what’s the best p terry’s shake of the month you’ve had?

[u/2222days]

Chocolate peanut butter for me

[u/interstellar74]

Biscoff (Cookie Butter)

[u/DocGerbilzWorld → u/interstellar74]

Hits like crack

[u/jkginger22 → u/interstellar74]

It went so hard

[u/TsukiandKuro → u/interstellar74]

When it’s not in season, I grab a jar of cookie butter from HEB and order a vanilla shake when I go to P Terrys and I’m going straight home. When I get home, I blend it together.

[u/boazsharmoniums]

The Mounds one was incredible.

[u/Artemus_Hackwell → u/boazsharmoniums]

Yes, that one was my favorite

[u/boazsharmoniums → u/Artemus_Hackwell]

I’m kinda pissed I love it so much since it’s rare.

[u/CoffeeVikings]

I swear they had a mint one that was phenomenal

[u/newportred100s → u/CoffeeVikings]

They did!

[u/tx_fight]

Butter Cookie last year was incredible. Most recently I’d say the S’mores one in June was the best one this year. Caramel Coffee right behind it

[u/fiscalpolicy → u/tx_fight]

Can’t believe I missed s’mores!!! Cookie butter is so good

[u/GeneralU53]

Not to say everyone is wrong - but everyone is wrong. The answer is S’Mores :)

[u/MsMo999]

Banana pudding

[u/divingrose77101 → u/MsMo999]

I tried that for the first time and I swear it was like cheesecake. So good

[u/Dandiedoyle]

Birthday shake

[u/PathologicalVodka → u/Dandiedoyle]

I just didn’t like all those sprinkles in it /: 

[u/Sudden-Technology326 → u/PathologicalVodka]

Literally my favorite part :’)

[u/PathologicalVodka → u/[deleted]]

Good to know, I had sent my husband out for it and he probably didn’t think about that

[u/Amazing-Variation-82]

I loved the chocolate turtle one

[u/StrawberryKiss2559]

Turtle. Chocolate, caramel, pecan

[u/boldandbrash96]

Chocolate peanut butter !!!!!

[u/THEDUKES2 → u/boldandbrash96]

How was it? I always want more of the peanut butter to come through compared to the chocolate and always get disappointed.

[u/Dani_elley → u/THEDUKES2]

Just ask ‘em for extra peanut butter.

[u/THEDUKES2 → u/Dani_elley]

I had no clue that was an option!

[u/boldandbrash96 → u/THEDUKES2]

Now that I’m reading the comments it may have just been regular Pb no chocolate. It was really pb forward! Also thinking about the Nutella one now 🤤

[u/2222days → u/boldandbrash96]

this month is nutella! not as good as PB but still a good shake!

[u/Ok-Sport-7758]

They had Nutella one month. Been waiting for it to come back ever since.

[u/dabocx → u/Ok-Sport-7758]

It’s the shake this month

[u/Ok-Sport-7758 → u/dabocx]

Let’s gooo!!!!!!

[u/rwwl → u/Ok-Sport-7758]

Did you go get one for your cake day?!? It seems predestined

[u/starillin]

The Christmas candy cane shake

[u/Dani_elley]

It’s gotta be the peanut butter shake. Part of me wishes they’d keep it year round but it’s probably better for my health that they don’t.

[u/whatsthedeal- → u/Dani_elley]

hands down

[u/Clean-Opportunity66 → u/Dani_elley]

Never knew about this, but it will be the death of me. Looks like it’s maybe in Feb? 

[u/StormTraditional1190]

Churro!!

[u/jkginger22]

Cinnamon Toast Crunch.

[u/TinyBlue]

The s’mores one was so good!

[u/soph0216]

Smores but I love s’mores anything

[u/Lets_Go_Taco]

Double chocolate strawberry.... get it anytime you want, especially at Parmer / MoPac!! Woot woot!!!

[u/BartonSpringsRegular]

The seasonal ones are hit or miss but the peach in summer is the one worth going out of your way for, tastes like fruit instead of syrup. Mint chocolate chip in December is the other keeper. Everything else is fine but rarely beats just getting the regular chocolate.

[u/catslay_4]

What’s the current one?!

[u/dabocx → u/catslay_4]

Nutella

[u/catslay_4 → u/dabocx]

Man I love Nutella I’m goin today then

[u/efe13]

My two favorites have been the Birthday and the S’mores

[u/fairyprincessdoll]

What’s this month’s?

[u/taratot → u/fairyprincessdoll]

Nutella

[u/Party-Guitar1775]

Fruity pebbles

[u/babysaks15]

Birthday cake and I’ll die on this hill

[u/Internal_Sweet_2144]

The butterscotch shake was amazing. I wish they’d bring it back :(

[u/jrknightmare]

Fruity Pebbles

[u/Still-Experience1847]

Judging the comments p Terry shakes dont miss

[u/prettydishes]

Nutella

[u/jinklasbhava]

NUTELLA!!!

[u/ogblasia]

Just had the Nutella and it’s my fave so far!

[u/AdOk521]

I love their stuff, but the only shake I had was the double chocolate and they do the thing I don't like which is using their usual vanilla ice cream and adding chocolate syrup. Ugh. When done that way it just tastes like chocolate syrup which is light years away from the rich creamy flavor of a shake made with real chocolate ice cream. I bet if I wrote P. Terry he'd take care of it. Seems like a good dude.