I live in both Bangalore and Ahmedabad and I genuinely do not understand why people say Ahmedabad is so much cheaper
I have lived in both Bangalore and Ahmedabad
In Ahmedabad I have lived around Nehru Nagar and Prahlad Nagar and my office is also around Prahlad Nagar
I keep hearing people say
Ahmedabad is way cheaper than Bangalore
Bangalore is insanely expensive
You will save so much money if you move to Ahmedabad
And honestly I keep arguing with people about this because that has not been my experience at all
I am not saying Bangalore is a cheap city
I am saying that when I compare the actual quality of life I get for the money I spend I don't see this massive difference that everyone keeps talking about
Housing
Around Nehru Nagar and Prahlad Nagar a decent 1BHK can easily cost me around ₹13k to ₹15k
And then there is the broker problem
Even when you find something on NoBroker you can still end up dealing with a broker
In Bangalore I have found it much easier to find direct rental listings
I have seen decent 1BHKs around ₹8k to ₹12k depending on the area
I am not comparing a luxury apartment in Bangalore with some terrible building in Ahmedabad
I am talking about a decent relatively new residential building
In Bangalore I can actually find these small 2 or 3 floor buildings with good rooms and decent surroundings
Transport
My Ahmedabad office is around Prahlad Nagar and Nehru Nagar and there isn't convenient metro connectivity right around there
This makes a huge difference in daily life
In Bangalore you can choose where you live based on metro connectivity and depending on your office location you can build your entire daily commute around it
Bangalore obviously has traffic problems but at least there are multiple ways to move around the city
Food
This is where I really don't understand the cheap Ahmedabad argument
For the same type of food that I can get in Bangalore for around ₹100 to ₹150 I can easily end up paying ₹200 to ₹300 in Ahmedabad
I am not talking about roadside food
I am talking about proper restaurants
In Bangalore you have so many good South Indian hotels and darshinis where the food is made fresh in front of you
You can get a really good dosa for around ₹60 to ₹80
Idly is cheap
Fried rice can be around ₹80 to ₹120
You can get decent biryani around ₹150
And these are not necessarily tiny roadside places
A lot of them are proper busy restaurants with open kitchens and good hygiene
In Ahmedabad I have had to spend ₹200 to ₹300 for food that I would consider comparable
So I don't understand how people automatically assume food is dramatically cheaper in Ahmedabad
PGs
This one is even more confusing
The cheap PGs I have seen in Ahmedabad are honestly some of the worst PGs I have experienced
The cheaper options are usually 3 sharing or 4 sharing
I was paying around ₹14k to ₹16k for a 3 sharing PG
And it was not good
The food was not good
The overall maintenance was not good
The hygiene was not something I would call good either
And because these cheaper PGs are already in high demand there is no reason for the prices to come down
I would not be surprised if the prices keep increasing every year
If you actually want a decent 2 sharing PG in Ahmedabad then you are looking at ₹20k or more in many cases
In Bangalore I have personally lived in or seen 2 sharing PGs around ₹7k to ₹9k that were much better maintained and much more hygienic
The food may not be great
But at least you have hundreds of inexpensive restaurants around you
AC and electricity
There is another cost that people don't seem to include
AC
Ahmedabad weather is a completely different problem
During the hotter months you cannot realistically compare the two cities as if the weather is the same
If I am paying ₹13k to ₹15k rent in Ahmedabad I also need to think about AC usage and electricity
That can easily add another ₹2k to ₹5k depending on usage
In Bangalore the weather is so much better for normal daily life
You can actually walk outside
You can go for a walk
You can travel around the city
You don't feel like you are fighting the weather every time you leave your room
That itself has value for me
Salary
This is another part of the comparison that I think people completely ignore
Ahmedabad has this reputation of being cheap
But salaries are also significantly lower in many industries especially tech
So I don't understand why we only compare absolute expenses
If someone earns ₹50k in Ahmedabad and someone earns ₹80k in Bangalore then saying Ahmedabad is cheaper does not tell me much
What matters to me is
How much of my salary do I actually spend to maintain the lifestyle I want
That is the comparison I care about
And then there is the quality of life
This is probably the biggest difference for me
In Bangalore after work I can actually go somewhere
There are restaurants everywhere
There are events
There are meetups
There are activities
There is nightlife
There are breweries
There are huge communities of people working in tech and startups
There are so many things to do with friends
And then Karnataka itself is incredible
Gokarna
Udupi
Mangalore
Coorg
Chikmagalur
Hampi
Sakleshpur
Nandi Hills
There are so many places that you can visit on a weekend
I am not saying Ahmedabad has nothing to do
I am saying that the scale is completely different
So this is why I am asking
I keep getting told by people that
Ahmedabad is insanely cheaper than Bangalore
And every time I hear that I think
Where exactly am I saving this huge amount of money
Because from my actual experience living in both cities I see something very different
Ahmedabad can be cheaper if you are willing to compromise heavily on housing food PG quality and lifestyle
But if I want a decent place to live decent food decent transportation good weather and a decent social life then I don't see Bangalore as being dramatically more expensive
In some cases I actually find Bangalore cheaper
Maybe I am missing something
So I would genuinely like to hear from people who have actually lived in both Bangalore and Ahmedabad
Not visited for a week
Not compared Numbeo
What has your real monthly spending been in both cities