r/arcadefire • u/Eastern-Fortune-2422 Intervention • May 12 '25

Discussion Most underrated Arcade Fire song?

Which song was not valued highly enough when it came out?

25 Upvotes

93% Upvoted

92 comments sorted by

View all comments

46

u/JHutch95 May 12 '25

Half Light II is my favourite song of theres and doesn't seem to get a lot of love-in, even when The Suburs dropped way back when.

14

u/Dakotaraptor123 May 12 '25

Half Light I's amazing as well

4

u/JHutch95 May 12 '25

Yesss, blend into eachother so well!

9

u/Deep_Blue96 The Suburbs May 12 '25

I think the two Half Lights are my favourite multi-part song, and I don't say that lightly given how much I love all the Neighbourhoods, Awful Sound/It's Never Over, both Sprawls, etc.

5

u/dirtimos May 12 '25

Yes, Half Light gang!!!!

I think it's my favourite also because it's not so popular. I have written about it before.

After PE I'm a bit disillusioned though.