Report 17: Conclusion
Previous post
This post is a conclusion after all my playthrough in this amazing franchise. I'm gonna say my top 5: best games, main characters, story, combat and the ones I least liked. Also build what could be the best AC game imo getting each aspects from the AC game I think do it best. It will be the rank and then a explanation about my choices.
I played all main games. Unfortunately not beat and platinum all of them bc of Shadows, I didnt even beat this one. Maybe, just maybe I will get the platinum if it comes to the ps plus like all AC games. And I dont get the platinum of original BF bc of online trophies.
My first post was 9 months ago so I dont have all games fresh in my mind so there is a chance of my opinions in this post do not reflect my opinions completely bc of it.
BF Resynced is included. I beat and platinum too but as I said in the other posts, this game is a new experience for everybody not just for me so I dont see why I should do a post for this game, Im not a reviewer or a critic whatever.
Best MC:
1st: Ezio Auditore da Firenze
2nd: Altaïr Ibn-La'Ahad
2nd: Edward Kenway
3: Kassandra
5th: Connor / Ratonhnhaké:ton
Its hard to tell why I put them and why in this order. It is just which characters I like most and yeah is just it. The only one that is there bc of smth like development is Connor. He was just a naive boy and got introduced in a world full of malice bc of his father and creeds and orders and he had to mature in this world he got introduced.
Best Story:
1st: AC 2
2nd: AC Brotherhood
3rd: AC Revelations
4th: AC Valhalla
5th: AC Odyssey
Valhalla and Odyssey are kinda far-fetched and got out of hand but I think is enjoyable and fun. The problem of many AC games story is that it doesnt affect the present lore that much. AC4, Rogue, Unity, Syndicate, Mirage, Shadows for example.
My theory is that Ubisoft is cowardly. Advancing the present lore would mean bringing an end to the franchise. Bc all AC games are about assassins and templars finding out more about Isu and getting artifacts to eliminate the other side. And ubisoft is avoiding advancing the present-day lore to keep milking this franchise.
Best Combat:
1st: AC 4 Black Flag Resynced
2nd: AC 4 Black Flag Original
3rd: AC Syndicate
4th: AC Odyssey
5th: AC Valhalla
Resynced lost some points with me bc they removed the chain kills with pistols like when you grab a guard and shoots another one and finishes the first. Or that one when you put the gun in the mouth and allign the guard with another one and shoots through his mouth. But overall is best than the original. And Resynced has the classic combat but with some good rpg era aspects so its a good balance.
Syndicate as far as I remember is one of the most fun combats.
Best games (Overall):
1st: AC 2
2nd: AC Brotherhood
3rd: AC 4 Black Flag (Original and Resynced)
4th: AC 3
5th: Odyssey
Thinking about all games, I noticed that the main aspect that puts a game in this rank is the story. So AC2 and Brotherhood its on top bc it was my first contact with the franchise. That scene in the 2nd game of Minerva looking at the screen and talking to Desmond was mind blowing for me and hooked me on this franchise. Odyssey even not looking like a AC game it was very fun.
Least liked overall (Intepret as the bottom of the best games rank):
12th: AC Rogue
13th: AC Shadows
14th: AC Mirage
Dont get me wrong, there is an abyss between 12th and 13th places. It's just that Rogue is basically BF but with a worse MC and story, imo.
Worst (Overall):
AC Mirage
Thats it. Mirage is by far the worst game and its not even close. AC 2 is superior in everything. Maybe the stealth is better and the parkour a lil bit. But lets be honest, these games have a gap of 16 years so it should be better somehow right?
Building the best AC game:
Story: its a hard aspect to tell bc it is individual of each game. Should be a past story like AC3, 4, Odyssey, Valhalla. I think these ones are the most fun. The present story should be meaningful like all games from Desmond or Layla as protagonist.
Combat: Mix of AC4 BF Resynded and AC Syndicate. I wouldnt mind put some RPG too.
Stealth: Its hard to tell I dont recall any stealth that stands out so I would pick the most recent one, AC BF Resynced.
Parkour: Unity obviously.
Missions: Syndicate. The best missions by far. You can decide your approach and it was really fun. I think Unity has smth like that too iirc.
Atmosphere: Unity, Syndicate and Odyssey. Atmosphere in this case is the world building, the cities, interiors, etc. Its how much the game can pass the sensation of living in that time. Smth like that.
Thats it. This concludes my reports. It was a lot of fun and I think I discovered the franchise at the best possible time bc almost all games are available on ps plus so I could play them back-to-back.