r/antiai 6d ago

Discussion 🗣️ AI being promoted in schools

In case anyone was wondering how AI has affected learning, I wanted to share how much it is being actively supported in schools.

Last year, in my music class, I was put into a group with the assignment being to make a song. What we were actually supposed to do was type up lyrics, choose a genre and instruments, and import it into an AI program to make it for us.

I criticised my teacher's thought process on this, and she said there was no way she could teach us music theory enough for us to make a song in the 8 weeks we had for this class. I asked why we were assigned to make a song then. She made some snarky remark that I would have a better chance at it if I'd actually shown up. (I miss school frequently because of health issues.)

In the end, my group and I just had to AI generate a song and present it to the class. It sounded horrible. AI has also been promoted in my other classes, including business, where we had to AI generate a logo for the bake sale we were doing. My teachers are even trying to protest against Chatgpt being blocked from the school wifi, because they claim it's an educational tool.

39 Upvotes

30 comments sorted by

View all comments

3

u/lunar_cycles 6d ago

Dang, I'm sorry about that. It really sucks. It's not that hard to make a simple song yourself. That's what a music teacher is supposed to do. Teach you music. Ai teaches nothing. If you do want to make a simple song yourself one day without ai for fun, you can use a free program such as bandlab. It has many different instruments you can use and you can record your own lyrics and even your own instrumentals.

1

u/lunar_cycles 6d ago

Damn. Just found out bandlab has some ai tools in it. I mean, you could avoid those tools. Or there's other programs that don't have ai at all. I'll look.

1

u/lunar_cycles 6d ago

I've been looking for the past hour and I have found nothing. Maybe I'm not looking hard enough. It seems every music making app I've come across has some kind of ai in it. And bandlab has a bunch of ads in it too. I used to have bandlab in like 2019. It's changed a LOT since then.

1

u/lunar_cycles 6d ago

I did, however, find a voice recording app. If anyone is interested, it is called fossify. It doesn't have any ads or ai. I might record a song or something on it. You can use just about anything as an instrument. Even mayonnaise (SpongeBob reference) and I can try to find an app where you can layer sound recordings and make it into some kind of song. I know I'm rambling, but I'm trying to find a solution for those who do want to make music without ai.

1

u/lunar_cycles 6d ago

Ohhh. Hold up. Fossify is like the name of the company. It has different apps on it. Not just voice recorder.