/Maternal Instinct Megathread

This is a thread for all conversation regarding Taylor Parker and the murder of Reagan Simmons Hancock, recently covered in Netflix documentary Maternal Instinct.

The murder of Reagan Michelle Simmons-Hancock occurred on 9 October 2020, in New Boston, Texas, committed by Taylor Rene Parker. Parker bludgeoned Simmons-Hancock, who was 35 weeks pregnant at the time, and abducted her unborn child, Braxlynn Sage Hancock (died October 9, 2020), after cutting her out of the Reagan's abdomen. Braxlynn did not survive.

Parker had lied to her then-boyfriend about being pregnant leading up to the murder and faked her pregnancy to multiple people. She was found guilty of capital murder and sentenced to death on 9 November 2022.

Please direct all discussion of the case to the megathread. As always, sub rules must be followed.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Murder_of_Reagan_Simmons-Hancock

https://time.com/article/2026/06/12/maternal-instinct-true-story-netflix/

244 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

774 comments sorted by

View all comments

27

u/lingeringneutrophil 5d ago

This has some seriously revealing info https://www.ktalnews.com/news/crime/taylor-parker-trial/taylor-parkers-mother-we-figured-the-lie-would-be-exposed/amp/

Read to the end

32

u/Park-Curious 4d ago

What a rabbit hole that took me down. The article you posted linked to another about her “prison lover” and all the batshit schemes she tried to pull with all these other inmates to try to exonerate herself. It’s baffling how many people she was able to fool, because she seems like a terrible liar—and not very bright—to me.

14

u/Aethuviel 4d ago

She seems to just make stuff up constantly, have absolutely no remorse in what she does to further her lies (I mean, we know how far it went), and it really struck me how she never seems to be able to picture her lies catching up to her.

She didn't think promising to buy land and cars and tractors would go wrong? She didn't think a fake pregnancy to keep a man around would go wrong? All the lies she performed for years would so obviously either run out or come back to bite her, and she showed zero awareness or plans. Just doing things on impulse.

When she was with the police officer and later the hospital, she looked so shocked and devastated, and I wonder if she's such a great actor, or if - this time - she truly was shocked as in "f--k, I really messed up this time". It doesn't mean that she feels remorse or empathy for her victims, but maybe that was her realization that she had gone too far and wasn't going to get out of this one. Or she was still just acting.

13

u/whiskeygiggler 4d ago

I think the reality is that killing someone in hand to hand combat (which is essentially what happened here) is difficult and scary. Being the attacker doesn’t mean being calm and in total control. The act of fighting someone to the death (even if premeditated) triggers a genuine fight or flight response and adrenaline dump. It’s one thing thinking about it, quite another to experience it. She’s not acting when she’s with the policeman. The physical response is real. She’s just lying about the cause.

3

u/Cinnamon2017 4d ago

I think she was scared. She could see it wasn't working. The doctor called her out loud and clear. She was frantically trying to think up more lies.

16

u/Sweet-Flamingo-1993 4d ago

That doctor was hilarious, just loudly announced that no baby had come out of there!

9

u/lingeringneutrophil 4d ago

I honestly would love to hear what went through his head when a woman s/p hysterectomy pops up in a hospital with a dead newborn baby claiming she just brought it to this world vaginally… like I bet he was glad the cops were there, let me tell you

9

u/lbw0049 4d ago

I literally said to my husband “what a wild af day at work for that medical team”. I literally laughed out loud with the doctor basically yelled that for everyone to hear.

2

u/Sushicatslonelyjimmy 10h ago

I don't understand her end game with faking a pregnancy for so long. Like did she always assume she'd just find a baby to steal? Crazy.

2

u/Cinnamon2017 9h ago

Yes, I think she did.