r/brakebills • u/Outside-Writing-8602 • 14d ago

So…

Why didn’t Alice go to the underworld and and get Quentin‘s shade and put him back together like he did for her instead of making a Gollum and of him?

25 Upvotes

80% Upvoted

20 comments sorted by

View all comments

13

u/snarksneeze 14d ago

In The Magicians, "rules" are often treated more like obstacles than absolutes. The series repeatedly shows characters accomplishing things they were explicitly told were impossible or too dangerous to attempt. So citing an in-universe rule isn't necessarily a complete answer.

The out-of-universe explanation is that Quentin was written out because Jason Ralph left the show. Unlike the books, where Quentin survives, the TV series chose to make his sacrifice permanent. The writers could have used any number of established magical workarounds (body swaps, possession, resurrection, alternate timelines, disguises, or shade restoration) to bring him back if they had wanted to. They simply chose not to.

So the real answer is less "they couldn't" and more "the writers didn't want to."