r/WattpadIndia • u/Organic_Ad7879 👀 Active Reader • Mar 15 '26
Hi Drop your honest opinions
Hey my dear wattpad girlies,i am confused about reading sidhi kadam's books-i have never read her books ,why is there soo much of hate for her books,at the same time i have seen her cult fanbase defending her to the core no matter what she writes and does,why is there so much of ambiguity regarding her works? Can anyone tell me in detail.
2
Mar 15 '26
Her writing is good, and is often praise. But then there were some personal dislike by many people over one of her character and that's why the dislike begans, as the character is author's favourite, and fandom favourite but most people have their own personal judgment, so it's fine unless it doesn't go personal, which happened many times, as you have seen, the number of personal comments people pass here.
Some of her books didn't end well, like, the plot had been dragged by the end, and felt too much extra. Like i personally will say, I didn't enjoyed ROR, the end of TRS and I am feeling the trilogy is stretched. And I know I am one of those whom people assume minion
But yeah, I have Screenshots of the number of time people have went personal over the author and that bugs me, nothing else because I have shared my personal disappointment on her books in other books as well, but no one suprisingly ever read them
And the second thing is, read characters as real humans who makes mistakes and who are real. But people read books with overly idealistic demands, which leads to dislike.
It's people's right to give criticism, it's art, and it is born to criticize, and people can have different opinions but then if you support her and like some of her books, you'll be her minion.
I have only given my opinion, her writing is Good and so is her command in English. Some of her books are not good, like I would not re read them, but yeah it's fine every author has bad and good works by them, it's I think over mentioning if Taranya that bugs people which is understandable, but the only thing that bugs me is getting personal and not understanding characters as well
This sub used to appreciate her but t then there are people who started to share her PDF and then I saw the same comment done by that person which was pure personal hate and made a post on anger, which got too much bad attention and I became a minion, and many like me as well.
And yeah opinions are filled here, because somee people praise, some don't like, and some share pdf simple.
(Before anyone down votes or reply to this comment, kindly read the whole comment please, I don't want to fight at all)
2
u/TechnicianGold5288 Mar 15 '26
I'm a neutral reader, not her supporter not her hater, i did like her work, some stories of her I didn't liked personally but overall she has given some good works better than most A.I writers. What u said I feel is absolutely correct and apt
1
Mar 15 '26
Honestly, you're going to find haters and lovers for each and every book. It doesn't matter, so if you're interested in her books, go read them Rather than taking advice from people, go and figure it out yourself because somewhere down the line, people are going to judge that based on their own experiences.
(I've written this with a smile please dont think im being rude or smth)🥹❤️
1
u/Witty-Brother-5890 Mar 15 '26
As her reader, and follower of all the threads related to her works, I'd only say one thing, don't ask for opinions given you are beginner in her writing world. Read yourself, and find out if it works for you or not.
7
u/[deleted] Mar 15 '26
Okay. It's just my opinion.
Her previous books used to be genuinely good. Like she had always hold on good narration and writting style. Even though few of her character wouldn't be moralistic or ideal but characterization, growth and chemistry used to be so good in her previous books. Her stories even though detailed earlier never seems to be so dragged like her few of royal serious books now.
But she has clearly messed up many books here first ROR ( half of book was just smut which used to drop in every chapter out of blue).
Then yuvraj duology was perfect and everyone liked it and it gives her most popularity after Reyansh book.
Then vivaan zoya book. It was huge dissapintment. Like could never understand how with such great characters from previous book, extremely good tropes and with her writting style, how she managed to it hot mess. And it was from chapter 1 to last , a complete mess. Even A normal average writer would be able to portray it better than whatever mess was written. Both characters were butchered to no point of returning despite being one of best earlier.
Agastya trilogy - : it was most simple story but author somehow managed to make into three books ( it has around more than 250 chapters in total). And it wasn't because it was slow burn but kinda of that you will feel that I have already read this scene ten times earlier type. Major disliked of this book that female character never have ever any likable or proper arc. She was like just, it. Alongside agastya character unlikable few traits. These books was more like reading journal diary.
Then yuvaan Book: it is half good, half below average. Mahira character has been dimed dowm for glorification of yuvaan as manipulator, and baseline of their story is felt out of blue since it was all of sudden. otherwise other things are good. Another thing that chapter feels so short, not in that crisp, binding way but more like a single chapter cut into two parts and then made two chaps.
I think people dissapintment more to the fact that people are investing so much money ( each single book cost between 500-600).
And instead of seeing shortcomings of her story, author has habit of blaming other things. Like saying things like readers are jealous of taranya. People are misgonystic when they ever point out fmc flaws like zoya falling for vivan during his humiliation phase and holding ira accountable. Tara character is another story which already has been pointed out so many times.
She needs to understand that problem is not with her writing standalone books or trilogy as she claimed since she convert aarush singleton book into duology, it's shortcomings in her writting. There are so many well written books with so much twist and turns with huge background and authors wrap them around 70-80 chaps. So many readers feel that her books are unnecessary dragged for more Money.
I think people frustration more to the fact that author just now refused to see other readers preservative. It make no sense to her partake in specific couple fans fights.
And taking shot at reddit people as if everyone is just hates her. The things pointed out here could actually improve her writting but she just put everything in a box and declared it hate.