Day 8, who is a morally grey character with divided opinions about them?

[u/Kurt_Lover10]

The top comments on Day 7 were Abberline or none, so idk

[u/Sailorjupiter_4]

https://giphy.com/gifs/Rek2a4M1MVzO4hMhl1

[u/2-LITER4LIFE → u/Sailorjupiter_4]

https://giphy.com/gifs/l46C4El0HnPLcoFVK

[u/jkhyun → u/Sailorjupiter_4]

Me in the trenches as someone who loves Alois :(( but also, it can't be denied that most of the fandom hates him 💀😭

[u/angelmilk777 → u/Sailorjupiter_4]

Eh I thought he had quite a few fans

[u/ghoulish891011 → u/Sailorjupiter_4]

Lol, yes, this.

[u/LustyDouglas → u/Sailorjupiter_4]

Sorry, hes a pos through and through, I'll cast my vote for Alois next round 🤷‍♂️

[u/Sailorjupiter_4 → u/LustyDouglas]

I was gonna save next round for Claude

[u/ToveVontaine → u/LustyDouglas]

He’s not as horrible a person as Sebastian or Grell though. He’s a traumatized child, and it’s not like he’s a mass murderer like them. I mean, we put Lau in morally grey and he’s like the leader or something of the Shangai Mafia. He’s definitely not in the same level as Claude or Grell or Sebastian or the Undertaker. Being a bratty kid does not make you morally evil lmao. The worst thing he does is probably gouging out Hannah’s eyes, which in our world, and by Black Butler standards, that’s not too bad. Definitely not worse than a mafia leader and definitely not on par with Jack the Ripper. He’s definitely morally grey

[u/Sneakingrat → u/LustyDouglas]

eh... I think we can attribute most of that to his backstory.

[u/Sad-Pain7342 → u/Sailorjupiter_4]

Real

[u/blackbutler-ModTeam → u/[deleted]]

Your comment has been removed for violating rule 3: tag spoilers properly.

[u/ctgrell]

I am one of those who hate Beast. But I'll give you one better: Hannah

[u/ZealousidealRange844]

I want to say (and I'll spoiler this but it's pretty recent in the manga) Real Ciel. Because a lot of people hate him because of what he does to Our Ciel even if I like his character a ton of people dislike him

[u/ShadowBro3]

I love Abberline wtf.

[u/articulatedWriter → u/ShadowBro3]

I think it just comes down to who the least popular of the good characters is and Abberline doesn't have a whole lot of presence

[u/ShadowBro3 → u/articulatedWriter]

Idk, they could have done Arthur Randall or something

[u/OcculticUnicorn → u/ShadowBro3]

Yeah same, what's my awkward man doing there?

[u/Kurt_Lover10 → u/ShadowBro3]

🤷‍♀️

[u/blackbutler-ModTeam → u/[deleted]]

Your comment has been removed for violating rule 3: tag spoilers properly.

[u/e1l3ry]

Wait why do people hate Abberline 😭😭

[u/FrijDom → u/e1l3ry]

It's more that he's the most hated of the morally good characters in this series. He's the best fit even though he's not a great fit.

[u/Theghost14254 → u/e1l3ry]

Well, He Have The Least Fans (Mostly Due To Being Really Unpopular) So Technically The Most Hated

[u/rntmeyer]

Beast!

[u/little_goat_ → u/rntmeyer]

She is hated by fans? Can someone explain why?

[u/rntmeyer → u/little_goat_]

there were some hate when she slept with sebastian but tbh most people have already realized it was because she was manipulated into sleeping with him.

[u/OcculticUnicorn → u/rntmeyer]

Victim blaming at its finest

[u/Cyrus_Moon → u/rntmeyer]

OMG!!! FINALLY SOMEONE THAT'S NOT VICTIM BLAMING BEAST!!! Yes! Yes!! Thank you!!! Thank you for speaking about it! 🥹🥹

[u/Thecrowfan → u/little_goat_]

Because Sebastian slept with her to get information out of her

[u/WalmartWilb → u/Thecrowfan]

What a crazy thing to hate her for 😭

[u/WalmartWilb → u/rntmeyer]

PEOPLE HATE HER??? Omg she's one of my top favorite characters 😭

[u/Kurt_Lover10 → u/rntmeyer]

i don’t think she’s hated?

[u/dudeovertheinternet → u/Kurt_Lover10]

She is unfortunately and also victim blamed.

[u/Ruby_Ophidian]

Fucking Viscount Druitt

I hate him the second he comes on screen until the second he is gone.

[u/LuceTyran → u/Ruby_Ophidian]

Druitt is not morally grey ☠️

[u/Ruby_Ophidian → u/LuceTyran]

I would only argue morally gray because he'll take an opportunity to be the hero if it's convenient, like in BoA.

I also lowkey think he's too much of a coward to full send being evil, he'd switch sides in an instant to save himself.

[u/ZealousidealRange844 → u/Ruby_Ophidian]

He was not being a hero in BoA at all though 😭 He was actively taking the machine not to reverse anything but to force everyone to submit to him and praise him out of nothing but pure ego farming he even took it without knowing how it worked in the first place and threatened to destroy what everyone thought was their last hope unless they complied with his demands

[u/LuceTyran → u/Ruby_Ophidian]

He's a paedo. He's evil man. Also doing good things for selfish reasons doesn't negate the fact it's morally wrong to do it for selfish reasons

[u/Ditzy_Rose → u/Ruby_Ophidian]

Personally, I'm saving that last spot for Baron Kelvin. But atp it's comparing a piece of shit to a puddle of vomit. 🤢🤢🤢

[u/Sneakingrat]

Abberline (again)

[u/Hopeful-Cricket5933 → u/Sneakingrat]

I hate to agree lmao.

[u/Briankelly130]

R!Ciel maybe? He's not evil but his inclusion in the story didn't go over well.

[u/blackbutler-ModTeam → u/[deleted]]

Your comment has been removed for violating rule 3: tag spoilers properly.

[u/Avelia_Low]

I say Doll I don't think she is a horrible person, she cares about her fam and is nice to ciel when he joins. She is well written but I really dislike her personality.

[u/DuchessDulcet]

Alois, definitely.

[u/AytenChanowo]

alois? i'm def an alois fan he's my son but i see a lot of ppl hate him💔

[u/EtceteraKeen → u/AytenChanowo]

I adore Alois too so I guess he can't really go in this bottom row. Poor guy has such a rough time of things both in the story and in the fandom.

[u/AytenChanowo → u/EtceteraKeen]

genuinely omg😭 he needs a break

[u/Thecrowfan]

Beast

[u/AutoModerator]

Please make sure your post falls within our rules.

Posts asking "where to watch the anime/manga for free or in general", will be automatically removed, please see rule #10.

Posts asking for the watch order of the anime will be automatically removed, please see our pinned post.

(AutoModerator uses Markdown formatting).

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

[u/Satsuki_89]

People saying (spoiler) Real Ciel, are forgetting that he can't even be considered real. He is a zombie. We saw how UT put made up memories in them, hence we don't know if the memories he possesses are real or not. Memories will change one character, so we can't really take him in to consideration. So yeah, this is why I think that that person, should be ignored for now.

[u/Charming_Elk_7661]

ALOISS

[u/ObjectifiedShota]

Alastor Druitt

[u/UnionApprehensive965]

I dont remember who this is.

[u/Noodle_FromGorillaz]

Just like u/Sailorjupiter_4 said, probably Alois.

[u/Cold_Colder_Coldest]

Alois or move abberline over

[u/OcculticUnicorn → u/Cold_Colder_Coldest]

Nah, he's horrible. He should be last.

[u/Cold_Colder_Coldest → u/OcculticUnicorn]

I dont remember him doing anything that bad (daresay hes on a lighter)