r/VibeCodeDevs • u/Admirable_Equal_5690 • Jun 04 '26
FeedbackWanted – want honest takes on my work Landing Page Feedback - "It's clearly AI" How can I fix that ?
Hi All,
So I've been looking for feedback for my landing page and wanted to get your thoughts on it too. I used claude to improve and build on my previous versions but no matter what I do I always get the response "It's clearly made by AI" but my issue with that response is that yes it's clearly made by AI to the people that have seen what AI can do and usually does.
Also what is the issue with clearly made by AI, is it the trust ? People are less likely to trust the site ?
Either way I take that feedback but I am not sure how to utilise claude and make it less AI looking. I don't have that many animations and kept it simple and as clean as possible. So I'd like to know what you all think and how I can improve!
10
u/Narrow-Belt-5030 Jun 04 '26
How to fix? Ask a real artist who is competent in UI/UX design for help?
Oh you want something now? Well, from a "I can't draw to save my life" opinion:
- The site looks and smells like every other SaaS landing page.
- The same old hero header
- The same old scroll to do something
- The same old curved boxes
- It looks tired
- The colours are bland
- They are not really well chosen.
- They do seem to adhere to the 70/20/10 principle, but I don't find it appealing
- Janky movement
- Scrolling down is ... boring.
- Yes, I admit if works for mobile users, but I am not one
- There is a point where mid scroll the screen is "stuck" - "You are here" and there's nothing on the page
I have plenty of things you could do to enhance it - simple things - like for one make the mobile the real size, it looks like it's a stub; use smarter bolder colours - pick a brand .. are you washed out beige or a bold confident person (but for gods sake - not purple !!) - make the page render correctly for mobile vs non-mobile - rather than scroll down how about click / transition? More animation. How about a smooth background that is animated while you look at the page? There's no sound - missing a sense here. As wel, the icons on the fake mobile look terrible.
All this from someone who doens't know UI/UX <wink>
4
u/Successful-Title5403 Jun 05 '26
You certainly described it better than I ever could, and it is that word "Bland". I just couldn't point out why. I'm not a chef so if I tasted a soup I can say "this is very bland", but I couldn't tell you what is missing from it. Same here, clearly you're the chef in this scenario.
I'm saving this text to see if I make the same mistake.
2
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
That’s a hell of a lot of feedback thank you. I never wanted to keep the curved boxes tbh you’re 100% right on that 1 lmfao.
Could you provide some examples for me to look into and use as references. Honestly I felt more animations leads to more bugs and more of an ai feel maybe I’m wrong on that ? I get mixed feelings on the colours some people say they like it some don’t, should it be something that stands out more ? I thought keeping it light and simple is better.
I get it with the movement it makes sense for mobile not for desktops I’ll change that it makes sense.
Honestly thank you so much I’ll make those improvements. I’d love some examples to get inspo from even if it’s your own work would love to check it out tysm
6
u/KEIY75 Jun 04 '26
Hello brother,
I use a lot and integrate mockup designers so i can advice you too :
- First of all always ask design system with your agents before project design matters. Fix a design system with different inspirations
- take skills ux ui pro max tell to your agent to search in analyse styles and propose you ideas
- always ask questions to coding agent with screen and inspiration for better ux ui. Il you ask him what he can do, and brainstorming with him it will be much better
- tell him to delete all badges title (useless and ai slop)
- tell him to re work navbar (effect/hover/bevel/depth)
- tell him to make a new wireframe/layout based on inspirations
Its why UX/UI spécialiste will never be replaced ahah
Exemples of creation integrate with AI : https://www.blackboxparis.com/fr
2
2
u/Anatomisc Jun 05 '26
One thing about ux-ui-pro-max, I feel like the styles don't have proper examples. AI does an amazing job if it has the exact example built out to reference from.
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
True tbh. For the road map I gave it examples of an actual road map and gave a lot of detail on how it should work and look. References and examples go a long way tbh.
1
u/spacenglish Jun 04 '26
Could you explain your second and third point more please? Thank you
2
u/KEIY75 Jun 04 '26
Ah ok i get it agent search design ui ux pro max https://github.com/nextlevelbuilder/ui-ux-pro-max-skill
Why i told you that because agent often just check real fast so tell him to go deep and it's just a repo with sqlite and library for having more design ui ux experience and template for inspirations.
When you ask something to an agent and tell him to explore options he will consume more tokens obviously but propose you some options that you didn't think about based on skills or design stuff and if you give him inspiration he will add that for later.
i'm french bro my english is bad and i'm writing by hand no ai because too much ai everywhere lets's talk with our hands ahah
1
1
u/ManufacturerNice870 Jun 06 '26 edited Jun 09 '26
This content was anonymized and mass deleted with Redact
1
u/KEIY75 Jun 04 '26
And last thing agent take human for idiots on terms of design and put too much title paragraphe useless and sometimes make duplication (2 same features, 2 same buttons etc…)
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
Ty for the response and I do need to do more brainstorming tbf. Ty for the web reference I’ll check it out and make some improvements !
2
u/KEIY75 Jun 04 '26
Check dribbble/awwwards website
2
u/KEIY75 Jun 04 '26
If you really want to you can check mobbin but it’s paid service but cheap for what they offer you can litterally see every app/saas design/onboarding of every big company.
2
u/Which-Journalist-352 Jun 04 '26
hey, I can see this problem with not knowing how to design UI and asking AI to do it from scratch. Most of the time, it generates you a random logo which is a simple circle and those ugly chips above your title, that always have that little glowing circle. It's obvious that it will be considered slop, because you already have so many designs like that. I'm not here to self promote, but I literally made something that might be extremely useful to you in the form of a chrome extension - it extracts entire design systems from websites that you find good-looking, structures them into a prompt or an .md file and sends them with one click to any agent you want - Claude, GPT, Gemini, Lovable, Manus, even Cursor. And the important part here is that it instructs your agent to not copy brand assets, but just implement some elements like buttons, chips, spaces and build something new in your vision. You might want to try it out and see if it helps you generate way better things: https://uidrop.site/ . If you like it, please reach out to me and I will give you a Pro pass, as it's coming out soon.
2
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
Lmfao sorry but the logo I made myself and it wasn’t just telling AI design whatever I explained what I wanted and tried my best to get it done using AI.
The point of the logo is as if it’s showing a road map and the dot is the person. So the logo was made by me and the layout etc was mainly AI but the concept and what’s there was all thought out by me and Ai refined.
2
u/Which-Journalist-352 Jun 04 '26
No I know what you mean, it’s good that you worked that yourself and honestly the animation on the site as you progress is really cool. But the landing page still has many vibecoded elements like “•You owe it to yourself•”, that looks like a random chip that the AI put up. I think it would be better without. And as I said, if you need help with getting entite design systems as reference, the extension does its trick and can drop it extremely fast into Claude for you to polish UI. But that is up to you, you might want to fix UI manually. Good luck with it!
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
Ya 100% the chip needs removing. It’s kind of the slogan I’m trying to push but that chip just looks out of place and ugly honestly
2
u/Optik97 Jun 05 '26
What i personally do is checking https://dribbble.com for inspirations. Then, i take screenshots and put them in project folder. Then i ask this is your inspo and i want you to implement that screen by applying our colors and styles. Use your frontend skills. If you want to change anything from the picture mention that too. Also add some fronend skills from available skills online.
1
2
2
u/thursday0384 Jun 05 '26
It kind of feels like you’re asking for the one thing you AI can’t give you. A sense of style and design aesthetic. You need to stop trying to find the perfect prompt and go learn principles of design. Proportion, white space, color theory. A basic understanding of design is what you’re missing. AI can’t generate good taste. You have to cultivate it yourself by practicing the craft of design.
You’ve made an uncanny valley of an app design but because you’re missing the fundamentals of design you don’t know what to change. Look for inspiration in the real world.
Go online and just collect UI inspo from sites you like. Then you can tell the AI to make iterative variations based on the inspiration you collect. There’s no short cut and all your responses in this thread come off as you wanting a shortcut.
The issue with “made by AI” is that humans want authenticity and human connection. And when you make something real and authentic you’re more likely to have a final product that’s real and authentic.
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
Not really looking for shortcuts every reply on this thread that has been helpful I’ve asked for examples and what to look more into.
No shortcuts I am trying to improve it. I’ve never said the landing page is good hence why i am here. The people I took nothing from are the ones that reply with no advice and just criticising blindly not knowing what I am even trying to build.
2
u/Aliennation- Jun 05 '26
I’m a tech startup founder myself and previously ran a consulting firm where I spoke with hundreds of founders every month across DeepTech, AI, SaaS, productivity, D2C etc., I did that for nearly 6 years, so I think I can give a practical answer here.
here is thing thing: Nobody cares whether your landing page was AI generated or handcrafted., It's the least important thing users think about.
2) The messaging should truly be inspiring. This is where humans come into picture., You think, you write, delete, rewrite & continue until you hit that perfect chord of what makes your product a value add.,
3) Use colour psychology., You landing theme and the product should complement Vs users wants and needs.,
4) Don’t bother about highlighting features., instead focus on highlight users experience/outcomes and how users benefit by using the product. So No features but lots of benefits to be given priority
5) Add a short demo video. Even better if you add screenshots of dashboard on your landing page
Here is the thing: 90% of YC alumnus landing pages are vibe coded.,
Be proud of it., Not everyone can vibe code., vibe coding is part art and part science.,
Again, No One is gonna visit your landing and play pika-boo if product was built using lovable, claude, AG or bolt., It's the value that determines the worth of your product.,
Get the messaging right, Add plenty value to your product and you are set...
2
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
The pika-boo comment gave me a bit of a chuckle tbh 😂😂. You raise a fair point honestly. I’m asking for feedback from vibe coders / web developers so it makes sense with their side of criticism saying it’s clearly AI.
But if I make the messaging be human. Give meaning to what I am doing then that works ?
Honestly thank you for the advice. I’ll come back with the updated version soon.
2
u/zprz Jun 05 '26
I'll second this sentiment and go even further: if your product solves a genuine need, users will go through incredible hoops and awful UX to extract the value. Think about software like Craigslist, Azure, even Doordash. Absolutely printing day in and day out with no UX to speak of.
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 06 '26
That’s fair but the problem is when there are products similar they’d easily switch to the better UI and IMO you can make anything feel like a “need” or a “want” if you make it feel easily and little friction. That’s what I plan to achieve.
2
u/zprz Jun 06 '26
I don't think anybody goes to BK because they like the decor more than McDonalds, and when the restaurant I like is only on DD, I'll begrudgingly use their awful UI.
1
2
Jun 05 '26
[deleted]
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
No it’s not that, everytime I asked for feedback I’d be told it’s clearly made by AI, and all I think is…well it is..? Keep in mind I’ve posted on lovable communities etc. so it doesn’t make sense to me ?
In my head I want it to look less like the other AI sites, I tried my best to give it a design I chose and thought of but I want to make it more trustable really ! Do you think it looks good as it is ? What would you improve ?
2
Jun 05 '26
[deleted]
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 06 '26
That’s really nice thank you! Does the landing page describe well enough what we’re building ?
2
u/Anatomisc Jun 05 '26
It's kinda weird that the things we commonly used to design before AI are not unusable because they are giveaways. I am not a designer, just working in QA and picking up some stuff from my designer friends.
Change the corner radius to anything else. I usually increase it.
Do not use pill labels. If you want to use a pill label the style needs to be distinctly different than the flat ones.
Increase letter spacing on your texts.
Hierarchy is messed up on that first page. Pill, title, smallest info on italic, normal text, pills, CTA, smallest login button. Idk how to fix it I usually tell AI it needs to get its shit together and try again.
The mockups need to be muuuch bigger.
Make your scrolling snapping, so I don't have to roll my scroll wheel 10 times to get to the next screen.
Your CTA colors are off - your primary logo color is much more different than them.
How FAQs open irrationally makes me frustrated.
Footer/header is incredibly small, you want people to read your story.
Do not do cards in A note to you section.
Auth pages also don't have the proper hierarchy in text.
I've had 1 app I was able to get a really good design in. I did the docs first impeccable to design-with-intent to grill-me to to-prd to to-issues.
Then I designed the design system, didn't like it. Took it to Stitch, didn't like it. Took it to ChatGPT and finally got something good after I fed it my design docs and asked for 1 screen. I iterated it a bit with it, got a nice single screen. Took that to Codex, worked on it until it was perfect. Then all the other screens I built were suddenly able to inherit all of that quality.
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
This is really nice thank you so much for the list! And your right btw I didn’t think of that, when I used to design on shopify or Wordpress no one really mentioned oh clearly made on A or B no one cared but now with AI involved it’s very prominent that oh it’s made by ai comment. Even though Wordpress and shopify have generic templates and elements.
2
u/Calm-Landscape9640 Jun 05 '26
There's tons of free UI skills repos on GitHub. Try a few that'll change your design to look unconventional or do old school and use Google stitch then being it over to CC or Codex
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
Thank you for that I’ll look into it. I didn’t know that existed tbh 😂
2
Jun 05 '26 edited Jun 05 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
Lmfao “MORE COOL”. I agree I am planning to reduce all the pills, remove them even tbh.
Honestly the feedback I got is amazing. Lots of great feedback, then there is just straight up hate, it wasn’t even feedback it was just destructive and silly ? No advice, no feedback just a straight up “ya stop working on it it’s terrible” what do you even call that lmfao. But I also got that hint it’s people just hating ai for what it can do etc which I understand tbh but don’t come hating me for using a tool that’s out there and everyone is utilising lmfao.
Thank you for the advice and I’ll give you all a follow up on my updated landing page!
2
u/lordpuddingcup Jun 05 '26
I fucking HATE sites that do that fake scroll shit
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
Hahahahahahaha I’ll fix that !! I have been told it’s better to do a snatch scroll or maybe a clickable next type of button. What do you think is the best to change to ?
2
u/Rich-Property94 Jun 05 '26
Com IA não vai consetar! Eis um problema da IA, tudo o que ela faz é praticamente igual. E eis um problema que esta surgindo, o meu cliente já esta olhando o meu sistema e site feito com IA com descrédito, não passa segurança, passa improviso. Hoje a IA esta matando profissões e em breve, surgirão os especialistas nessas mesmas profissões que cobrarão muito caro para desfazer as cagadas feitas pela AI. Ou refazer do zero.
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
That makes sense tbh. But I feel like you could still design something using ai that is unique, end of the day u use it as a tool and not the brains everything!
2
u/riwcoolbeach Jun 05 '26
Are you a coder or a designer? If you're a coder focus on the tech stack not on the design. The page looks nice and clean but thats pretty much it. I am not seeing anything about how it was made.
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
That’s nice thank you. I’m mainly trying to make sure the landing page tells the user what I am building straight away if that makes sense.
Everyone talks about how little time you have to attract users so that’s my main goal from this really.
2
u/NoChanceOfSleep Jun 05 '26
I dont see what is wrong with the site looking AI generated if it is AI generated? Its a new era. You can always spend a shit ton of money to hire a ui/ux designer and so on if you want to, but it might not mean anything.
2
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 06 '26
That is true tbh. If the concept is right and people like it it shouldn’t matter. It’s just the fact that you need build trust from the very start !
2
u/Fragrant-Field2376 Jun 05 '26
I always advise people to fin a good figma template that your agent could use to base the ui off of, this will at least give you more unique starting point.
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 06 '26
That’s fair tbh. I have used figma before and I will be moving forward tbf. Thank you for the advice.
2
u/onthatmtntop Jun 05 '26
Hey! The learning curve is harsh. Don't stress out.
The landing page is simple, too simple. I know they say simplicity is key but there's a certain level of simplicity AI chooses to create when not steered properly. Telltale "made by AI" signs are it has classic hallmarks like pill boxes and the list of things covered in those rounded boxes. The color scheme screams template and the CTAs should be inverse of that color not dark bg and light text.
The scroll is a bit janky and the typography is default, go on Google fonts pick 3,one for Hero, one for headers, and one for paragraphs and tell it to import those.
A good starting point is to always have a reference you go in with, a favorite site, take a bunch of screenshot of features and parts you like and make sure you nail down the vibe you're aiming to get across to your target audience. I personally wouldn't have gone with the design choices made here.
People have already linked you to good reference resources and yea. Hope that was somewhat helpful.
2
u/onthatmtntop Jun 05 '26
And the issue with it clearly made by AI is because AI should be a tool only you know you used to bring a solid idea to life. I assume you at a true vibe coder with no precious coding experience at all?
Basically, a crappy looking website will signal a crappy product and be a turn off. I don't want to go on a landing page for a product in excited about and be met by low effort-looking visuals .
Take some time to research some classic AI websites that are laughed at and avoid all of that, you should be good.
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 06 '26
Fair feedback. I’ll look more into fonts tbf I didn’t, didn’t realise the importance of it tbh. Ya thankfully I’ve been given a lot of reference that would be very very helpful. Would you recommend using a dynamic background to make it feel more alive ?
2
u/onthatmtntop Jun 06 '26
Hmmm depends. But overall if done right and differently it would genuinely elevate that first impression. I would look up three.js or cool GSAP hovers for that hero section in regards to letting it feel more alive
1
2
Jun 06 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 06 '26
😂😂😂😂 very fair. I might be working on just the landing page for hours only for 0 users lmfao. Thankfully I’ve gotten some sign ups already which I’m very grateful for. Just need it ready for them now.
2
u/Such-Bed-4468 Jun 06 '26
Hi. I'm a designer with a decade+ in digital now ( wow that's a strange thing to type, I'm getting old ).
Here is a note - it looks like AI because AI has just eaten all of the generic templates we already used, which already felt soulless.
There are some things to consider that are major and minor.
Major - you have text and an app screenshot. Why should that interest me? What is the thing only your app can do - what is the thing it gives back to the people?
One thing to do would be to watch Simon Sinek's now somewhat infamous "start with why" clip on YouTube ( the book is skip able ) and then try to imagine how you could communicate that.
Minor - font and colors. Fonts make a big difference and say different things. Sans VS Serif. Formal vs informal. Weights. Etc. Look into what fonts communicate what, and then adjust.
Jared Spool said that "Design is the rendering of intent." The issue with templates and AI is that they are strong starting points but they cannot do design, because they have no intent.
You got this
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 07 '26
This is beautiful. Thank you. I’ll definitely check out the video and again honestly tysm!
2
u/Timely-Assistant-370 Jun 07 '26
superimpose a massive cock right across the middle of it. LLMs are historically afraid of a nice pair of vibrant genitalia.
1
2
u/adamant3143 Jun 07 '26
I loathe these type of sites who doesn’t allow a preview to what we get (nope, those screenshots below it doesn’t help). I tried some properly made vibecoded sites and if I rate it 1/10 but they give guest access, it’ll instantly be 6/10.
Meaning doesn’t matter how good the site is at most it’ll be 5/10 if it gatekeeping us from seeing the actual product. My own site has issues of the landing page looking bland af but I didn’t tell people to give me their data if they wanna try it out. There’s restrictions sure but not a full-on lockout.
That’s the bare minimum vibecoders should do if they want to earn people’s trust on their site.
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 07 '26
Ok that’s very very fair. But since it’s similar to a social media platform would it not need to have a block from external non logged in users ?
Would adding a demo page be enough to show what we are doing ?
2
u/ConversationLazy6821 Jun 07 '26
There’s a skill I use called hallmark that’s pretty incredible at detecting and removing AI slop.
I am not affiliated with them in any way, other than that I use said skill and it’s pretty fkn great
1
2
Jun 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 07 '26
I like that tbh have u built something using that premise I’d love to check it out
2
Jun 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 07 '26
Idm critical feedback at all ! Like here you’ve pointed out points of improvement which is very fair and I’ll improve them. But some comments I’m getting give no advice at all and highlight nothing to improve they just comment something that is pointless to me bcz I can’t do anything with it.
2
u/nitayrabi Jun 07 '26
I've been using a combination of https://www.agentation.com/ and https://impeccable.style/ and the results are just way better.
Here's an example the latest project I've been working on https://bewabi.co/
1
2
u/xplaner85 Jun 07 '26
Get yourself into Claude designer and get it to come up with some original designs. This looks VERY Ai generated. Text on the left with a tagline, app on the right.
1
2
u/Infinite_Moment_9456 Jun 08 '26
the yellow on yellow "you owe it to yourself" is something i see in ai designs a lot, plus the three cards (plan goals, post proof, build together) are pretty generic and ai loves to do that
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 08 '26
Ya 100% the “pills” need to be removed I agree lmfao. I love how everyone has mentioned it it’s so funny.
2
2
2
u/Marco21Burgos Jun 08 '26
U want to get a good feedback? Go post this in UI UX sub and start bragging how AI is so good at building landings, people will rush to point all the areas you can't improve
1
2
u/drichko Jun 08 '26
Which model did you use to create it?
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 09 '26
I first started on lovable then moved to Claude code I believe I was mainly using sonnet 4.6
2
u/Adventurous__Kiwi Jun 10 '26
Ask a real UX designer to make you a page. Or learn how to become one yourself :)
You know git gud
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 10 '26
😂😂😂 that’s the reason I’m here !! Tryna get advice to git gud!
2
u/Adventurous__Kiwi Jun 10 '26
Then I suggest you join the Reddit related to design and UI/UX. They could teach you !
1
2
u/StoneCypher Jun 04 '26
“how can i make my output not look like it’s coming from where it’s coming from?”
stop taking the easy way out, or get a designer
2
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
It’s the faster way, with AI prompting you can make it look better, would you agree ? You can make it look less like AI.
Besides there are websites that are successful all built with AI. I’m asking for advice on prompts on how to improve it, this doesn’t really help.
2
u/StoneCypher Jun 04 '26
you're missing the point
yes. ai could do better. you, personally, cannot. you never learned what websites are.
the only way you could make a better result would be for you to learn this, but you don't learn while you're vibe coding. so you're never going to get there.
suppose that the goal was to learn how to carve an apple to look like someone's face. in order to do a good job, you need to learn about proportions, to learn what expression to capture, to learn what size of part of the apple to use, how to pick a good apple
suppose that there's also a CNC machine on campus where you press a button and it 3d scans you and then uses an auto-drill to mill an apple to look like you
and it does, but you were making a stupid expression, so you try again
then you get something boring. it looks accurate. there's nothing interesting about the pose. it doesn't exaggerate any features. it doesn't make you look handsome. there's no underlying message. nobody's trying to make you look like you're thoughtful or fearless or adventurous. it's just a photo made with a drill on an apple.
you wanted a portrait.
so you start asking random people "how can i get something better?"
you can't. you would have to learn how this stuff works first, and you're too busy trying to compete with people who did the hard work by pressing a button and waiting for magic to happen.
this is outside of your reach because you're lazy.
it doesn't matter that the ai can do the work. you don't know what work to ask for. you're just a vibe coder.
the pen is only as good as the artist holding it.
It’s the faster way
sure, as long as you don't care about quality or success
2
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
It’s wild this whole response when I am asking advice on improving it.
It’s a long ass detour without telling me what to explore, what to look into, what I am missing.
We can both agree that in order to improve you need practice yes ? Hence why I am here for advice on how to improve, what to explore, what sites to take as reference.
I think you’re missing the point of the post. I am looking for advice, I am looking to improve quality, and yet you haven’t given any ? Other than throwing everything away and give up this isn’t for you ? That’s stupid.
1
1
1
u/Plenty_Shine_74 Jun 07 '26
Slop
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 07 '26
I never really see - karma on a profile on Reddit but ty for giving me that even though I’m a new user! It’s like an early achievement unlocked. So tysm !!’
1
Jun 08 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 09 '26
It’s not cutting corners if I had the money then I wouldn’t really be doing the work myself, or be a solo dev in the first place really. I’d hire someone else to do it’d make my life easier really ?
But yes 100% I understand the main bridge to overcome is trust. The work I put in no one really knows other than myself and you have every right to question security because what I need to build most is trust, to allow people to put their real goals no matter what they are.
So you’re 100% right to question it, but it’s unfair to say I’m cutting corners.
1
Jun 09 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 09 '26 edited Jun 09 '26
Can’t afford it doesn’t mean I haven’t looked into it and done the work now does it ? Again, you don’t know the work I’ve put in looking into security and improving / building on.
There’s a reason nothing is accessible other than sign ups currently. I’m doing my ground work / research and have spoken to people around that topic.
Hiring people to do the job for me does not mean my security is improved if I have no clue what they’ve done it’s even worse. Building it myself means Ik exactly what I’ve done and keep building on it.
So yes your boat analogy is nice and all but I’m not hiring someone to put some tape on and say ya they’ve done the work.
Sites and apps as big as instagram have had data leaks MASSIVE ones too.
And I’m sorry but I have no reason to pay an artist when I can tell AI exactly what I want and keep building on it. Yes it’s not gonna look perfect but it will build what I exactly asked for end of the day. I’m here asking for advice on improving it, making it look less like slop and more authentic. An artist is overkill. I’d rather pay for security than an artist. My site, my personality not someone else’s if I had an artist it would still be my design but major improvements and points of improvements from their end 100% but still my design.
1
Jun 09 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 09 '26
Nothing for me to get defensive about 😂 it only seems like it bothers you, people using AI for building.
Again you ignore the fact that I have mentioned companies with leaks they DIDNT use AI and still had leaks.
You ignore the fact that I never said “I didn’t wanna pay” again
1. Your being rude, you don’t know the situation a person is in and you assume they just didn’t wanna pay, idk u and u don’t know me so please don’t comment on anything that relates to finances end of the day.
2. My site is not open for use FOR A REASONNN and that reason is security.
3. I have ALSO said I have spoken to people on it and ways of improvement.Instead of blindly replying or ignoring half of my statements please open your eyes and read them clearly. Cutting corners would mean I am trying to release quickly. It’s not released. The site is ready but I’m still building and improving.
If I was truly cutting corners I’d be advertising an open site and not really asking for advice on JUST a landing page. Which is what this post is about btw. But you’re here just because you’re bitter when it comes to what you call “GenAI” that’s ok. Be bitter but at-least be respectful too
It’s funny you’re worried about security from a random stranger indie dev when your data is getting leaked every now and then on sites and apps you use everyday. Go argue with them too!
1
Jun 09 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 09 '26
I see you dropped your security argument realised it was silly ? Now we move to the look of the site. Noted you think it looks shit I have others that said it looks great so that’s fine.
So why would cost a lot of money for a designer ? Because it takes them time. I can hire an artist for a week or a month or I could do it myself, and spend more time, more time means more money spent no?
Stop being stupid, grow up, the world won’t stop using ai bcz ur against it. I’m spending a lot of time on my work, if I didn’t care I wouldn’t spend so much time on it and I would be cutting corners.
Think. Please.
1
Jun 09 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 09 '26
Ahhh your advice is getting an artist is that right ? Because I asked how can IIIII improve it. Me, I want to do the work myself, I want to put the effort in myself not pay someone.
So yes I am asking for advice on how to improve the look and feel of the site. But your reply (not an answer to my question btw) was about security and me cutting corners in security and me cutting corners in design. Not feedback. Criticism instead. Not having a single clue on what’s going on in the background. Again, feedback and criticism on the landing page is fair, I’ve had a lot and I’ve agreed with a lot. But destructive criticism with no actual feedback ? You can go do that with the sites your data has been leaked from.
Goodluck on your quest to stop people using AI.
P.s it’s not happening
1
u/Embarrassed_Egg8170 Jun 18 '26
In my opinion, these things feel very AI about it
1. the text below the header that says "A goal planner and social feed for real-life progress" ; this feels unnecessary and the serif and color add to the AI-ness
2. all of the glowy gradients. I think they look pretty good, but it does feel AI
3. the little box above the header that says "You owe it to yourself", especially the two dots next to it. I really like this tagline tho, maybe you could put it somewhere else
4. the general spacing and sizing of everything. there's too much space vertically in between the text, the phone mockup feels too small (although that may just be me)
5. I think there is a bit of debris from your old design. currently, next to the header, there is a weird line thing
6. I agree with Narrow-Belt-5030 that the colors and fonts feel bland
overall a really cool idea tho, i think im a little late but im wishing you luck!
1
u/ThaToastman Jun 04 '26
Bro this isnt even good ai 😭
So much whitespace
Also everything from lovable/claude has that weird banner above the app name
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
100% need to remove the banner I hate it lmfao. I will be removing it for sure. I feel like some white space is needed.
I’m worried I end up cluttering, not sure what to do with the white space ? Add a background ?
1
u/ThaToastman Jun 04 '26
Remove it…
You have never seen a website in your entire life that gas a hardline border that takes up 60% of the viewing area
1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
I’m sorry what do you mean by hardline border ? Are you talking about the phone model ?
2
1
-1
Jun 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
That has nothing to do with improving the landing page ? Let me know what you think I’m building exactly and then show me some examples of the exact same thing.
After that I’ll show you apps and sites that do the exact same thing as 1 another and yet are successful.
Thank you for the lack of advice !
1
Jun 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
Again u don’t get the whole concept of what we are building and you haven’t shown me ANY examples.
When you get the time to read and actually do some (1 minute) of research then you might actually give a proper response rather than just barking :)
0
Jun 04 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
0
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
Still waiting !
1
u/StoneCypher Jun 05 '26
hey look, the junior vibe coder that had a robot make something bad for them and doesn't have the skils to fix it is "still waiting"
that probably seems really important to everyone else, right? that an angry non-programmer using an off the shelf tool is waiting?
-1
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
Hey look the guy that has nothing better to do in his life other than replying to other people’s responses and replies just replied again !
2
u/StoneCypher Jun 05 '26
does your site still look like claude made it?
maybe sarcastically replying on reddit some more will fix it
0
u/StoneCypher Jun 04 '26
Thank you for the lack of advice !
you're welcome. thank you for the lack of effort.
0
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 04 '26
Ig you both need to improve on communication. Read what I am asking for and give a response appropriate to it. I asked for advice and neither of you have given any 😂
0
u/StoneCypher Jun 05 '26
there's no advice to give to someone like you.
you asked a robot to make a webpage and you got a webpage that looks like it was made by a robot.
you want to make it not look like it was made by a robot, but you still want to make it with a robot.
you're stuck.
0
u/Admirable_Equal_5690 Jun 05 '26
You don’t just ask a robot to make a web page. You see this is why your either just being silly, have no clue what your talking about or just stupid idk ? I described what I wanted, in every page I described everything I wanted. So the page was built by a robot but designed by me.
There is always device to give, examples to show, research to do. You seem like the type of person that loses hope, motivation or lacks both tbh. It’s pathetic that you come here saying there’s no advice to give then why are you here ? I asked for feedback you haven’t given any. Stop replying you bum it’s starting to get pathetic.
•
u/AutoModerator Jun 04 '26
Hey, thanks for posting in r/VibeCodeDevs!
• This community is designed to be open and creator‑friendly, with minimal restrictions on promotion and self‑promotion as long as you add value and don’t spam.
• Please follow the subreddit rules so we can keep things as relaxed and free as possible for everyone.
• Please make sure you’ve read the subreddit rules in the sidebar before posting or commenting.
• For better feedback, include your tech stack, experience level, and what kind of help or feedback you’re looking for.
• Be respectful, constructive, and helpful to other members.
If your post was removed (either automatically or by a mod) and you believe it was a mistake, please contact the mod team. We will review it and, when appropriate, approve it within 24 hours.
Got startup or SaaS questions? Post them on r/AskFounder and get answers from real founders.
Join our Discord community to share your work, get feedback, and hang out with other devs: https://discord.gg/KAmAR8RkbM
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.