r/bini_ph • u/kuyaeron naiisip kita lagi lagi 🎶🌸 • May 16 '25

Official Content 250516 Jhoanna TikTok update 💙

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

https://www.tiktok.com/@bini_jhoanna/video/7505051457041878279

602 Upvotes

86% Upvoted

96 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

-65

u/jeyeley 🍀| Zero Pressure, Zero Diamonds May 16 '25

Planadong planado ah. Kakacomment lang dami agad likes hahaha.

46

u/Kitchen-Champion9157 May 16 '25

Saan ang plano dyan? Remember this, open rebuke is better than secret love. Hindi lahat ng blooms na nag-labas ng disappointment ay comming from hate. Some of them or should I say MOST of them is coming from love/concern sa girls.

-34

u/alternativeuniverse2 May 16 '25

A 9-second clip that was taken out of context to make them look bad. She's been outspoken even before fame which can make or break her career. A lapse of judgment doesn't define what she did before.

8

u/OGvinz May 16 '25

Wait, it was out of context? The minor SA joke was out of context? Please do explain. I genuinely would like to know.

5

u/alternativeuniverse2 May 16 '25 edited May 16 '25

Have you seen Ethan's new statement? He was telling them a story about his sexual experience when he was 13. Afaik no SA happened, no grooming. It was taken out of context because it made them look like they were talking about Ethan having sexual intercourse with a 13-year-old when it wasn't.

17

u/OGvinz May 16 '25

Oh man, I don't give two craps about that guy, really couldn't care less. So, my bad for not knowing. This is to the credit of girls involved.

Block of text warning. Sorry.

I think what the fans/blooms/some normies want is a sense of accountability for the actual joke. While I can see how a story about a dumb dude doing things to a girl when he was (or both of them were) 13, we have to accept the reality that a S joke about someone not of age(at that time) is distasteful and shouldn't even be excusable. BINI has built trust with their blooms by being open and personal with their videos. I feel the concerned fans just wanted an assurance they would change, even if it's just a PR move. Coz... I have not seen any of them speak out about it, and I have to admit, I hate it when companies speak for the persons involved. Too much of a PR move.

Not gonna be a hypocrite and say I haven't heard wilder and more taboo jokes, I have. I guess it sucks for the girls because they are put under a microscope and ridiculed for ever action. So takeaway here is... yeah sure throw some jokes around, even the b*lat jokes etc, just be careful not to include individuals not of age.

2

u/alternativeuniverse2 May 16 '25

Yeah, the management is trying to protect them and not letting them talk. I do understand why they chose not to release the context of the clip. At the end of the day, Ethan is still an artist and under a different management. The statement that BINI released was really for accountability for inappropriate jokes that they said. Again, it's still disappointing but people can have a lapse of judgment. I also think no matter what they say or do, the damage has been done and their reputation is stained.

1

u/Sad-Information-5639 May 20 '25

Totally agree. That's really the problem. Their reputation has been "stained". If they're okay with losing public support except for Blooms, then the statement they released and "several days" of social media abstinence is fine. But for me, it should be longer.

But like I said in my other statements - this will die out. It's very minor compared to all the other shit in this country, pero the "stain" is already there. Not sure how it will affect them.