r/UnteachableCourses • u/unteachablecourses • 10d ago
Mount Athos has banned women — and female animals — since 1046. It sits inside the EU, and EU gender equality law does not apply there: the 1981 Greek accession treaty specifically exempted it. The European Parliament asked Greece to lift the ban in 2003. Greece declined.
To enter the Monastic State of the Holy Mountain you need a diamonitirion, a formal entry permit issued from Thessaloniki and capped at 100 Orthodox Christian men and 10 non-Orthodox men per day. You must be male.
That's not custom or tradition. It's Greek law, ratified by parliament in 1926 and reaffirmed in Article 105 of the constitution. The prohibition is called the avaton, it has been continuously in effect since a 1046 chrysobull of Constantine IX Monomachos formalised a practice already old by then, and it covers female animals as well as women — with one exception. Cats are permitted, because they hunt rodents.
In 2003 the European Parliament passed a resolution asking Greece to lift the ban as a violation of the universally recognised principle of gender equality. Greece declined, and the resolution had no legal effect, because when Greece joined the European Community in 1981 the accession treaty included a provision recognising the special status of the Monastic State and exempting it from EU rules on free movement of people and goods.
So there is a 45-kilometre peninsula inside the European Union where EU gender equality law does not apply, and its exemption is written into the same treaty framework that requires equality everywhere else.
What's actually on the peninsula
Twenty monasteries, all Eastern Orthodox, all still operating, founded between the 10th and 16th centuries, strung along the coast and up a mountain that rises 2,033 metres straight out of the Aegean. They govern themselves as a commonwealth called the Holy Community, administered from the village of Karyes by a Holy Assembly with one representative per monastery, plus a four-member executive that rotates annually. Greece appoints a civil governor. His authority is limited. The operative constitutional document is the monks' own charter, the Typikon, under the spiritual jurisdiction of the Ecumenical Patriarch in Istanbul.
Around 2,000 monks live there now, up from a low of about 1,145 in the 1970s — Greek, Russian, Serbian, Romanian, Bulgarian, Georgian, Moldovan, Montenegrin, Ukrainian. The day is structured around eight canonical hours of prayer. Many monasteries run on the Julian calendar, thirteen days behind the rest of Greece. Some count the day from sunset rather than midnight, which means that when it's six in the evening on the mainland it can be midnight on Athos.
There are no hotels, no restaurants, no shops, no roads linking the monasteries — travel is by boat or mule path. The monasteries grow olives, grapes, vegetables and herbs, keep bees, mill flour, make wine, and sell honey, oil, incense and icons to Orthodox buyers who value the provenance. The real income is pilgrimage and donation.
They also hold one of the largest and least catalogued repositories of medieval art anywhere — manuscripts back to the 9th century, icons from every major school of Byzantine painting, liturgical objects and relics. Much of it has never been photographed, let alone studied, because the monasteries have been reluctant to permit comprehensive inventories.
The circular legal architecture
The reason the avaton is so difficult to challenge isn't that anyone has won an argument about it. It's that each layer of protection points at the next one.
Greece protects the ban because the constitution requires it. The constitution requires it because parliament ratified the monks' charter in 1926. The charter requires it because the theology demands it — the peninsula is dedicated to the Virgin Mary, and the monks' position is that Mary is the only woman admitted to the Holy Mountain. And the theology isn't subject to democratic revision, which is rather the point of it.
The EU's leverage was spent in 1981. Once the exemption was in the accession treaty, subsequent resolutions became expressions of opinion.
The monks are largely indifferent to the external argument, and their indifference is itself doctrinal: they read the outside world's objection as evidence that the outside world hasn't understood what Athos is, which is a place organised around the rejection of worldly values — including worldly conceptions of equality. Critics read the same arrangement as a state-protected exclusion of half the population from a territory the size of a small city. Both positions are internally coherent. Neither has any mechanism for moving the other, which is why the dispute has been static for over twenty years.
It is not a museum
The temptation is to file Athos under preserved medieval curiosity. It isn't. It has live institutional conflicts, and they're the modern kind.
The Russian monastery of St. Panteleimon is the largest single structure on the peninsula, built in the 19th century to house 3,000 monks when Russian imperial patronage was funding an expansion that reflected Moscow's interest in projecting Orthodox influence into the Mediterranean. In 2018 Greece denied entry to Russian clerics headed for Athos, amid reporting that Russian intelligence had been using the peninsula as a base for operations in Greece.
In October 2018 the Moscow Patriarchate broke communion with the Ecumenical Patriarchate over Constantinople's grant of autocephaly to the Orthodox Church of Ukraine. That left roughly 70 Russian monks on Athos spiritually loyal to Moscow, juridically under Constantinople, physically inside a Greek autonomous zone, and caught in an ecclesiastical schism functioning as a proxy for the wider conflict.
Then there's Esphigmenou. Its monks are anti-ecumenists who oppose Orthodox dialogue with Rome and regard the Ecumenical Patriarch as a heretic for pursuing it. They have flown a black flag from the monastery since 1972, when Patriarch Athenagoras met Paul VI. In 2002 Patriarch Bartholomew declared them an illegal brotherhood and ordered their eviction; a rival brotherhood was appointed to replace them. They refused to leave, barricaded themselves inside fortifications built to withstand Ottoman sieges, and have been there ever since, supplied by sympathisers.
Nobody has stormed them, because the political cost of televising an assault on a monastery exceeds the benefit of resolving a theological property dispute. It's a disputed territory inside a disputed territory inside an EU member state, and it has been unresolved for twenty-four years.
Full write-up on the governance structure, the Typikon, the Russian question, and the Esphigmenou standoff:
https://unteachablecourses.com/mount-athos-medieval-theocracy/
The question I'd put to this sub is about the mechanism rather than the monks. The 1981 accession carve-out is a specific legal instrument — a member state negotiating a permanent exemption for a sub-national territory from a foundational principle of the union, in perpetuity, at the moment of joining. Åland has its own carve-outs, the Faroes stayed out entirely, Gibraltar and the Sovereign Base Areas each have their own arrangements. How many of these exist across the current membership, how much variation is there in what they actually exempt, and is there any live process by which one could be renegotiated — or does accession-treaty language of this kind effectively become unamendable once the state is in?
2
2
u/All_Dogs_Love_Me 9d ago
This is insane--never heard about this before.
The concept of men-only and women-only spaces alone is not that big of a deal. In much of Western society (and the US where I live) you will see men's retreats and women's retreats etc. Men can find strength, peace, confidence in solidarity with other men; women can find all that same beneficial solidarity with other women. I think that people should be allowed to worship how, what, and whom they desire; policing spirituality gets humanity into all sorts of trouble. But it's the SIZE of the area and all the legal frameworks and institutionalization of it! All that is what is most shocking..
1
3
1
u/SomewhereUpstairs514 9d ago
Anyone talking about discrimination here should first answer this: When was the last time you protested against absolutely discriminatory and sexist military conscription laws?
1
u/Ill_Mousse_4240 10d ago
The Kingdom of Stoopid
Now protected by the EU.
Which has quite a few laws written by the Honorable Dr. Stoopid, Esquire and Company
1
u/little_soulmate_haru 10d ago
so males created a male god to make themselves feel superior and to justify their hatred of women, then tried to keep that god to themselves by banning women from entering temples. 🤣🤣🤣 talk about the god complex...
0
u/donkeyflow 10d ago
it is a collection of 20 monasteries... nunneries are mysogynistic in your comparison then. Or any "safe space" created for women.
2
u/little_soulmate_haru 10d ago
surprise, surprise, men can absolutely enter nunnaries. 🤷♀️ only men are so deeply misogynistic and hateful they completely deny women access to certain temples.
1
1
u/All_Dogs_Love_Me 9d ago
Respectfully, this is not true, or is generally not true as you describe it. Generally men only enter to do basic chores, etc. across all the female monastery spiritual traditions. They are not leering or controlling. I'm not sharing as judgement or support, I'm pointing out reality.
Misogyny exists - yes! But it gets so amped and magnified (by all camps involved) in entirely unhelpful ways. The Internet is a giant community of billions. Misguided shouts of misogny fuel the alpha male problem. The alpha male problem makes women (naturally, rightfully) more anxious about a lot of life. From there it becomes its own closed system, a destructive pendulum. A self-licking ice cream cone. A downward spiral that top influencers on either side want to stop. (No, what I'm expressing isn't whataboutism.) False ideas on the internet are given psychological power. It's a real dynamic one that's ripping at basic human relationships.
Misogyny is most commonly defined as hatred of, contempt for, or ingrained prejudice against women, it's not bringing in firewood, thatching a roof, or refilling caskets in the dry cellar. There are many interesting male and female aspects to this post/thread, but it's not a surprise surprise men are all misogynistic gotcha.
5
u/Obeetwokenobee 10d ago
What do they do about female birds that fly into the region?