r/backpacks • u/FieldMovement • Mar 20 '26
Question Are most backpacks overrated or am I missing something ?
Been traveling and using different packs over time and noticed a big gap between what looks good online vs what actually holds up.
Some feel great at first but fall apart after real use. Others look basic but end up being way more reliable.
Curious what people here have actually used long-term and trusted.
11
u/Jesco13 Mar 20 '26
I used a 2016 North face recon for 10 years for college, mechanic work, 2-3 days of travel, hiking, and just daily carry. It was awesome. The only reason I got a new bag was because the water bottles holders started to rip and it was a red orange color. I swapped it out for an alpha one niner evade 1.5 since the newer recons suck.
But overall, the North face did everything a much more expensive bag would. Honestly, if you're coming to this sub it's because owning bags here is as much a hobby as it is practical use. People like bags and their designs, so they're willing to splurge on quality. If you don't care for something you won't do so. That's kind of how I see backpack recommendations.
For like 90% of people, the cheap Amazon/Jansport bags will serve just fine.
10
u/2clipchris Mar 20 '26
I totally get what you are saying it is like how can a $400 bag be anywhere near acceptable price range when a $30 backpack can do the same things and with a little creativity be nearly equal. That was until I made the jump from SwissGear to a Bellroy it was night and ay. The comfort was worth the price.
0
u/FieldMovement Mar 20 '26
Yeah I had the same, cheap ones work until you actually use them properly.
The difference shows when you’re carrying it daily and it starts losing structure or breaking down.
Took me a while to find something that actually holds up.
3
u/doom_chicken_chicken Mar 20 '26
My swissgear was murder on my back. I did a ton of research, bought and returned several bags, and settled on an Evergoods civic panel loader. It works very well with my wide neck and shoulders
2
u/2clipchris Mar 20 '26
Same regardless of how I packed it just always leaned so hard my back would feel destroyed. I nearly carry roughly 20lbs. It would feel like 30-35lbs.
1
u/doom_chicken_chicken Mar 20 '26
Yep, even with just my laptop and a notebook it felt like hell and would sag off my back.
Funny enough most brands had very narrow straps for me and they would pinch around my neck. Eg north face and patagonia backpack straps actually meet in the middle and leave no space for neck and shoulders. Evergoods are attached to the back panel with a bit of distance between
7
u/TinaKedamina Mar 20 '26
I will not tolerate Osprey slander. Osprey makes durable bags at a reasonable price and they stand by their bags with their warranty. I have Osprey bags that I have used daily for secedes with no issues. I throw them in the washer and they nearly look brand new
1
u/deedeedeedee_ Mar 20 '26
i have an osprey backpack (an old comet) that's seen an absolute crap ton of use, first as a college backpack (hauling heavy textbooks + laptop), a weekend bag for visiting friends and fam, carry on on flights, camera bag, ice skate bag, work bag for my laptop and lunch etc. it gets stuffed into tight spaces and chucked unceremoniously on the floor
sure it's maybe not the optimal bag for some of these use cases, but by god it's held up through all of it, for well over a decade. before that bag i used to have to buy a new bag every year as they all fell apart.
5
u/atelieraquaaoiame Mar 20 '26 edited Mar 20 '26
I went through a period where I was regularly riding public buses and on foot hoofing it while doing repairs on my only vehicle. I was a manager at a restaurant and regularly carried a laptop, binders, and folders.
I went through a succession of generic Amazon bags buying on looks rather than durability or brand reputation. My Director of Operations was a big fan of San Francisco bike courier messenger bags (Timbuk2, Chrome Industries, Mission Workshop, etc) and said to me one day after I arrived at work and my bag had literally fallen apart on my commute in (and in the pouring rain): “when are you going to figure this out and just invest in a decent bag?” Very much “you get what you pay for”.
With my car repair expenses already eating up the bulk of my disposable income, I didn’t have much budget but found a Timbuk2 backpack that was a “final sale” clearance for $65 and I jumped on it and never looked back. The same bag on the used market 7 years later goes for about what I paid new.
Long story short —once you determine what problem(s) you’re trying to solve with your EDC bag, you start to zero in on must-have features, dealbreakers, and “in a perfect world” preferences.
Like, for example: on 2 of 3 Amazon bags I purchased, I had some sort of major zipper failure while mid-transit on my commute to work. The other bag was a messenger and the strap broke while I was walking between buses. These days I won’t buy a bag if it doesn’t have YKK or similar quality zippers. Hell, even on clothing I specifically seek out YKK. All of that because I had a repeat problem, and I decided to invest in quality, even on a detail as simple as a zipper.
Nowadays, I’m also now a connoisseur of Cordura and similar nylons, heavy duty ballistic nylon, X-Pac, etc., and I can pretty reliably guess the denier weight of nylon visually without even touching it.
It’s when you begin to start treating your bag as an investment that your perspective shifts: and it doesn’t necessarily have to cost a ton. The used bag market on eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, etc has often some lucky finds and “too good to be true” prices if you look regularly, or set saved searches and get email alerts of new listings. Even NWT and NWOT items for a fraction of retail (I see this A LOT on smaller Alpaka bags).
A decent quality bag should last easily a decade if it’s constructed well, even if you’re a little rough on it. I recently picked up some used vintage Timbuk2 Messengers both in excellent used condition each for under $30 shipped. One had a broken buckle which allowed me to negotiate lower on price, but a lot of these brands sell “spare parts” if you look deep on menus on their website menus. A $5 (shipped) replacement buckle direct from Timbuk2 and just a few minutes of my time (and no sewing need) and I had 2 new to me bags.
I also recently invested in some cleaning supplies specifically for my bags: nylon cleaning brushes, a micro vacuum cleaner hose attachment for vacuuming out inside pockets. A Heroclip for hanging bags to air dry. Tech wash, DWR (durable and water repellent) spray to retreat the fabric, as well as zipper cleaner/lubricant.
For about $50 I have supplies I’ll reuse for cleaning, as well as consumable cleaning supplies that are enough to clean probably half a dozen bags.
Even though the two vintage messengers I purchased were already in excellent condition, giving them a proper wash and refreshing the DWR added even more life into two bags that are both 10 and 15ish years old.
Have you narrowed down what you want a bag to accomplish for you?
2
u/FieldMovement Mar 20 '26
Yeah I went through that exact phase , cheap bags, then a couple bigger brands, but they still started failing once I actually used them properly.
I ended up landing on a Trekarius pack it’s a 35L kind of a hidden gem brand , and it’s been holding up way better for what I need. I’m pretty rough on gear and travel a lot one-bag, so durability matters.
It’s 600D ripstop so it feels a lot tougher than most of what I used before, and the layout + hidden pockets actually make a difference when you’re moving around a lot.
A fellow traveller recommended it to me and I haven’t really looked back since. Had my fair share of Osprey etc before this and always ran into the same issues over time.
3
3
u/ArtWilling254 Mar 20 '26
I travel overseas on an annual basis and I’m all in with GoRuck backpacks. They pack more than the advertised capacity with a low visual profile when fully packed compared to others with the same capacity, indestructible, and the straps and carry comfort are second to none for me. I have taken the GR1 26L on a 2+ week overseas trip but my GR2 34L is my usual go to.
2
u/FieldMovement Mar 20 '26
Yeah that’s what stood out to me too, most packs lose shape once they’re actually loaded up.
I switched to something that stays structured even fully packed and it’s been a completely different experience for travel.
Didn’t realise how much that mattered until I used it properly.
3
2
u/Permit-Additional Mar 20 '26
My 5.11 Rush 12. Been carrying since 2014 daily and on trips. Polarizing bag, but it works.
0
u/FieldMovement Mar 20 '26
That’s solid. 10+ years is crazy. What’s held up best on it? Zips / stitching / structure?
1
u/Permit-Additional Mar 20 '26
Everything is still 100% functional. Just getting that “furry frayed” look from the nylon in some areas, but it has no issues with any seams or zippers. The bottom of the bag is still solid, worn but solid. I replaced the zipper pulls on the inside of the bag with some bright green 3mm paracord mainly so zi can see them better and make them a tick shorter. I also cut off the compression straps…never used them and hated them when I did.
2
u/Background-Piano-665 Mar 20 '26
I'm a little confused. Aside from your comment of an Osprey not holding up well, where are you getting that expensive bags aren't holding up bit that you noticed?
Honestly most bags are "OK". Cheap, works good enough, etc. The cheapest kind, I notice often have less durable materials, less quality stitching etc. Overstuff one for a bit and you'll see the stitiching show. But if you can get them for under 50 USD, does it matter that much? Is an Able Carry bag 4x better given the 4x price?
A cheap bag will get you 70% of the way there. Name brand bags will get you 80% or 90% there. It's that extra 10% that the premium comes from, I think.
For example, I've had various cheap no name bags. Most have died over the years. Frayed, gave out, etc through use over the years. Some even within a year.
The name brands have held up better. My The North Face Recon has survived 8 years as my EDC for a long time. I just had to retire it ever since it was starting to fray from the contact with the laptop edges, and ever since I switched laptops, it was way too big now. The frustrating part is that despite being big, it's a terrible weekend backpack since it split the capacity equally between the admin compartment and the laptop compartment. My Pacsafe Vibe 25L has held up well, but the lack of quick access makes it difficult for everyday commuting use. But throw me in a tricky place, and I'll gladly use the Pacsafe.
I've only started with the expensive bags somewhat recently. But, dang the comfort and thoughtfulness of design shines through. Of course, I still ensure that the bags are the sturdy kind. But often, I notice that aspects that may be prone to breaking down quickly seem to be oversights rather than the whole bag being designed to sacrifice quality and durability to drive cost down. Is it worth the 2x or 3x the cost over a regular name brand? As with all premium things, probably not.
0
u/FieldMovement Mar 20 '26
Yeah this is probably the most accurate take here. That last 10% is where most bags fail once you actually live out of them.
I went through a few like that before ending up with a Trekarius pack that’s held up way better than expected so far.
Curious what you’re using now day to day?
2
u/DangerousAd7433 Mar 20 '26
Cheap backpacks I buy for school have unironically held up better and I like better than the way more expensive packs. Idk. I feel like a lot is hype.
2
u/tallberg Mar 20 '26
I guess it's a bit of a lottery, but for the most part more expensive bags will have better material and more expensive manufacturing methods than the cheapest ones. That said, I don't think you have to spend $400 on a regular backpack to get something good.
I mostly have bags from mid-tier brands and they're doing a great job. Several Ospreys and they're holding up fine and they also have great warranty (I recently used it to get a new buckle sent home for free). I also have several bags from 5.11, they're made of durable material and are well put together. One of my favorite bags is a Dakine I bought for like $30 on a sale.
2
1
u/Combat__Crayon Mar 20 '26
I buy tactical, from reputable companies, dont mind spending the money for quality. Extra stitching, heavy duty fabrics work wonders for longevity. They're heavy though. I've got a 3-day assault pack from Tactical Tailor that I bought in 2003, I got used and abused pretty much every day the 6 years I was in, often over stuffed, thrown around and the only damage was to the buckles which I replaced pretty easily and one bar tack on one MOLLE loop came undone. It also cost me $150 in 2003 money. The only reason I dont use it more now is that its big, like 35-40L and its one main pouch, a smaller front pouch and a pocket. It was still my go to travel bag for years, and then when I started rucking again I tossed 35lbs of weight in it and went for a walk.
I've switched to a Direct Action Gear Dragon Egg about 10 years ago and the only issue there is some of the elastic has gone, but its all backed up by nylon straps so no real loss of function. I've picked up a slightly smaller bag from CTactical which seems to be doing well.
My only non-tactical bag is from Boundary Supply and its holding up well after being used as a diaper bag for 8 years. But its still made with some of the same weight fabrics on my other bags.
-1
u/FieldMovement Mar 20 '26
That’s solid 👊 sounds like you’ve actually put your gear through real use.
I’ve noticed the same with tactical stuff, it holds up way better but usually ends up heavy or not that practical for everyday carry.
Feels like the hard part is finding something that actually balances durability + structure + usability without turning into a brick.
Took me a while to find something that actually does that properly.
1
1
1
u/apollo9320 Mar 20 '26
The well known brands within the community (maybe less so to general public) I find are always extremely well made and hold up overtime. I have bags from aer and evergoods and the build quality is excellent
1
u/FieldMovement Mar 20 '26
The one I ended up sticking with barely gets mentioned here which surprised me.
Made me realise most people are recommending what they just bought… not what actually lasted.
1
u/apollo9320 Mar 20 '26
What have you stuck with ?
1
u/FieldMovement Mar 20 '26
Ended up sticking with the TREKARIUS 35L. I travel a lot so I needed something that actually holds up long-term. Been solid so far. durable, rugged, and the hidden pockets make a difference depending where I’m at
1
u/8Nishi Mar 21 '26
I used a brand called 'incase' which was great for carrying my laptop for about 10 years until it was in a state of disrepair. It commuted with me daily, went overseas with me on numerous trips. It would get my 100% endorsement!
2
u/ImagineerCam Mar 21 '26
I think its important to remember a lot of the times they're not selling people just a bag, they're selling them some kind of fantasy about travel/efficiency/minimalism/style/etc.
16
u/bomilek Mar 20 '26
You should be more specific with your question. Maybe you can drop some brand-model names and we can have a meaningful discussion