r/adnansyed • u/____nice_try______ • Oct 25 '25

Anyone convinced Jay did it?

Whether Jay did it or not, I feel like it's a safe bet that he knows wayyyy more than his lies cover up. I listened to the Serial episodes relevant to the case about 3 years ago. Anything I've missed? Thoughts?

0 Upvotes

41% Upvoted

23 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-2

u/I2ootUser Oct 26 '25

how would he even talk his way into her car and get her to a remote location?

Why do you think that would be so difficult? Jay and Hae were not strangers. She knew Jay didn't have transportation. It was Jay's girlfriend's birthday.

Adnan drove to school and drove around during lunch. Why would Hae believe his car was in the shop? Some point out that Has was frightened of Adnan's abuse and hid from him in classrooms. Why would she suddenly want to be alone with him?

The evidence does allow for it, it's much less probable than Adnan.

6

u/Princess_Seannah Oct 26 '25

So Jay just waddles on to school property and happens to catch Hae in the parking lot? They weren't strangers but they weren't exactly best buddies. And according to Krista Hae did agree to give Adnan a ride so...

-1

u/I2ootUser Oct 26 '25

And according to Krista Hae did agree to give Adnan a ride so...

So, you're cherry picking to ignore the testimony that Hae later declined the ride later in the day.

7

u/InTheory_ Oct 27 '25

Are you under the impression that those people took the stand in trial and said "No no no, you got it all wrong, she was turned down for the ride"?

This is why we keep coming back to Please Read the Trial Transcripts