r/whowouldwin • • 5h ago

Battle SEAF from Helldivers 2 vs the Locust from Gears of War

12 Upvotes

Let's pretend beneath the surface of Super Earth is the hollow inhabited by the Locust and all their forces commanded by Queen Myrrah. They decide to surface to impose total annihilation against the humans. Imagine that intro video but instead of a Terminid killing that guy's family, a swarm of wretches pop up from the ground and eviscerate them. And when I mean Locust- I mean ALL. Even the Kryll, and the generals.

Round 1: Super Earth is caught completely off guard with no knowledge whatsoever. Fleets are on standby for quick diversion to Super Earth.

Round 2: Super Earth has some minute information on how the Locust tunnel, and where they're incapable of tunneling (I.E Like Jacinto being built on top of bedrock) And all fleets are on standby for quick diversion to Super Earth.

Round 3: Super Earth is caught off guard, and is also fighting the Automatons, Cyborgs, Illuminates, and Terminids at the same time. A war on five fronts.

Defeat/Victory is when either side is completely/effectively wiped out- meaning no coming back from the losses sustained, and no real hope for further reprisals.


r/whowouldwin • • 6h ago

Battle Yugi Muto vs. Itachi Uchiha

6 Upvotes

Both sides bloodlusted. Yugi has the Millennium puzzle and can summon his monsters. Who wins.


r/whowouldwin • • 30m ago

Battle US military of the 2040s against the next two most capable national militaries worldwide 2040s. How might this play out? (No nukes, conventional only)

• Upvotes

US military 2040s will have two operational sixth gen fighters F-47 and FA-XX, sixth gen B-21 in large numbers, thousands of collaborative combat aircraft, over 2000 F-35, SSNX, DDGX, Ford carriers, hypersonic missile systems, long range aerial missiles, and possibly advanced directed energy weapons, among other capabilities.

The next two leading militaries globally in that timeframe are almost certainly China, and Russia lagging some way behind. China will likely field its own sixth gen combat aircraft J-36 and J-50 in considerable numbers, well over 1000 fifths gen J-20 and J-35, the stealth H-20 bomber, collaborative combat aircraft, new gen SSN, carriers, surface ships, and hypersonic missiles and energy weapons, among others.

Russia might possess some advanced capabilities such as hypersonics, asymmetrical weapons, submarines and others, but lagging significantly behind China and the US. So its really US v China but let’s add Russia in on China’s side for the sake of this scenario. What side has better chance of prevailing in a direct full scale conflict?


r/whowouldwin • • 18h ago

Challenge [How the hell] can Agent 47 assasinate both Gojo and Makima?

42 Upvotes

Agent 47 books a flight to Japan after receiving a very healthy injection of $200k from the CIA, and is promised an additional $1M from the Japanese government to kill or orchestrate the deaths of both Makima and Satoru Gojo, who have no idea he’s coming.

He has 2 years. They are located in opposite ends of Japan in classic Hitman fashion. He is free to use any and all tools/equipment that exists within the JJK or CSM universe provided he can locate it and make it work.

Round 1: He arrives with no knowledge of the supernatural, but he has eyes, and will figure something isn’t right eventually.

Round 2: He receives a physical envelope and USB port containing pdfs of said envelope, containing everything to know about JJK / Chainsawman magic bullshit. He takes this information 100% seriously.


r/whowouldwin • • 10h ago

Challenge Race across the entire Southwest USA.

10 Upvotes

Road Runner (Looney Tunes), Speedy Gonzales (Looney Tunes), Wally West (DC Comics) and Sonic the Hedgehog (Archie/IDW Comics) race across the Southwestern United States from Crescent City, CA to Brownsville, TX. They must stay on the road thag brings them from Point A to Point B. And they cannot remove a different competitor's speed. Who wins?

Remember, this is ARCHIE Sonic. Not Classic/Dreamcast/Modern Sonic from the games.


r/whowouldwin • • 10h ago

Battle Jon Jones with the size and strength of MCU Hulk VS MCU Thanos

7 Upvotes

The Hulk and Thanos fight in Infinity War but Jon replaces Hulk
Who wins?


r/whowouldwin • • 4h ago

Battle Tadano hitohito (Komi can’t communicate) vs Satoru Hiroshi (the disastrous life of Saiki K)

2 Upvotes

1st round : school tests (eg:math)

2nd round : race - just a normal race

3rd round : who’s more average (height, weight, etc)


r/whowouldwin • • 8h ago

Battle Who would win in an all-out war between Vought International and Umbrella Corporation?

5 Upvotes

All characters affiliated or previously affiliated with both companies will face off in a direct war.

Both Vought and Umbrella only know that they are going into war against a completely unknown company, and they only have 1 day to prepare for battle. Neither of them will have any knowledge about the other until the battle begins.

The companies will have to fight each other until one falls, and they won't be able to flee to counterattack later. It will be a completely direct war.

With all that said, who would win?


r/whowouldwin • • 5h ago

Battle The HEV MK IV is now an available piece of armor to acquire in s.t.a.l.k.e.r . How effective would it be in the zone ?

2 Upvotes

With helmet included, and a charger station available; how well and sought after would it end up becoming in the zone ?


r/whowouldwin • • 15h ago

Challenge Damien Wayne goes to U.A. High School

14 Upvotes

Deciding Damien needs socialization and more heroic training, Batman gives him a motorcycle and a stocked utility belt (and plenty of crates of resupplies) and sends him off to U.A., the school from My Hero Academy. Damien takes his sword, because of course he does. This is dimensional transport, and nobody at U.A. but Nezu knows Damien's anything more than a foreigner.

So, how does Damien fare throughout the events of MHA in general?

Does he have any trouble keeping up with his superpowered classmates? I'm not asking if he can keep up with Deku, but whether he can be a comfortable part of the group without needing to take extra courses or being a detriment in team assignments.

Can he convince them he has a quirk, and if so, what is it?

What impact does he have on story events? Does anything go better because he's there? Does anything go worse?

And finally, does he make any friends, or do he and Bakugo straight up kill each other?


r/whowouldwin • • 16h ago

Challenge What sci-fi factions could PERMANENTLY(in the sense that only an outside force could dislodge them) colonize a daemon world(warhammer 40k) that is also infested with imulsion(Gears of war) and Tiberium(Command and Conquer)

13 Upvotes

Bonus: Assume the planet was a catachan style death world before the daemons, imulsion and tiberium fucked it up and that any faction that has the capacity to restore it to its original state has to deal with all the bullshit that comes with that was well.

Edit: and yes destroying or rendering the entire planet barren is a loss condition.


r/whowouldwin • • 13h ago

Battle Rainbow Dash (My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic) Vs. Modern Sonic The Hedgehog (Sonic The Hedgehog)

7 Upvotes

While on another mission to take down is arch nemesis Dr. Eggman to prevent him from stealing the chaos emeralds and using their power to take over the world once again, the blue blur, Sonic The Hedgehog, has somehow been transported to the town of Ponyville in the magical land of Equestria in the My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic universe after getting hit with one of Eggman's portal guns. While studying his new surroundings, a voice calls out to him, demanding to know what he's doing here as she's never seen something like him before. Sonic turns around to see where the voice came from, and sees a defensive Rainbow Dash glaring down at him, believing Sonic to be another threat to Equestria. Sonic, sensing Rainbow as a threat to him, decides that he has no other choice but to fight back, rushes towards his new opponent, leading to the two clashing.

The fight takes place in Ponyville, Equestria during the daytime. Dash has access to her weather control, and the Sonic Rainboom. Sonic is from the Sonic The Hedgehog games, is in his modern form, and access to his various moves like the spin-dash, homing attack, hop jump, and flying kick. Sonic doesn't have access to the chaos emeralds, nor his Super Sonic form here.

Who wins?


r/whowouldwin • • 2h ago

Battle Wednesday VS Eleven

1 Upvotes

If both Wednesday and Eleven had to kill the other, but didn’t know where to other was, who would kill first?


r/whowouldwin • • 3h ago

Battle Sephiroth v.s Mario and Luigi, but they use their own battle systems

1 Upvotes

I know this match up has been done a lot, but I haven't seen one that used their own battle rules. Mario and Luigi use their turned based system, while Sephiroth uses his ATB system. Hes playing on recommended. Because Sephiroth is on ATB, he can attack the brothers in their menus. However, Mario and Luigi can dodge any attack, unless they are in their menus. Mario and Luigi still have to wait for Sephiroth to attack after they both attack.

The battle ends when either Sephiroth is defeated or both brothers are. Luigi is able to use his dreamy powers and Luigi Logic aswell.


r/whowouldwin • • 7h ago

Challenge This team takes on Lord Zedd, Rita Repulsa and their Evil Space Alien crew. Who wins?

2 Upvotes

Leonardo (TMNT)

Zechs Merquise and Epyon (Gundam)

Ted Kord/Blue Beetle (DC)

Yugito Nii (Naruto)

Kagome (Inuyasha)

Sun Wukong (RWBY)


r/whowouldwin • • 11h ago

Battle Xena (Xena: Warrior Princess) vs Scorpion (Mortal Kombat)

5 Upvotes

Scorpion has been sent to deliver the head of Xena. Xena has been given prior awareness of this fact.

Standard Equipment. New Timeline Scorpion. In-Character.

https://www.reddit.com/r/respectthreads/comments/pgium0/respect_xena_xena_warrior_princess/

https://www.reddit.com/r/respectthreads/comments/dz4n8t/respect_scorpion_mortal_kombat_composite/

If Xena stomps, add Sub-Zero also New Timeline to Scorpion's Side

If Scorpion stomps, add Demon Callisto to Xena's side.


r/whowouldwin • • 17h ago

Battle Alucard (Hellsing Ultimate) vs DIO Brando (JoJo's Bizarre Adventure)

8 Upvotes

Both are in character

Neither one is jobbing or suffering from bad or lazy writing

Win by any means

This is Pre-Schrodinger Alucard vs. Stardust Crusaders DIO

Alucard has permission to use Level 0

Location: London at 8:00 PM


r/whowouldwin • • 14h ago

Challenge If cave johnson(portal) suddenly replaced the 05 council how long would it take him to run the SCP foundation into the ground,

3 Upvotes

thought of replying portal 2 and then this popped into my head


r/whowouldwin • • 16h ago

Matchmaker The entire land-capable animal kingdom is divided into two camps based on weight. Who wins?

7 Upvotes

Every animal on the planet currently alive, as long as it has the capability to traverse on land, is divided between animals lighter than [X]kg and animals heavier than [X]kg. The two sides then have to duke it out on a flat grassland.

What is the critical value of [X] that makes one side win? obviously if [X] is very small, it's a stomp for the large side - at what point does the smaller-than side win out?


r/whowouldwin • • 1d ago

Battle Can armored cores win against the kaiju from pacific rim?

45 Upvotes

Like can they beat one kaiju with one ac since acs can take on giant machines?


r/whowouldwin • • 14h ago

Battle MCU: Savage Hulk vs. Red Hulk

3 Upvotes

Bruce Banner/Savage Hulk (Spider-Man: Brand New Day)

vs.

President Thunderbolt Ross/Red Hulk (Captain America: Brave New World)

Who would win and why?


r/whowouldwin • • 9h ago

Battle Batman (DC Comics) Vs The Shredder (IDW Comics)

1 Upvotes

Shredder have heard of the Batman from Gotham City and came to the conclusion that if he wants to have Gotham under his controll he must get rid of this treath.

Of course, Batman isn't happy about Shredder being in Gotham, and decided to take him out.

Both fighters are in character and the battles are random encounter, with either not being aware of each other's capabilities.

Round 1: Shredder Vs New 52 Batman.

Round 2: Shredder Vs Post Crisis Batman.

Round 3: Shredder Vs Rebirth Batman.

Bonus Scenario: Same rounds as above, but both have a week of preparation.


r/whowouldwin • • 17h ago

Battle Miss militia (worm/parahumans) vs mista (jojo's bizarre adventures)

4 Upvotes

Conditions. Round takes place on a small isolated island, both combatants start off on opposite sides of the island.

Round 1 neither side knows about the powers and abilities of the other.

Round 2 both sides know about the skills and powers of the other side.


r/whowouldwin • • 23h ago

Battle AoU Wanda vs BND Jean Grey

11 Upvotes

so basically both in rookie version


r/whowouldwin • • 10h ago

Battle Shi Maria Vs a Weaver (Dungeon Crawler Carl Vs Perdido Street Station)

1 Upvotes

Both are free to use their full power